St Matthew’s House Thrift Store

Absolutely the best Thriftstore anywhere. They have a Starbucks in the store. Amazing prices, great staff, fabulous selection and the best charity.

I found all sorts of treasures there. My best find was a $ 25 Fendi purse that was selling on eBay for $ 200. They have a lot of really nice looking stuff, some were even brand-​new. It’s a great place to go for work clothes and maybe get lucky and find some really nicely priced designer items.

A great place to shop. It really is organized and can find some great stuff in there

The Naples store is great. Good selection, high quality, and good prices. Always worth stopping in. Clothes and high end furniture, if you know your high end names, you can get a great deal. (If you give this place bad ratings for prices, like the one person did, then they have no idea of the quality they are buying. Most of my furniture came from stores like these, you have to know your brand names. I live in a multi-​million dollar home, so these aren’t just for the needy buying. I buy and donate.)

On my way from work I decided to stop at this thrift store to look for some blouses and summer dresses.
While they do have the usual $ 5 and $ 10 items I also saw $ 250 (Chloe) dress and $ 140 (YSL) as well as $ 170 blouses. Not believing my eyes I had to ask the sales associate if the price tag is correct.
It was.
When I said that it is a thrift store and NOT consignment store all they could say is that the items are good brands and «you know this is an upscale area».
Makes me question who exactly is it they are trying to help.
I think that their pricing of high end items is immoral.
As church organization they probably get tax breaks and free (donated) merchandise.
The lady that donated the high end clothing donated it because:
A. She did not care about selling it through consignment store.
B. Perhaps wanted low income women or fresh out of college girls to have a chance to own some nice quality clothing suitable for work.
One plus of this store is the selection and quality of furniture.

We understand it’s faith based, but the music is obsessive. Goal and mission have become very corporate and overpriced. Few bargains.

Definitely one of the busiest thrift stores I’ve seen. Neat and organized with a big selection of clothes and some furniture and accessories. Timing is everything with these types of stores however.