MyYoMy! Frozen Yogurt

Self-​served yumminess custom-​made with all your favorite toppings! Easy to go a little over the top and end up with a $ 8 ice cream :-) but maybe that’s just because my eyes are larger than my stomach! Nice location near the Milwaukee riverwalk. Never disappointed with my frozen yogurt creations from My Yo My! The name says it all…

I love the yogurt and topping selection at myohmy, but I must say they consistently provide poor service and are seemingly always out of vanilla!

This place has great fro yo. It’s well managed, and clean. They used to have different sized cups which was great for portion control so I kind of miss that now that the cups are all one size. They also have less toppings then when they first opened but it’s delicious none the less.

When they first opened basically everything was delicious. I particularly like the tart flavor but now they’ve added extremely sweet and odd flavored. Also, I don’t come weekly but the last couple of times they were out of boba gels which I crave regularly. It’s disappointing because this is the closest fro yo spot. I may have to trek to Brady St.

ive since been back to this location and it was delicious! lots of topping. lots of flavors. i am in love with the orginal tart with strawberries and captain crunch.

A nice and convenient frozen yogurt place for a decent price. It’s not in a bad location either, right within the Third Ward. I like coming here in the evenings after a long day of studying, and it’s great for dates. They have outdoor seating when it’s warmer out. They have lots of options for toppings, although their flavors seem limited. The yogurt is made well and is self-​served. It’s a nice place for a quick frozen yogurt craving :)

Pros:
–Try as many samples as you like.
–The options available are consistent — smooth & creamy, not icy. Right now, I dig the Peppermint Stick.
–Decent toppings — fruit, some candy, cereal, nuts.
Cons:
–Not the friendliest staff on the planet. I’m usually not greeted.
–Not as large of a variety as some other local spots.
–Location can make parking a challenge during peak times.
All around, I’m happy with ³⁄₅. It’s frozen yogurt, and when I want it, I’m just fine heading here for my fix.

Not too many places where you can build your own frozen yogurt mix and you get as many free taste samplers you want. Great for the kidos for sure. However while this place meets a good standard for frozen yogurt, the price is outrageously expensive. I personally believe they charge more than a similar shop I know elsewhere.

I am a sucker for frozen yogurt and when it comes to locations MyYoMy is my absolute favorite to go to!
For MU students it is not too far at all, just in the third ward area a short walk from the Public Market. It is near the river and a bunch of awesome condos. It has outdoor seating for those warm summer/​spring/​fall days and nights with an exquisite view of the city life — cars, dogs, people, oh and the pedal tavern! Then there is indoor seating, very bright and colorful if you don’t feel like eating outside! Nice high chairs seated in front of a window or your average table and chairs for those of us who do not want to climb to get seated haha. Parking might be difficult if you’re driving though so plan accordingly. If you’re a biker then your parking spots are limitless.
Now for the yogurt. They let you sample every flavor they have as many times as you want! And I believe they cycle their yogurt flavors pretty regularly. My favorite flavors are raspberry, cheesecake, salted caramel, birthday cake, and mocha. (writing this review makes me want to go there right now!). They have a good variety of toppings, sauces (chocolate, caremel), and even cereal.
The cost is pretty reasonable and depends on how big you make your dessert. Oh yeah I forgot to mention this is completely self serve :)…which can be bad if you’re worried about diet and have no control like I do. Let your mind go crazy! If you wanted to stack all of their flavors in one cup I am sure you can get away with it! Also if you are a student you’re in luck since they give a discount with any student ID.
As I said this place is my favorite frozen yogurt place, and once you stop by you will think so too!

What’s not to love about building your own desert. Plenty of options to mix and match. Personally, I went for the roof-​of-​the-​mouth cutting captain crunch. I definitely relived a little of my childhood.
There is a nice seating area outside so you can enjoy your froyo in the sun and fresh air if wanted.
Overall the place was clean, organized and had bright colors. Don’t really have anything bad to say about it. Worth a try if you are hAngry for dessert.

Good yogurt in the third ward. All the fruit toppings was fresh and the yogurt had a creamy texture and flavor to it. Took the family here after brunch. The only drawback there was not enough indoor seating. Staff was friendly and prices were reasonable.

I’ve never had frozen yogurt before and went here to check it out n i totally fell in love. I like that they have many different flavors and even more topping. He pricing was pretty decent and it was clean and quiet wit the outside seating

What’s up MyYoMy!!! My oh my did you surprise me! Why have I been avoiding you? I thought you would be another bland TCBY throwback, but oh no, I like you much more than that. Anyone remember the non-​fat yogurt Seinfeld episode??? Well I do, and pretty much think this is way too good to be sugar/​fat free (some of the flavors). I disbelieve! I’ll keep on living in ignorance and enjoying my new little sweet treat which is unfortunately right down the street from me.

