Your Pie

Your Pie is one of my favorite places to go to if I want a quick bite to eat. The ordering structure is similar to Chipotle or Subway, where you walk down the line and call out which items you want added to Your Pie. Give it a chance if you want some pizza, but don’t want to wait a long time for it!

A Unilocal search for food, in between arts and crafts shopping stops, landed us here.
Craft pizzas, craft beer. Murfreesboro, meet Asheville.
While the décor is satisfactory, I felt the space a little dirty. Not the «Ew! I can’t eat here!» kind-​of-​dirty. More like, «Is the bus boy out back getting high again?» kind-​of-​dirty.
We stood in line… for a loooooong time. We were committed at that point, so we stuck through the wait. We did notice at least one employee that seemed quite stressed trying to keep everything moving. So perhaps it was abnormally busy despite the restaurant was nowhere near capacity???
I opted to build my own pizza. The construction process easy and quick; the staffer nice enough.
While my pizza queued for the brick oven, I perused the beer selection before check-​out. Sadly, so much goodness had ran dry. The cashier was super nice, apologizing they were out of so many. She kindly answered my questions about the remaining, never once seeming annoyed or trying to rush me.
We found a table with our pizza number in hand. The wait for our food was incredibly long.
It did finally arrive, and it was warm… thankfully.
I realized I had forgotten to ask for a side of ranch dressing (Yes, I’m one of «those» people.), so I went back to the check-​out counter. The cashier immediately noticed me there, and kindly grabbed me a cup of ranch.
That chick deserves a raise for her awesome multi-​tasking skills, and her superb hospitality.
Aside from the burnt edges from the brick oven, the pizza was pretty good.
I also sampled their raspberry gelato. It was surprisingly very rich and incredibly tasty.
I think I’d be willing to give this place another shot… even if for only the gelato!

Pretty good! We walked in and they took our order quickly and politely. We both ordered the combo with the 10 inch create your own pizza, salad, and soft drink. Our dinner total for two combos was $ 27 and that is too expensive for an establishment like that. The food was very good! Aside from some pink lettuce. It was great to choose my own toppings, sauce, and pizza crust!

Found this place on Unilocal,looked to be great from the reviews. When the 3 of us walked in, there was no one in line, but a larger family walked in behind us. Ordered 2 standard pizzas and a sandwich. 5:47pm. My sandwich came out in a reasonable amount of time, but I was surprised to find that is was cold when I had ordered a hot Pesto Turkey. (Not one to complain, I just went ahead and started eating.) When the young man gave me the sandwich, he confirmed that we were still waiting on the 2 pizzas (for my kids). He told me «they will be right out». A few minutes later, I see him take 2 kids pizzas to the family that had been behind us. I thought oh they’re probably just waiting to bring my kids pizza with the other one we ordered. After a while (6:13), I see that the kids are done and running around, and we still don’t have ours. I go to the counter to find out where our pizzas are, and the manager didn’t have a clue. He found out that they were never made. He just explained that he «had 2 new people working and they aren’t fully trained». Of course, that’s an annoying explanation, so I asked him when we could get them because my kids were pretty hungry at this point, and they had been waiting for about 30mins now. He refunded my money and said he would get them made and personally bring them right out. Well, one pizza came right out (which means they probably took one from someone else), but my 5yo’s cheese pizza never came. I went back to the counter and waited for about 3 minutes for the manager to get off the phone. He looked at me and said, «Can I help you?» I told him I was looking for the cheese pizza and he was surprised. He said he thought I didn’t want it. At that point I got pretty livid and reminded him of what he told me about 12 minutes prior. I also had to remind him that my older child got her pizza right away. My 5 yo came up at that point and asked when she was going to get to eat. He just apologized over and over and asked if I wanted him to make her a cheese pizza. ARE YOU KIDDING ME!!! I tried in my calmest manner to ask how long it would be before she got her pizza…“5 minutes and I will personally bring it out myself”. I reminded him again that was what he told me before, and he told me WE must have had a communication problem. I let him know that the only problem we have now is that he has now caused me to have a shitty Mother’s Day. My child got her pizza a few minutes later, and we have now been here over an hour for «fast food» pizza.

I love Your Pie! Brick oven pizza is hard to find, and this place does it perfectly! I like getting to choose exactly how I want my pizza, and their customer service is superb! Highly recommend!

Quick service. Good food. Chill atmosphere. Good for groups or parties of 2. Lots of drink options. Local brews. Perfect for a light lunch. Pizza is my new favorite in town. highly recommended.

