Caked Up Cafe

Went in the other day to pick up a couple of cupcakes for my co-​worker and myself and our experience was great. The Cupcakes were amazing and the customer service was amazing but the reason I’m giving four stars is because of the frosting. The cake itself was the moistest cake I have ever eaten but the frosting hit my sweet tooth hard I couldn’t even eat it and ended up removing half of it. Overall good cupcakes, I would just not make the frosting so overwhelming.

Denise Byrnes and family are truly amazing. I e known Denise for 18 years and when I say class act she is really one of a kind. We have used her for our son and daughter in laws baby reveal and shower and she never disappoints. The cupcakes are top of the line and the taste is something you can’t explain you need to taste. I have been truly blessed to know her and her family.

I reached out with a major cupcake dilemma– I promised my girlfriends I would bring chicken n waffle cupcakes on our memorial day weekend trip in Annapolis without checking their store hours. I had a mini heart attack thinking I couldn’t get to the store before I left for my trip so I sent them an email. Within just a few hours I got a response and they were willing to accomodate my schedule. I’m super excited that I will be able to live up to my promise while eating these delicious cupcakes. Thanks Caked Up for making my day and ensuring our girls weekend gets kicked off with a sugar high!!!

When they first opened, i was drawn in a couple of years ago by the bright pink exterior. It reminds me of a classic bakery. Anyhow, i knew i found a gem when they read me the +10 flavors of cupcakes they have. I tasted one and never looked back. Now for every special occasion my family orders cupcakes from here and before i knew it my cousins were ordering from here too. Every flavor is delicious. I haven’t tried their cakes (yet) because you need to order a little in advance– and my family always forgets to do so. However, cupcakes can be ordered the day before and they are extremely accommodating and helpful all the time. Thank you guys for helping me and my slacker family.

Caked Up made amazing cupcakes for a recent party. The staff is extremely kind and helpful. Their cupcakes always taste delicious, and I love that I was able to get gluten free cupcakes, too.

These guys are absolutely AMAZING! I ordered my daughter’s smash cake 2 months ago as I live out of state & only come home to visit family on occasions. The cake was so pretty & my daughter loved it! Half of the cake she didn’t eat, my family got to taste it & they couldn’t believe how good it tasted. I just ordered vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream in the middle with fondue on the outside to match my daughter’s theme. So pleased that I even ordered 30 cupcakes and one being texas size for her other birthday party. Thank you guys so much & I am so glad that I found this bakery :)

I’m so glad we discovered this place! The cupcakes are incredible. I haven’t tried the regular cakes, but my wife had some at a birthday party and raved about it. Everything is fresh and you can tell they take pride in their product. We are having some cupcakes for dessert tonight and I can’t stop thinking about it.

After a mix up they managed to make me a cake in an hour for my sister’s baby shower! It wasn’t the cake I originally had in mind but I think it turned out better! Although, they told me they wouldn’t be able to put the bear on top last minute and I could have cried! That was the most important part of the cake! My sister’s first baby was born premie and only lived for a day :(((and she called him Baby Bear. So I wanted the bear for her baby shower cake as a little tribute to him. When my mother got back from picking up the cake there was the bear!!! I was ecstatic and my sister loved it! Thank you so much for pulling this together so last minute and for being so helpful getting the cake and cupcakes into the car for my Mom! Oh and the cake and cupcakes were delicious!!!

Wonderful bakery with delicious cupcakes and custom themed cakes. The owners are so nice and friendly and the special order cakes are not only beautiful, but are delicious. I would highly recommend this bakery!

Brought my wife here to get birthday dessert. We ended up getting a bunch of cupcakes, more than bellies could handle, but our eyes where saying, «YES!!!» When the owner found out we there for my wife’s birthday, she gave her a free cupcake. She love it! Please try this place.

I was looking for cup cake shop near nanuet for my wife’s birthday. Came across this suggestion on Unilocal.Excellent place! Nice shop with its own parking at the back of the store (the store is not directly on the street, it’s tucked in just off the street on the right). Cup cakes on display looked fresh and there was good variety of flavors. Picked up a six pack for $ 16.50 i think (may be a dollar or two here and there, i don’t remember exactly) which i thought was a decent price. The manager/​owner whom i spoke to was very helpful, explained me all the flavors on display. Gave me details of their «made to order» cakes and the photos looked promising.
Now to the quality of cup cakes — delicious and extremely flavorful! Soft, nice filling and very good icing. My wife especially was all praises for the banana and the mocha. All flavors i picked up were extremely tasty. one of the best cupcakes i have had. Would definitely come back for more cupcakes!

omg these cupcakes are amazing! well-​priced and everything is baked fresh every morning. They were making a cake for Kevin Durant’s birthday when we were there… really cool.
Tried the breakfast and speculoos cupcakes… both were so good. Who would have thought to put a mini pancake on top of a cupcake? such creativity. wow.

Wow. Finally a bakeshop that is not so incredibly over priced, and DELICIOUS.
These are just great cupcakes. Not a ton to say otherwise! They are moist, and the icing goes great with the cake, not too overpowering. I love that at the end of the days (not sure if it is everyday) they lower the price of their cupcakes an hour before they close. We payed $ 2.00 per cupcake which i feel is like unheard of in this day and age.
They had some really fun flavors, and the man working behind the counter seemed really proud to be there. The bakery itself is a great place to eat a cupcake because it is so cute and quaint. I also know they make favors here or cater to private events. I will be sure to check them out for my wedding!

Amazing treats. Mind blowing! Seriously. No more cupcakes from the city needed.

I’m so grateful for the wonderful owner of cakes up café! I wasn’t able to make it home for a friend’s birthday but wanted to send cupcakes to her in new city. With the owner, I went through the details of the order, and he mentioned he would personally deliver the dozen cupcakes himself. I really appreciated that he asked me questions about peanut butter (peanut allergies) and if the breakfast cupcake that included bacon would be ok — my answer was: ABSOLUTELY!!! My friend absolutely LOVED the cupcakes and was able to share it with her family.
This is my new favorite gift :)
THANK YOU!

Everyone was very friendly. Cute little area to eat with three two person tables. The cupcakes were incredible. My wife and I ate our cupcakes on the spot… Too good to wait. The maple bacon cupcake had the complex flavor you would expect and was fresh and moist. My wife had a peanut butter type cupcake that was creamy and rich.

I love the cupcakes except my friend found a hair in the maple cupcake once. Haven’t been there since.
It was in January.

I have to say that I love love love Caked Up Café. This year again they did my son’s 5^th Birthday cake (Ferrari theme, pictures to follow) and they nailed it. The design, the taste, the texture. I am telling you my waistline will continue to grow should I keep eating their cake. Thank you to the Caked Up Café Family. MJ and MK love love love you guys.

And we have a new world cupcake champion! On January 3^rd Caked Up Café KOed the previous reigning champion Nora’s Cupcake company of Middletown in the first round. Some cupcakes companies charge a lot for very tasty cupcakes (Nora’s), and some places have low costs for only medium to good cupcakes. This place however solves both of those conundrums by charging little ($ 2.75 per) and delivering great cupcakes. My gf and I are kind of cupcake connoisseurs and we have tried many different places, but this place takes the cake on cupcakes.

Recently read this place opened on Patch so I had to check it out. I love smaller, single owner food establishments; always something new and inventive gets created here. Prices are great compared to competitors — $ 2.75 per cupcake and $ 16 for 6, I think.
I was pleasantly surprised at the great flavor and freshness, and cupcakes were soft! Good place to drop in and grab some dessert. Will be back!