Lexington Square Cafe

This was a perfectly adequate experience. Props for honoring the reservation. We got there at 7:30pm for our reservation and they sat us right away even though the place was very busy. Thank you for that. The service from the wait staff was friendly and prompt. The food was fine. Tasted good but generally unremarkable. If dinner all in was $ 80 I would say, yes I’ll go back. But this was more like $ 140 after gratuity, and too me, it better be exceptional as there are too many other restaurants that I’d prefer to go to for much less. My wife and I each had one drink (mine a beer), shared an appetizer (large portion), two entrees (mine a pasta), shared dessert with two espressos (served luke warm). Everything was fine, but I want to walk away from an expensive restaurant saying, wow. This was ok.

Had a very good night tonight. Had to wait a little long for our reservation on a busy Saturday night, but was compensated with a complimentary appetizer. The food was excellent! Fresh. Finely prepared. Spot on with the taste sought after. Service was excellent. Definitely recommend a trip to Mt. Kisco.

Hopefully our first visit will not be our last. The Calamari was very good as was the Lobster Bisque. The wife had Crabcakes from the Specials menu and I had the Steak & Frites. Neither was as good as the appetizer and soup. But we will go back and give Lexington Square another chance. Service was very good, all in all it was an enjoyable evening.

This is a great place in Mount Kisco right by Dunkin Donuts and Mrs. Greens to celebrate special occasions or just grab a nice (but slightly pricey!) meal.
I’ve celebrated both my own and my brother’s graduation and my brother’s bar mitzvah at Lexington Square. The staff here is accommodating of big parties on special occasions (we were even able to rent the entire restaurant out on one occasion!) They also make beautiful and delicious cakes, so ask about custom cake options if you do decide to host a party here.
The ambiance is slightly dressier — I would opt for a collared shirt for men and a dress or a nice skirt for women. The food lives up to the dressy atmosphere — things are a bit pricier, with items like penne with lobster and filet mignon appearing on the menu. However, everything is delicious and worth the price every once in a while. I don’t recommend making this your weekly dinner spot, but come here for a date night or a special celebration and you’ll be happy you splurged.
Surprisingly, this is also a fun place to catch a game. The bar is huge and they have plenty of TVs to put on your favorite team. I personally love their cranberry vodka’s

Excellent quaint Americana fare! Good quality wonderful service!

We have dined here many times. Parking can be difficult at dinner time but, in a pinch, you can park across the street (be careful crossing). The steps to the restaurant are steep and in poor repair. When one enters one is greeted with attractive pastries. Service is usually good and the wait staff is friendly. If you order correctly, the food is uniformly good to very good. Prices are a tad high. Over all, a good restaurant.

A consistently good place for dinner. Good specials and friendly service. My one criticism: the acoustics. When it’s filled, it’s hard to hear what your dinner mates are saying.

Been going here for brunch for the past six months. I’m writing this review now because we were away and we tried having brunch in SC last week. I hate to say but it was a joke. They have no clue down there. Anyway we just got home at 2 Am. And guess we’re we are going !!! That’s right Lex. This place has always been on point. The manager is great and so is the staff. Food is amazing. Can’t wait to get there. See Ya

Decent for a party. Staff were attentive but long waits in between courses and skimpy portions. Food was good from what I did have.

After all these years in town, this place still has it together! My date and I had the most amazing evening there. From beginning to end, everything that was put down on our table, was perfection. I would recommend this place to anyone.

This place is great. The wait staff couldn’t be better. The food is always consistent and delicious. And the changing selection of oysters is by far the best in the area. I am very picky when it comes to restaurants and I love this place.

I go to the café often every time I go there I get great service and the food is very good as usual, the décor is very nice as well a must check out !.

Disappointed. This place could be a nice spot. I ordered the French onion soup it was nothing special. As an entrée I ordered the angus burger and my girlfriend ordered the filet Mignon wrap. The burger was extremely under seasoned and it came out on an English muffin. It was room temperature to warm at best. The filet Mignon was dry, tasteless and cold. Our waiter was nice and friendly just wish the food was better.

Service was impeccable. Attentive, polite, and on point! The arugula salad was under dressed and there was only one teensy slice of kalamata olive and one teensy chunk of Parmesan. It was wack. The penne a la vodka was also under sauced and slightly Bland. Scallops were cooked perfect! Cheesecake was to die for. If you’re around the area it’s worth checking out

I dine here frequently. The staff can tell you exactly how the foods are prepared and they are friendly. The bus staff will make sure your table is cleared and your water glass is full. This is the bare minimum we should want. but there’s more. This restaurant offers high quality food. I think they use fine ingredients and prepare each dish with precision. The flavors intentionally meld perfectly. Loved my steak, scallops and salad. My sister loved her tacos.
Thank you for always being consistently great!

