Slaughtered Lamb Pub

The best bar in the west village. Friendly staff, great service!!! If you are in the mood for a relaxed no hassle place to just have a few bricks or maybe a bite to eat, then look no further.

I love this place and have been coming here regularly for ten years. The bartenders (shout out to Karrie (sp?)) are awesome, and I love the dark wood /​english pub feel of the place. One thing that has stopped me from coming here a LOT this winter is the fact their fireplace is still not working. Ten years I’ve been coming here at least once a week for drinks, and now I’m only coming with my friends once every five weeks or so. The fire place is what MAKES this place a fun local spot. Hopefully the owners are working on fixing it, or realize how much it makes the bar a spot to go to???

Loved this place! Reminded me of the hole in the wall kind of place from American Werewolf in London! Check it out in Greenwich Village.

Good potential, but lots of room for improvement.
Pros: normal drinks are reasonably priced. Some food is pretty decent, like the sliders.
Cons: I swear to you, and others have confirmed that their house gin is total garbage. It tastes like plastic. Not a little bit, but like somebody melted a plastic bottle into my drink. I was there 4 months or so apart, and accidentally got their plastic variety gin and tonic. Still serving it. What the hell?
Now the food. Errm. I’ve had cafeteria food, or truck stop food that tasted better. For example there is the snack platter that consists of wings, potato skins and some other stuff. Everything was edible and did not cause consequences, but come on! Chicken wings were like the frozen welfare wings with some spicy ketchup on them. And the potato skins had those dry bacon bits from a jar. Disgusting!!! Red flakes. What the hell is this?
Advice to management: for the love of god, get rid of your plastic-​flavored gin and do something about the food!!!

The décor was pretty cool i like the dungeon look, But the Drinks were not on point. I ordered a Drink that had Gin in eat and requested Beefeater but when I received it it tasted like Fireball on ice lol I didn’t complain just laughed that they could get that wrong. The main reason I give this place one star is because it is roach infested and not just a little baby roach that I would understand being in NYC, no It was Huge the size of the palm of my hand. I got so grossed out I didn’t finish my drink and left

This place is fun for beer and getting loud with friends. The food is good for drunkchies, but that’s about it. My husband and I went there for dinner tonight because he hadn’t been and I liked the atmosphere, but I wasn’t drinking tonight so without the thin layer of buzz, the food was really disappointing. Appetizers and burgers that are pretty clearly thawed from Costco and seasoned with cheap sauces. My husband takes his burgers well-​done and his was very pink. So, if you’re in the area and you’re with friends, it’s a great atmosphere for drinking and getting rowdy (especially if you’re under 25…). The service is lousy. Our server was really distracted, inattentive, and slow. She apologized, explaining that she and the other servers were really focused on their Powerball ticket pool.
If you’re looking for a good meal, there are better places in the West Village. (Like, dozens of better places on the same block) But it’s a fun experience if your expectations are low.

If I could give 0 I would! Don’t waste your time or money. Food was mediocre at best. I mean really who the hell uses bacon bits on a potato skin? Frozen boxed mozzarella sticks, burgers burnt to a crisp and fries that had an unidentifiable taste!
Server basically could have cared less about us. Had a horrible attitude! We had to ask for menus and flag her down for orders and check. Speaking of the check I have never been to a place where you have to give your card in order to have a tab when you’re obviously ordering a meal!
Will be my first and last time here.

Drinks are gross. Like really, really, gross
Tastes like someone mixed gasoline and soap with the alcohol.
Really impossible to finish.
Also bad music

Cool place. I love the movie so was excited to visit this bar. Dingy and fitting.
Awful music, unless you like Fall Out Boy and Bön Jovi. Unfriendly bar staff, too. It doesn’t hurt to smile or reply when someone says hello. Jesus, does customer service even exist anymore?

Came into grab a few beers while watching some college football. It wasn’t that crowded and we got a seat at the bar. Bartender, while not the friendliest, was attentive the entire time. Beer selection was about average but was fairly priced (everything on draft was $ 7). I didn’t try the food but my friend had the hot wings and said they were good but incredibly hot. I bet this would be a fun place around Halloween to explore the theme a little more.

We got here early on a Saturday (like 10pm) and left around midnight or a bit later, just as they amped the music to conversation killing levels. But before the volume turned up (and a lot more people came in), it was totally fine. We scored a table in the back and had lots of drinks and it was a fun wacky place to hang out.

The food is solid with good burgers and a nice selection of tap beers plus full bar. But that’s not why I keep coming here. The décor is macabre and fun. Think An American Werewolf in London as narrated by the Crypt Keeper. You can’t help but smile as you out back a few rounds with friends. Come have fun.

Cool Name, Weak Place
The only reason this place is getting 2 stars is because of the awesome name. Went in and we were expecting this cool dive bar with friendly people. What we got was a dull atmosphere bar with slow unfriendly service and seriously overpriced drinks. 7 dollars for half flat Miller Lite draft???
With so many places to goto in the area, I can’t see any appeal for this place.
Tip:
Go across the street and have some drinks at Down the Hatch bar. Much more atmosphere some of the best deals in the city.
Thanks

I had been here YEARS and YEARS ago for a weekend lunch. Sat outside, got a good chili cheese burger, cool little themed place. Recently, I came back on a Friday night for drinks, and it felt like a completely different place.
Service (at the bar) was just okay, but the crowd and the atmosphere was a huge turnoff. I can’t pinpoint exactly what it was, but I know I couldn’t wait to finish my drink and move on. It wasn’t terribly crowded on the barside by the entrance, but all the seats were filled, the bar space was taken up, so we were just awkwardly standing at the corner of the bar. One of the few parties standing. I just felt out of place. It didn’t give me the «hey get some drinks and stay a while vibe.» I’m really disappointed in the difference from my first experience. But hey, times change.