My husband and I celebrated Pi Day here. All their pizza’s were $ 3.14. The line was almost out the door at lunch time, but it was so worth it. My husband and I both had «The Nat» pizza pie. It comes with pesto, spinach, sun dried tomatoes, chicken, mozzarella, and feta cheese. They give you the option of white, wheat, or gluten-​free crust. When I say this pizza is superb I mean I have had only one other «review worthy» pizza and this place has them beat. The staff is beyond friendly, but in a good way. The atmosphere is nice. My only complaint is that they ran out of sweet tea (after I got mine of course). I was very satisfied with their sweet tea (I am a modern day southern belle, you know we’re sweet tea snobs), so I was highly disappointed when I couldn’t get a refill.
Overall the pizza is worth the price and we’ll definitely be making trips back and not just one Pi Day. Again, the fact that they celebrate Pi Day whether it’s a promotional deal or not already gives them a plus in my book.

I really like this place. It’s completely spoiled me to other brick oven places. I travel for a living, and ever time I try some place similar in another city, I’m disappointed.

I remember Your Pie being a lot better when I first got to Murfreesboro 3 years ago. I had a pepperoni and sausage pizza, and it was really just ok. There was nothing memorable about it. Next time I will probably go with Papa John’s.
Other things about the restaurant: They do offer gelato and different craft beers. The atmosphere is very casual and the staff is really friendly. The price is ok. They charge you for a lot of ingredients if you want to create your own pizza, but if you want to try one of their speciality pizzas, they run around $ 7 — $ 8. My fiancé got their Thai pizza, and he really liked it.

Great place to get a personal pizza along with goodies such as craft beer or gelato. The crew is hip and helpful.
You can custom design your pizza or you can order one of their specials. There are many choices starting with the type of dough you want and going from there to sauces and toppings. They also have paninis and salads.
The pizzas are all thin crust and our Lineage and Ischia pizzas were both very good. The gelato dessert was a nice ending to our dinner. I don’t know why we waited so long to come here; I enjoyed it and will be back.

Excellent ingredients, Eric did an outstanding job, great personality, an overall incredible experience!!!

This is one of my favorite places in Murfreesboro. They are sensitive to food allergies and take steps to avoid cross contamination. Their gluten free pizza is actually delicious, and they have daiya cheese on their menu. I haven’t tried any of their salads or paninis. The employees are always attentive and friendly. The atmosphere is relaxed. There is plenty of seating. My kids love that they get a small cup of gelato with their kids meals (which are only $ 3 on Mondays… awesome!). They have outdoor seating available. Overall this is a great place. No complaints.

Fresh ingredients, brick oven, good pizza. Always a good pizza, always fresh! Lunch time favorite

Awesome place and great food! Quick service and friendly employees. They make the pizza dough right in front of you and you can watch them put all the ingredients on then they put it in a brick oven and you can see the pizza cooking… Highly recommend! They have gluten free crust which I tried… Very yummy!

The family and I went there not too long ago. This place is not a great value. I understand you are paying for the concept and the individuality that you get to bring to your order, but for me it is not worth it. The food was just ok. I ordered a chicken panini. It didn’t have very much flavor. My wife ordered the buffalo chicken pizza. It looked great, but again not much flavor. My wife thought it was good. The kids order cheese and pepperoni kids meal which do come with a drink and a gelato. The gelato is pretty tasty and they have a lot of flavors.

Delicious food and great service! They also serve craft beer! One of my favorite pizza places.

Interesting concept of restaurant. Make your own pizza or get a menu pizza. Either way, you can’t go wrong. Wheat & white pizza crust are both really good.
They were slammed when we walked in, but the crew worked hard and got all the pizzas made exactly right.
Great pizza, great Gelato (Maple — bacon was odd, but really good)!

I’m not usually a big pizza person,… I know, I know,. but Something about canned tomato sauces and thick crap mozzarella cheese just doesn’t do it for me.
That being said,… Your Pie isn’t your normal, everyday pepperoni pizza.
They have absolutely any type of pizza you could imagine.
I invented my own pizza I have now dubbed the «Nom City Bitch»… «Classic White» crust (Fresh), Zesty BBQ sauce, Cheddar & Feta cheese, Green olives, Chicken, Roasted garlic, bacon, and Mushrooms.
OH MY GOD ITS HEAVEN.
I eat here at least once a month– I get it to go every time though. So i can’t comment on eating in the restaurant itself, But my to go order is always ready as soon as i get there, always fresh, and always on point!
(PS– I have noticed they serve alcohol inside. So that’s a plus obviously)

Great atmosphere and solid staff. Had Laura «surprise me“for my pizza choices and she fearlessly put me together a great pie.
The gelato is very good. I got out with a great 10“pizza, drink, and gelato for about 12 $ so a good deal for the quality of food.

So let’s get some things straight. This is NOT great brick oven pizza. I feel like if I say anything too positive about this place some pizza mobster will hunt me down and force me to eat mediocre pie the rest of my life.
But here’s what it is. Good-​enough-​in-​a-​pinch if you want something to eat. You could do worse in the fast food/​sandwich category. It’s consistent, but it is the subway of pizza. And I live 2 blocks from it, so I will be settling more often than I would like in this pizza forsaken town.