I ate here for dinner last night, because I wanted a nice light dinner and I know that they have good seafood here.
I shared the crab cakes and fried calamari for apps, they were both good. I really enjoyed the crab cakes, esp. the corn and mango salsa.
I got the asiago flat bread for my main entrée because I wanted something small. It was pretty good, but there was too much balsamic vinegar and not enough fig marmalade. Also the crust was kinda soggy, but overall it was decent.
The other people I was with got the Parmesan encrusted sole, and a grilled branzino. Those were both really good! I think next time I would get a fish entrée, since it is what they specialize in.

Blah!
The following words are all my opinion and not intended to express anything beyond that based on personal experience:
The restaurant was not crowded Tuesday 4 March 2014 night. Non-​existent happy hour specials. Overrated. Expensive. Poor Service.

I went there last week for a business lunch, and was extremely happy with my meal and the entire experience. I had been there before and always enjoyed it, but was a bit nervous because of all of the recent negative reviews.
My associate got the chopped salad, which was the perfect lunch portion and very good. I got the tuna tacos, and they were absolutely delicious. Our server, Christian, made sure everything was perfect for us. We ordered a dessert sampler, which wasn’t supposed to include the one dessert I really wanted. So what did he do? He had the chef put it on for us!
I will definitely go there again. The menu is very broad and has something for everybody.

It’s no surprise when you find an upscale restaurant seemingly in the middle of nowhere, that it’s going to be THE place to be. And unfortunately, this usually means they don’t have to excel in terms of the food, because they’re going to pack the house with locals regardless.
Such is the case of the Lexington Square Café.
Change the sign outside to «Houlihan’s» and you might not know the difference, at least in terms of the food. The ambiance however, is very nice. It’s actually a beautiful, welcoming interior, if a little crowded. Enjoy the dimly-​lit long bar and sip an overpriced cocktail while you wait to be sat late for the reservation you made for earlier. But who really cares? Especially when the bartender brings out a plate of free appetizers and tells you they are a new «test item» — fried chicken wings stuffed with garlic mashed potatoes. (Right? This makes no sense.) These greasy little wingdings were tasty, but odd. They were, literally, chicken wings with mashed potatoes somehow balled up inside them. But hey, they were free. (Which is about what I would pay for them.)
We finally sat for dinner and were greeted with a menu that was clearly suffering from multiple personality disorder. It’s never a good sign when a restaurant like this sells SO MANY different types of food — from pizzas, to sandwiches, to grilled fish and steaks, to Asian, Cajun, Mexican entrees. Restaurants with endless food options remind me of mediocre places like the Cheesecake Factory — a jack of all trades, but a master of none.
In the end we shared some lobster dumplings (meh) and Asian lettuce wraps that P.F. Chang himself would have laughed at. I tried a skirt steak chimichurri, which again was on par with a steak you might get at Chili’s. And whatever else everyone at the able ordered was completely forgettable. So not worth the money.
All of this could have been forgiven for a fun night out catching up with friends we hadn’t seen for a long time. But then we get the bill. And on the bill were two Grey Goose martinis that we didn’t order. We kindly asked our waiter to take them off, and a few minutes later, the manager came over and started interrogating us as if we were lying about not having ordered the drinks. This is the kind of thing that infuriates me. We held our ground without losing our cool, and she eventually relented and took them off the bill. But this is not how you run a business. I should give you the dreaded one star, but hopefully this was just a one-​off in terms of service.
The good news is I won’t be up in Mount Kisco for a long, long time. But if I were the owners, I’d heed these reviews, get a new chef, and put together a more simple menu that you can actually execute. The place has promise, but unfortunately, the reality does not live up to it.

Had reservations for Easter brunch. I’ve been here a couple of times before and I do like this place. A nice classy setting.
The Easter brunch menu looked really good, but I felt that I had to get the ham. It was Easter after all. The ham was actually very good. It wasn’t too fatty, as it sometimes can be. It also came with brussel sprouts and mashed sweet potatoes. Everything tasted fantastic, the service was top notch, and all this while it was extremely busy.
The place is a bit expensive. If I remember correctly my ham entrée was $ 22, but I wasn’t leaving hungry and it was a special occasion. All in all a nice place get a good meal, in a nice setting.