Bizzarro Pizza Suntree

Who knew? A true pizzeria next to a gas station, well believe it. A real New York style pizzeria. Delicious home made pizzas or choose from several selections available by the slice. My favorite is a white pizza with fresh buffalo mozzarella, garlic and basil. One slice is equal to two slices served in most places. My husband loves the meat lovers pie. The garlic knots and homemade Cannoli are fabulous. Prices are reasonable. Mostly carry out, they have a couple of tables to eat in but no ambiance. Love this place!

Located in the BP station the «You Ringa, we bringa» pizza shop of the space cost delivers adequate pizza at lightning speeds. The inside is New York themed, and appears to be much of a pick up location although there are a couple of seats for dining. Their salads are cheap, like the Caesar, that comes with fresh romaine and iceberg, parm, croutons, packaged dressing, and some really salty chicken obviously not made there. If you have a huge party go for the 24 inch pizza.

This place lost its lovin’ feeling, whoa that lovin’ feelin. A few years back, Bizzarro used to be the bomb dot com. Now, it’s more like a bomb. Ordered a large pie for work. The New Yorker order taker seemed to have an attitude problem. I felt like I was bothering him. Almost hung up on him. The delivery took an hour to travel like five blocks (late lunch), and our pizza was cold and very greasy. My dog seemed to like it, but that dog chews on leather. Nasty. Unimpressed. Time for some adjustments, Bizzarro. We’ll try again in a few months. I know you can do it – maybe you had a bad day.

My favorite place to get a white pizza. I always pick-​up so I cannot comment on delivery.

Pizza is very good. Did not give 5 stars because little slow to get delivered and pizza not always made the same way. Sometimes thinner than other times and sometimes more toppings than other times. But overall very good. … Oh here is a tip also. If you get the garlic knots tell them you want cheese on top. They will not tell you that you can get that way but you can.

We moved from Melbourne to suntree and had to use this bizzarros location for delivery for the first time. We ordered a pepperoni pizza and antipasto salad. The pizza was old, cold and chewey. The worst part was the salad: the cold cuts in the salad were CLEARLY GRAY AND SLIMY and the «fresh» vegetables in the salad (peppers, celery, maybe onions) were so old they appeared cooked! They were mushy and see-​through and withered. We’ve been eating bizzarros at least twice a month for four years and I can’t even think of one bad experience until we moved here. we will never eat at this suntree location again, what a disappointment.

On 12/​14/​2014 at 7:48 PM I ordered a 24″ pizza with mushrooms & pepperoni with the crust extra crispy. When I arrived to pick up the pizza, I was handed two boxes. I though okay, they were giving me two smaller pies to equal the 24″ that I ordered. I was surprised to find that the pizza in the boxes consisted of 4 individual slices per box. It looked as if they dumped any individual slices that were left over into the box. As for mushrooms and pepperoni’s they were non-​existed. Even the crust tasted old & soggy. They advertise Long Island pizza. I have had pizza from all over New York and this is anything but that. This made Papa Johns & Dominos look like gourmet. I highly recommend staying away & if someone offers you a slice, I would pass on it.

Remarkable homemade pizza’s by the pie or by the slice at a very reasonable price!
From the authentic taste to the extreme size, Bizzarro Pizza is entrenched in an Italian background.
You can buy a pizza by the slice or just snag the whole pie. Pizza by the slice is a good deal from Bizzaro. Their slices are authentic, delicious, and gigantic. One slice will feed an average person but at $ 2.50 per slice I’d recommend grabbing two. The whole Pies are sold at a very reasonable price as well.
All ingredients are freshly prepared, from the dough to the sausage! The White, Pepperoni, and Sausage are my favorite pies from the geniuses at Bizzarro. So next time you’re craving pizza in the Melbourne area, skip the chain stores and head on over to Bizzarro!

Having Italians and Sicilians in my family I know great pizza. These guys make the absolute best sicilian pie I have had outside the house. Light and airy, its a masterpiece. Their cheese and meat lovers slices are so tasty. The meatball roll is to die for. Forget the rest and go here for the best sicilian slice around.

Terrible! We ordered a Stromboli with extra meat. It was a joke. I wish I could have taken a picture so I could add it to this review. The other part of our order was Antipasto Salad with no onion. They didn’t get that right either.
There are much better places in this area

Do not let the fact that this is attached to a gas station deter you from eating a pizza here. The sauce has a great tomato taste without too much cheese on the pies. The crust is thinner on the bottom, but gives you some area to grab it too. They are cooked in a HOT oven so the crust is hot and crispy. Delicious pizza.

Good NYC style pizza that’s better than any of the chain stuff that is all over this area of Wickham. Not as good as the one over on A1A at Rt. 192.