Pie Five Pizza Co

Maddio’s is better and the same concept. When ordering, the people making the pizzas don’t seem very knowledgable or helpful if you ask questions. We have eaten here a few times but I would prefer Maddio’s over Pie 5.

Just diagnosed with sensitivity to gluten :-(
So I ventured in to see if they had a pizza for me. Yes yes and triple yes. You choose the ingredients to go on it. The Maui Wowee was great.
I will be back!

One of my new favorite places in Newnan! Love that they offer a Gluten Free crust, and it actually taste really good!

Not a great location but this place deserves to be! At first the manager seemed too forward but ultimately provided excellent customer service and gave great suggestions for the pizza creations. I loved the easy to read menu on the wall, the pizza creations all sounded great but you can build your own.
They give special attention to gluten free ($ 2 up charge) the salads look great. They have a few dessert selections as well and Honest Tea!
Great customer service. I hope it stays that way with friendly employees.

I like the concept and the pizza. What bothered me today was that they kept trying to up sell something. I already ordered salad and pizza, two different people don’t need to ask me about dessert. Also, being hit on by a staff member while trying to get a drink made me want to walk out and not come back. Good food can be absolutely ruined by poor service or behavior.

Good food, great price. Everybody can get what they want and be happy. I love this concept wth a picky eater.

Let me tell you something Pie 5 of Newnan I’m giving you 5 stars, Well deserved! I had the chance to visit the store for the first time yesterday with a couple of friends and we had a great experience. Friendly staff explaining everything from the menu and how it works. Thumbs up! I had the Carbonara+Salad+Drink for $ 10.99 and with all the toppings that you want… Dedfinenetly will be back soon with the family.

Horrible ghetto service! Out of everything on a Saturday and slowest service ever. If I was a franchisee I would sell this quickly if my managers ran this place like it is now. My wife asked if they had any more sweet tea and and the cashier said to another co worker that she should mix with sweetener. The entire staff is horrible. Pls do not waste your time at this place!

Was at Aspen Dental yesterday dental assistance told me to try this place great experience loooove my pizza my way will be returning.

This place is absolutely fantastic! Once you eat a pizza here you won’t want to try anymore other pizza places. As Jeremy says they make their pizzas with love! You can definitely tell the difference by the taste and confirm that statement. Everybody is friendly, polite and goes out of their way to make you feel at home very unusual in this day and time. From the very beginning of the line when you deal with Jeremy, all the way down to Matasha & Matarice who complete the process with putting your pizza together and adding the magic dust. Oh may I suggest you definitely add the magic dust to your pizza it is very addictive. You won’t be sorry if you just give it one bite, you will be hook!!!

Excellent attention to make sure no cross contamination when ordering gluten free crust. Massive selection of toppings. Will definitely return.

Great new pizza place. Ordering is like being at Subway… the difference being, these folks are friendly. The music was a bit loud, causing me to not be able to hear the dude making my pizza when he asked questions. A bit pricey when you are feeding a large family pizza (compared to Pizza Hut)

Not impressed. Tasteless… stingy on my veggie pizza. A nice young woman made my pizza, the cashier could careless if she waited on me or not.

Blah, our family of 7 tried it out last week. Overall price was good but the pizza is average at best. I had the deep dish style with sausage, garlic and jalapeño and it tastes like it came out of a box and been sitting to the side for 20 minutes. May have been a bad day but I have no interest in going back.

Really good pizza, great place to dine. The pizzas are single serving and will fill you up. Great atmosphere!

The review of the new Pie Five — well we walked in and of course like others have said not real specific with menu board to start off – guess it’s supposed to be like Moe’s but not really bc Moe’s is fun and quick… stood there for about 10 – 15 minutes waiting on one preparer that was talking to a friend and flirting with a customer — the line started to back up and still no concern from workers… they had at least ten workers in there and we didn’t understand what half were doing standing around just chatting… staff is either just too young and inexperienced or just plain immature… we walked out (these kids these days I guess just don’t know work ethic is all I can figure)…I am sure the people behind us left as well bc it took way too long — won’t be back to try — bad first and last impression.
Updated 9÷29÷15
I will change my review comments and overall review once we have tried this place again — I understand they are trying to get new hires trained and evaluated. The owners have contacted me and apologized for the behavior of the new hires that evening — and we will try it again and place a new review.

Board menu is non specific, it says you have 7 sauces to choose from but doesn’t tell you what they are so you’re not ready to order when you get to counter. Crust was bland, just nothing exciting about this place, even lacking enough preparers both times we’ve been there so customers had to wait while management interviewed new hires. Tried it twice, we’re done.

Came here on two separate occasions both were great experiences. The ordering line is similar to a chipotle, however the giant menu on the wall only had signature pizzas. To see the full menu with a full list of items you can combine you have to grab one of the smaller menus at the front of the ordering counter. Many patrons were unaware they even had these so they might want to think about placing it in a more visible area.
The staff is friendly, knowledgeable and ready for any type of request. There are a various amount of fresh dough, sauce, and toppings you can choose from. If you’re in a hurry just pick one of the signature dishes and you’re out the door in 5min. Overall every component of the pizza was very tasty and the price point was about average. Will be returning soon.

Excellent pies.
You select the pizza you want and it is made for you.
Various toppings and crust.
Only negative is the volume of music. A little loud.
Staff is very attentive.
Will return next time I am in the area.
Please open stores in Atlanta
Thanks

Fast food personal pizzas, what a concept! I love this place already. The concept reminds me of a more upscale Moe’s but instead of tacos and burritos they’re serving up 10″ personal pan pizzas with 4 different options for crust including wheat and gluten free! The ingredients are fresh, the staff was friendly, and they offer a very contemporary atmosphere. Satisfy your sweet tooth with delectable dessert options as well.