My Yo My is a fun self-​serve FroYo shop in Third Ward, although it is nothing too special. They have a wide variety of flavors, my personal favorite being the cake batter or mango sorbet, as well as countless toppings: candy, nuts, fruit, you name it. Indoor seating is very limited, but there’s plenty of tables outside on the patio. Service is always fast and friendly. They also offer discounts to students at Marquette and UWM which always sweetens the deal!

What’s not to love about fro yo, yo? it’s FRO YO.
The place: nothing really special on the inside– not as much whimsy as you’ll find at yo mama’s but why do you need fancy decorations to go with your $ 3 fro yo? I personally do not.
The taste: free samples, obvi, sometimes are a must, even though it’s really hard to get taste size portions out of the spout into the little cups they provide on the left wall. They have the classic original tart (for you health nuts out there), but when I was there, I tasted espresso, cake batter, apple sorbet… And I want to say dulce de leche. Lots of toppings too — you want maraschino cherries, kiwi, cookie dough bites? Help yourself.
My face: happy.happy.happy as if I’m in a room without a roof… And not just because I sat on the front patio while enjoying my fro yo. I bought mine and my friend’s and it was less than $ 8. And de-​lish.

The new trend in FroYo is self-​serve, where you start with a bowl (or bucket or vat), fill it with as much frozen yogurt as you like and then top it off with whatever toppings you want to have. All to your heart’s content.
With ten individual and five swirl flavors to choose from, it can be a bit overwhelming. Add to that a half dozen fresh and frozen fruit choices and a dozen dry toppings such as M&M’s and breakfast cereals and nuts.
At the end of this sits a small scale to take measure of your choices. Reasonable or gluttonous?
You can’t complain — you did it to yourself!

(I feel like I shouldn’t actually be reviewing this store as my brother is the general manager at one of the yo mama’s. I feel like I’m cheating on my family a lil bit! Don’t tell him I went here!!)
MyYoMy! is the closest yogurt shop to my neck of the woods and I have enjoyed it every time! Their yogurt flavors are always creative and the flavors are spot on! The flavors are so good on their own, that now I barely even put toppings on mine! I stopped in last week and blended pistachio and white chocolate macadamia nut and it was pure bliss!
The employees have always been super pleasant whenever I’ve come, and the store is ridiculously clean. So clean, that if I dropped my yogurt on the floor I may consider eating it. Its that good, and the store is that clean.
The only down side is the awful parking/​traffic situation, but other than that, MyYoMy is my (second) favorite yogurt shop in Milwaukee!

Descriptive phrase: insert-​generic-​froyo-​place-​here.
Frozen yogurt places are a dime a dozen nowadays, with MyYoMy! not breaking any mold of the fad.
Came here after a show at the Next Act Theatre down the street. Luckily I walked because there is zero parking. Got in around 9:50 when they closed at 10, and while they did push us out fairly quickly they were nice enough to let us get our froyo first.
The inside is a pretty stark and bare design, with splashes of color trying to warm up and area that’s much to chilly. There’s no explanation of what to do, but I’m an old pro by now; grab a cup and start pouring. The $ 0.45/oz is pretty standard nowadays. Their flavor options were pretty limited, with dulce de leche being the most exotic. I had the Irish Mint and Vanilla, with brownie bits on top. The brownie bits were gross, gritty balls of fake-​tasting chocolate. While they do have other options, including cereal, none of it looked that appetizing except some raspberries.
We sat outside on a really nice patio area. Luckily they did have one outdoor garbage can since the inside had already closed.
Overall, MyYoMy! offered nothing new in terms of froyo experience, and barely passed in the generic necessities involved with such a business.

I had so much froyo I’m gonna pass the flip out. Nothing can make you feel this sinful and gratified and still be legal. If required, Regina and I will be here everyday to make sure this stays open.
PS we have filled and used three loyalty cards come on myyomy when wi you open a premium account for us

Overall good experience. A variety of flavors and toppings. Prices equivalent to other frozen yogurt joints in the area. Easily 4 stars on taste. Why 3 stars then on my review? I have the following suggestions to make this a 4 star place:
# 1 — get sample cups!!! How will I know what I want to buy a boat-​full of if I can’t taste it? Because of no sample cups, I stuck with regular flavors (and yea, I had to dip my finger in my cup to see if I liked it or now). SAD. Because some of the flavors sounded interesting but I wasn’t wiling to buy before I got to try. I know there are some who might abuse the samples, but I put my money on there being more satisfied customers due to sample cups
# 2 — they have got to change the shape of the frozen yogurt globs coming out of the tubes. What would you least like associated with your food? Yep, that’s what it looks like!
Step it up, MyYoMy! and I will amend my review!