Good goddamn, where do I start?
During the week, it’s not a bad place to meet up with someone for a drink after work. It’s usually pretty quiet, so talking’s easy. The beer is good, the service is fine, and it’s not too loud. It’s a three star bar from Monday through Thursday.
Oh but then the weekend comes, and ohhh Beware the Moon. Tried meeting up with a few friends here (5 of us in the group) and suddenly the moon was out. This bar transformed from a friendly, good time place to a RAVENOUS BEAST replete with a dumb, rude staff, gross overcharging, and cold food.
First of all, don’t bother ordering any food. It’ll take about an hour for anything more than onion rings, and even those take 45mins. And no matter what you order, I promise you, when you get it it’ll be lukewarm and undercooked. It’s amazing that they even bother stocking a kitchen.
The group of us sat in the back, which is a larger, restaurant area, next to a party of seven who were drunk off their asses at 10pm on a Friday. I mean really stumbling drunk. Breaking glasses, smacking each other around, bumping into everything — unreal. Any decent bar staff would’ve kindly moved these asshats to the exit, but no — waitress brings over another round of shots for the group along with two more pitchers. Are you kidding me? The logic, I can only suppose, was to give these goons the heftiest bill they could. (But then again, they’re notorious for overcharging, so why waste the booze? But I digress.)
It took three reminders for our waitress to bring over a single pitcher, which she overcharged us for, and an hour after attempting to order onion rings, they arrived.
When we got the bill, which was 78 bucks for 2 pitchers and onion rings, we looked at each other pretty shocked, but we laughed out loud at the 18% gratuity. Really? GTFO.
#3 Stars — base rating
+1 full bar, decent selection
+1 atmosphere — American Werewolf in London! Fireplace! Nice!
–1 credit card fraud (the people of Unilocal agree — just look around) and frivolous gratuity
–1 reprehensible staff
–1 slightly more reprehensible food
–1 the place is filthy
AVOID AT ALL COSTS. BEWARE THE MOON.

This place sucks hard. First off I walk in and see only dudes. And I think is this a gay bar? Then I realize the reason only guys are here is because the DOOR IS OPEN and its 45 degrees outside (and women are usually colder than men). It’s cold as hell in this bar. It makes literally no sense.
Second problem there’s no wifi. It’s 2015. Get with the program. I had to kill time before a movie so that was annoying.
Third problem is wine is $ 9 at a PUB. It’s a regular old pub. It should be $ 7.
Fourth problem was the weird ass crowd including a douche who talked about how much money he had and some girl who kept moving over every time I moved over.
I moved to the Four Faced Liar across the street which was warm, cozy, and had wifi.
Anyway this place is a dump and looks like a dungeon and not in a good way.

I’ve always enjoyed going to this pub. I’ve been about 5 times in my many visits to NY. Love the reference to Dr. Jekyl and Mr. Hyde, plus all of the mannequins and what not everywhere is perfect. On a busier night the downstairs area is nice — waitresses come around with shots in big plastic syringes (but you don’t get to keep them, boo). I pretty much go for the atmosphere — like any bar it’s been hit and miss depending on the night. Definitely worth a stop by though if you’re in the area. Service was always fine, but bartenders and waitresses were pretty much hired for their looks not their skills — be warned.

Came here on a Thursday night with a group of friends to get the jello syringe shots. The décor of this place is really cool and spooky and I love the large wooden tables but they were so close together which was kinda annoying.
We each bought a jello syringe shot which the waitress gave us from her boobs which was really fun and different and we ended up getting 2 rounds haha. She put the end of the syringe in her boobs and i took the shot from the other end while she pushed down on it. I could barely taste any alcohol though but the flavor of the jello was very tropical and nice. Each jello syringe shot was $ 7.
The service here was so slow. My friend got up twice to flag down our waitress who still took forever to come. Reading the other reviews, it looks like this slow service is a problem.

I don’t know why, but I sort of like this place. It’s a crazy random theme, old dirty building (which somehow meets health code), and just an all around divey atmosphere. It’s weird, probably one of the weirder places I’ve been in the village area, it actually sort of reminds me of some places in the French Quarter of New Orleans.
Don’t eat the food, just grab a beer or two, enjoy the atmosphere, and go on to your next stop.

I came in at 250 p.m. ordered pumpkin ale because Sam Adams
seasonal was not working. I also ordered Thai red curry wings which are 8 to an order. When served about 15 minutes later it had 4 wingettes
4 drumettes. They tasted more like jerk wings than Thai red curry but they still were good. I didn’t understand serving blue cheese dip with them since they were supposed to be Asian inspired. I had asked the bartender about the wings after I finished with them and she said she wasn’t surprised by my confused taste experience.