Mellow Mushroom

I spend to this restaurant one other time in columbus. I like the one in Columbus a little bit better than this one. I happen to go here the night before Thanksgiving so it’s hard to judge how their service would be on a normal day.

This place is my favorite pizza chain! This place already got big they even have one in the Midwest now! Good atmosphere with friendly workers. This place does wonders for both tummy and soul. They even have the best veggie burger I’ve eaten called Herb. It has kale it it yet it is still yummy.

I love Mellow. Great beer selection, which makes it fun to build a flight to go along with my pizza, calzone, or salad. I know when I come here I can try great local craft beers and get a great pizza… with anchovies. You’d be amazed at the pizza places that list anchovies as a topping and when you ask for them, Whoops all out. Never happened to me at Mellow Mushroom. I appreciate that.

This Mellow Mushroom location really rocks it. I come here way more often than I should. The food (salads, subs, pizzas, pretzels, etc.) is always consistent and never disappoint.
In addition to good food this location has a lot of craft beers on draft, in bottles, and cans. They will also fill your growler for you. They are constantly changing out their drafts, so you can usually find something new on tap each week. This makes it great for their beer club that I’m a proud member of. After 100 different beers you get a really cool mug with your name (or whatever you want) on it, a t-​shirt, a free pizza, a coozie, and your name on the 100 Beer Club picture hanging in the restaurant. But why stop at 100 since there is an even cooler mug you get after 200 different beers. They even go all the way up to the prestigious 500 beer club where you are immortalized on a plaque behind the wall.
So you have kids and the beer club really isn’t for you? Well you are covered there too. Kids eat free on Monday nights at this Mellow Mushroom.
This location is also a great spot to catch you favorite team playing on one of the many televisions throughout the restaurant. They also have live music on the patio during the summer on the weekend; where they have a variety of different local musicians playing. There is also trivia and bingo year round during the week.
If all this isn’t enough, the staff at this location is SUPER! They are one of the most important reasons we keep coming back. We usually sit at the bar and are taken great care of by Molly, Erica, Stephanie, and Sarah. They are just awesome bartenders that polite, friendly, and know their stuff.
All in all, this Mellow rocks! It offers a little something for everyone.

Speciality pizza was very good. Fresh toppings good crust. The staff were very helpful and friendly. I’d visit them again.

Pricey but love love LOVE the pizza. I’m vegan and they do a great job of following instructions on specialty orders. The service is usually slow, but that’s to be expected to a certain extent in a pizza joint.
Love the outdoor seating and so do our dogs!

I’m definitely a fan. I have noticed some variation in the quality of salads, for instance, but overall, I think it is great choice for informal dining. I’m not sure I have ever had a bad wait-​person. Friendly and helpful. If you are into beer (which I’m not) they do seem to have a good selection. My last two visits (in the past 7 days) have been excellent – food and service.

I was incredibly excited to eat here. The pictures of the interior and the menu made this place seem amazing. However, my experience here was not that amazing. Yes, the atmosphere, décor, and overall theme of the restaurant is great, there were some major downfalls.
I am a vegan and I was excited to hear that this place had vegan options. However, when I asked our server about them she didn’t know about them. We finally figured out what we could order and got a large vegan pizza and a vegan calzone. When it came out, it was very underwhelming.
The pizza did not look like a large. We were told later on that it was a medium and that the gluten free crust, which was the vegan crust, only comes in a medium. The crust was also overcooked, it was crispy to say the least. The calzone was better, but the ingredients were unevenly distributed.
The one positive about this experience is the service was good and our waitress was nice and answered our questions when she could and went to management when she couldn’t.
I still have high hopes for this place and would go back. If I did, I’m pretty sure that the regular crust is vegan without the brushing of butter and sprinkle of parmesean.

Don’t eat here very often, but when I do the food is tasty and the atmosphere fun! Sometimes run out of parking space and occasionally it takes longer than average to get food, but overall a nice place to eat.