Jersey Mike’s Subs

Ok subs that are a bit pricey for the quality. Worth going over Subway but that is not saying much.

If you’ve never had Jersey Mike’s, don’t rate it based on price if you’ve never tried it like some of the reviewers here. I first had their subs down in Point Pleasant and I am happy to report that the New Providence shop follows the formula exactly and is just as good as the shore or the Westfield shop. Yes, it’s pricey, that’s true, but you get what you pay for and that is fresh fresh fresh ingredients and wonderful buns and dressing and so good that even when you’re stuffed you’ll want more. I recommend the #2 Jersey Shore above all the others and get a giant, you won’t regret it.

The Italian sub is amazing have it mikes way and you won’t be disappointed. The cheese steak is good and the kids love the turkey much better then subway.

Way way overpriced for what you get. I went there last week to get a roast beef & provolone sub sandwich. The regular size is $ 8.25. When the man cut the bread I said to him 3 times… are you telling me that little piece of bread you cut is $ 8.25??? It was 6″ long. He replied yes & if I wanted the giant sandwich which is double the size it would be $ 15.00. I told him to forget it & walked out… I would go somewhere else. The girl at the register made a snide comment as I left. Are you kidding me??? That small 6″ sub would not even feed a 10 yr old boy let alone an adult. I would never pay $ 15 for a sub sandwich. ShopRite has 12″ subs for $ 7.99. I actually went to Copolo’s Italian Restaurant & got a huge chicken parm sandwich $ 8.00 & was stuffed. Also SubZone in Berkeley Heights has 12″ subs for $ 10 & are packed w/​meat & delicious. Up to you where you want to spend your hard earned cash.

Overpriced and not that good… My children ate here once since they’ve been open… That tells how much we liked their sandwiches… On any given Friday we’re looking for something quick to eat in the area and we always just pass by…

The sandwiches they serve are very average. However the prices they charge are a bit steep. Walk out there spending $ 16 for a soda and sandwich that’s only 1 level better then Subways

The folks working here are super friendly. The cheesesteaks are amazing — maybe not as good as ones you’ll find in Philly but for northern NJ, I think they are the best you can get! Nice to have another option besides Smashburger and Chipotle.

Jersey Mike’s has locked up a spot in New Providence next to Chipolte which opened end of April. Good for patrons but likely will eat into Subway and Main St. Deli customers. Good luck Jersey Mike’s, happy to not have to be in Pt. Pleasant Beach to get a good sub…