Casapulla’s Red Mill Sq Steak & Sub Shop

Having grown up and lived in Delaware my entire life, it was always a known fact in my family and circle of friends that any sandwich or sub any sub place could make could be made better at Capriotti’s. Well, I’ve got a new saying. Any sandwich or sub a sub plce can make can be made worse at Casapulla’s.
This isn’t my first time at Casapulla’s. I had a couple of items from there when I was a kid. I never liked them. This was my first time at a Casapulla’s in at least 6 or 8 years. Man the sub was awful. I got the Italian with prosciutto. The roll (the most important @#!$%*@ thing when making a sub) was soft and flavorless. The meat tasted like it was three weeks old. It gave off a sweet, tangy flavor. That description might be complimentary when describing Sour Patch Kids. Not a sub. The inside is a dump. At least the service is fast.
Why do we write Unilocal reviews? To talk about places we love. To talk about places we hate. To advise visitors to our region where to and where not to go. If you’re visiting Delaware, or if you live in DE but never been to Casapulla’s, please don’t go. Go to the Capriotti’s in the Newark Shopping Center. Go to the Capriotti’s on Union Street. Go to the one in Hockessin. Go to the one on Kirkwood Highway. Just don’t go to Casapulla’s.

This Casapullas location is absolutely gross. I ordered a chicken cheesesteak and it was the worse I ever tasted. I will never go back to this location only Elsmere.

Very disappointing, staff was unprofessional. We went in 20 minutes before closing they had already shut down the griddles and seemed very upset that we asked for steak sandwiches. The sandwiches were poorly made, because of this will not go back anytime soon.

Had a cheese steak this time. Outstanding!

I didn’t realize there was a Casapulla’s here. I stopped in with a friend for dinner. I had a turkey sub which was so yummy. I love their fresh bread. I hate when you have a sub and the bread is so hard its like you have to rip it with your teeth. But everything was really good on my sub and I know I will be going again.

Great cheese steaks. Big a**onion rings