New York Pizza

Real pizza. Ordered well done which came out perfecto. 3 XL pizzas all came out perfect.

Having lived in New York for several years, I am finding it hard to find good New York pizza in Florida. But just like its name, this place nails it. I ordered online via their Unilocal app. I added black olives, garlic, and roasted peppers on a medium pie. About 20 minutes later, my pizza was delivered on time, hot, and with the toppings perfectly added. And it was as close to New York pizza as I have had in Florida so far. The driver was friendly, and the pizza was wonderful. I think I have found my new favorite Florida pizza. Great job guys. You’re definitely on my best of Florida list.

This place is so dirty. Me and my boyfriend are sitting at one of the middle tables, it’s all sticky and looked like it hasn’t been wiped down all day. Also It took like 30 mins for two slices?! Never coming here again!

This is the only place that you can (as of now) order online using the Unilocal app that will deliver in The Viera community. The garlic wings are the bomb (hello garlic breath for hours) and the salad portions are more enough for one person to eat and just right for 2 people. The parmigiana is a little too cheesy but the service is fast and food is hot/​warm. When delivered.

Superb NY style pizza! I am a northerner, and am a huge pizza lover and this place meets my high expectations. I got a large cheese and medium pepperoni for some of the kids in the neighborhood as a way to «bribe» them into not egging and TP’ing my house this Halloween and they devoured the pies in a few seconds. I think that it worked and they will leave me alone, but I will still set up the motion detector activated paintball turrets and continue with the building of my moat (filled with cybernetic Gator/​Rob Schneider pygmies of course).
My dog even had a slice and after eating it laid down near the couch in a blissful state of satisfaction. Next time I am in, I am definitely getting the knots!

Ate here for the first time today. The knots are the best I’ve had in the Melbourne area. Very good. The kids had pizza slices and I sampled– both good. I have been finding the sauce too sweet at the other NY style pizza places around town, but the sauce here is good. The «small» calzone here is huge. It’s easily enough for 2 people and crispy crust, not chewy at all. My husband got the 4 meat stromboli and said it was great. We ended up taking a lot of it home and we’ll eat it for dinner tonight.
The place itself is very no-​frills. You can see into the kitchen from the register and it looks very clean. Prices are comparable to similar restaurants in the area. We will go back.

This is very good authentic New York style pizza. The bread knots are ridiculous and addictive. Prices are a bit high and they don’t have many specials, but it is a good product. If you are in Melbourne and want New York style Italian food… its this place or Genna’s Pizza. Both are excellent and nobody else even comes close.

I grew up in New Jersey and am used to great pizza. This place is pretty close and definitely one of the best I have found so far in Melbourne, FL. It helps that it is really close to were we live. The crust is authentic and the sauce is spot on. My son hates cheese, so we always order ½ a pizza without cheese for him. They do it with no problem. The Mon-​Tues Large pizza deal is the best and that is when we usually go.

Ok. It’s been an hour and I was told 40 minutes on a Sunday night. Still no pizza. I’ll check back after I’ve eaten it

This review is based on a delivery service, and have not been in the restaurant.
Was in town for a bad situation, My mother was in the hospital. Spent 10 days with my Dad.
Had pizza delivered one night as we were in for the evening…
Outstanding crust, and very good sauce. Ours was pepperoni, and there was plenty of it.
All pizza places shine or fail based on their crust and sauce.
New York Pizza has very good crust, and they will even make it crispy for you.(helps if you load up the toppings)
Their sauce was good the first time, and much better the second time.
I’ve found this almost always happens when you order delivery from a pizza place and find that it grows on you to the point, where you really love it. Is that because of the ease of delivery or the anticipation of the pie on it’s way.
Anyway, these were my observations, and I made that apparent when I ordered my second pizza during my 10 day stay. The guy on the phone, Chris I think, said he appreciated it very much, and to my surprise, include some free garlic knots… Very tasty.
My Dad lives there by himself now, and I will probably be moving to Melbourne in the near future…
I will keep New York Pizza on my speed dial.
Update…
Been back to Melbourne several times, and I always order pizza from them.

Friendly service, plenty of tables, excellent pies… what more do you need? When we went in on a Tuesday afternoon — they had a large cheese special for $ 7.99! Close to the Pineda causeway and US1. I’m definitely going again if I’m in the area.