Cozzy’s Place

Living locally, I have tried Cozzy’s several times hoping that I will have a positive experience but that hasn’t happened yet. Unfriendly, odd staff, atmosphere not conducive to eating on site although they do have some very tightly packed, awkwardly placed tables. My spouse has had decent slices, but their gluten free pizza was so poorly prepared I had to actually cook it myself when I got home. The crew clearly has no clue how to heat up a frozen crust, much less add ingredients to it to make a pizza out of it. For what was supposed to be a plain cheese pizza, it was an occasional splotch of sauce on top of melted, shredded mozzarella cheese on an uncooked crust. Unfortunately I didn’t open the box before I got home. I should have looked at it before I left considering my poor experience there in the past. I will never order from there again. Someone please open a decent pizzeria in Millerton! My 2 star rating is being generous.

Great place to grab a pizza! Cozzy only uses top quality ingredients, and that’s reflected in the taste! Prices though? VERY reasonable for the quality!

Pizza is great: nice thin crust, sauce is good, I like the cheese. Price for two slices and two drinks is very reasonable. We like stopping in whenever we are in the area. Parking lot to the side, very small seating area inside.

The food has become very inconsistent here. The grilled chicken is just not good. The wraps are often messy and leaky. The ingredients don’t feel like they are of the better quality. The salad dressings feel like they are just poured out of a Newman’s Own bottle. And that’s fine, but you can’t charge $ 7 – 9 for something that isn’t fresh/​made from scratch. Like a lot of pizza places that attempt to branch out and cook other things, maybe they should just stick to pizza here from now on.

Good pizza — big slices, light on the sauce, the crust is very thin and crispy but not tough at all. Different than a standard NY style crust and worth checking out if like NY style pizza.
Prices are good and the place is clean. As one of the other reviewers stated customer service is not their strong suit. Cozzy is always behind the counter his completely no nonsense attitude can turn people off.
The bottom line: Good place to grab a slice

Great food at fair prices! Can’t ask for more :)
This place is a must visit! Perfect for the entire family.

great pizza… great prices… perfect location… large pizza for $ 9 with top shelf sauce and cheese