Greek’s Pizzeria

Best pizza around. Speciality pizzas are amazing! Staff is friendly and knowledgeable about area. Must visit if in Muncie. Breadsticks are to die for!###

Ordered a pizza with tomatoes on it. After waiting a long time the pizza finally came out. Pizza was inedible due to it being so watery. The waitress blamed it on me ordering tomatoes on the pizza! We left the pizza uneaten on the table and went to the Greeks on University Avenue as they always cook my tomato pizza perfectly. I would recommend driving a few minutes to the Greeks on University Avenue as they have the best location in my opinion.

A college town has to have good pizza joints, preferably with college students working there. Ask someone under 30 in Muncie where to get pizza and they will say «Greeks».
I had a small job in Muncie, and needed to buy the crew some lunch. I asked a local who had the best pizza and was directed to Greeks. Just to make sure, I asked another local and got the same answer.
There’s more than one, we found a location a few miles east of the University that was bigger than I expected. Huge round tables that seat 6 comfortably. I saw a couple with a large pepperoni pizza on their table that had so much pepperoni on it you couldn’t see the pizza. Very impressed already.
Our meals were chosen from the single page menu, pizza on one side, sandwiches on the other.
They have an interesting option on their sandwich list — anything can be made into a calzone — I think they call it a pizza stuff.

This review has been a long time coming. I’ve been to this Greek’s several times, and the service keeps getting progressively worse. Here’s the problem, they are chronically understaffed. So you’re likely going to wait, a long time, for service. Today, we waited over 15 minutes before someone even came to our table. And then another 15 minutes before we decided to get up and leave before our drinks got to us. The last time we went, my wife ordered pasta, and they came out after 35 minutes, and told her they couldn’t make the pasta because the microwave was broken! They don’t even boil their own pasta, and are unable to figure out how to make it without a microwave. If you do manage to wait long enough to get your food, it’s usually pretty good though. I will not be giving them another chance, and will be going to the one in the village in the future.

The food here is exactly like the Greeks in the Village. This is a nice space with lots of Muncie memorabilia on the walls – also some video games (though could use a better selection. There is lots of light and a tv. Would be a good alternative to b-​dubs if you want good pizza. The red checkers everywhere gives a classic pizza joint ambience.
I am a fan of the pizza – particularly the crust. Though I think that the sauce is a bit sweet. The spiciness of the sausage makes up for it though.

Garlic Bread sticks and pizza are amazing! Fast delivery!

McGalliard location. Much more seating than in the Village. No juke box. The Greek Salad uses a different kind of cheese. Worst of all – no Tootsie Rolls at the end. The pizza was just fine other than being cut a little lopsided.