Cobblestone Pizza

Good food, awesome service, nice atmosphere, reasonable prices. Careful not to over-​order, a mistake we made.
Also, they lose a star because of their huge salads, which are impossible to finish if you ordered a pizza along with it. And their Greek salad had some curious items in it, like baby carrots.

I really wanted to like this place. The other reviews are stellar so please keep in mind I might have just hit them on a bad day. My $ 25 was a total waste and I’d rather have my money back than have had what I got.
I came in at 9 on a Saturday. There was one table already eating, and three staff that I could see and no other customers. They said it would be 15 – 20 minutes for the pizza. Great It was 40. That was awkward. A guy came in to pick up a to go order and his wasn’t ready when it was promised, either.
I ordered an artichoke and olive topped pizza, plus their cinnamon bites. I expected it to be divine. That pizza combo usually is. Then again, usually there isn’t a tinny taste to the toppings or a whole can of wet sliced olives tossed on. I ate one slice. I offered the rest to my travel companion. He took a bite and passed on it as well.
The cinnamon bites would probably be great fully cooked. These had raw centers. You can see in the pic they are actually shiny, as moist dough is but fully baked dough is not. I ate the outer bits and that was good, but meant I got about ¹⁄₃ what I paid for, plus a mess.
I hate to toss out food so I feed the crows. They loved it.
I would’ve preferred an accurate time estimate and fully cooked, thoughtfully prepared food with fresh or at least non-​metallic ingredients. I give credit for having a lot of toppings to choose from, so dessert options and a mellow environment to eat from. I enjoyed feeding the crows and gulls, but not as much as I would have enjoyed the delicious pizza I’m sure they often make or having that approx. $ 25 to use on something else.

Good. Not great. Greasy. Could use a better sauce. Ordered a large half all meat and half Hawaiian for $ 25. That’s top dollar in SoCal, not sure where all these people who say it’s reasonably price are buying their pizzas. The Hawaiian is $ 19.50 /​the All Meat is $ 24.75. You’d think if you ordered half of each you’d split the difference, but they charge the greater of the two.

Good pizza. Good gluten free crust. My wife approves of her standard cheese pizza as well. We are from NYC, so there is standard that pizza has to meet to even make it on the chart. This pizza does. However, the people that spoke of the long wait were correct. If my restaurant had an hour and a half wait for pizza, the kitchen would look like a tornado and I would have more than two guys working, casually. That’s just me though. It’s probably worth it considering the other options in town. I’ll eat here again whenever I’m in Newport. Plan ahead and you won’t be disappointed.

When you walk in you order your pizza at the counter. Then they bring you your pizza/​order to your table. The place isn’t really big and it’s very calm inside. There pizzas are normal average price and loaded with toppings !

Love, love, love this pizza! Great crust and great garlic rolls! Love their weeknight special (M-​Th) of 14″ one topping pizza for $ 11.

We ordered a classic Italian and added mushrooms. The pizza was delicious — perfect amount spicy Italian sausages all the ingredients were fresh and they were very generous. The crust was perfect — crunchy chewy and very tasty. We recommend Cobblestone for a great end to a beautiful day in Newport, OR.

We arrived at Otter Rock after several hours in the car, traveling from Medford. The last thing we wanted to do was find a place to eat. So when the front desk told us we could order a pizza that would be delivered, it was the perfect solution.
I consider myself somewhat of a pizza snob. I love pizza but not the cheap chain ones, which is what I was expecting. We ordered the combo, without the black olives (my husband doesn’t like them) and what we got was one of the best pizzas I have ever had! Yes, we paid a $ 5.00 delivery charge but they came almost ten miles to deliver it. It was hot and absolutely delicious. I was so glad we had ordered a large so we had enough left over to heat up for lunch today.
Seriously, I will probably order from them again during this stay and every other time we find ourselves in the Newport, Or area. Best pizza ever!!!

Made it to Newport kinda late for dinner. Called Cobblestone and ordered a large pizza and Itilian salad. Person taking the order was very nice and helpful. Delivery was prompt and courteous. The salad was huge with ham, peparoni, extra salad dressing and vegies. They brought paper plates, napkins and plastic utensils. The pizza was big and well covered with toppings ! I highly recommend you try Cobblestone!!!
Let’s see The other guys beat that !

Small family-​oriented pizza joint with cheap and generous lunch specials and very nice people at the counter.
The pizza (personal size w/​mushrooms) was pretty good but also pretty greasy. It made my skin all shiny for the rest of the day… I tried to pass that off as my ebullient personality but I’m not sure if anyone bought it.

We ordered the Cobblestone Combo, cheese pizza (for our kids) and an order of garlic knots. The garlic knots came out first and we’re very delicious. At $ 3.75 for a dozen, they were a steal. Buttery, garlicky, chewy, and piping hot. The pizza was pretty good, generous toppings, fresh and delicious. Service was fine, prices were not bad ($ 31.00 for a young family of 4), facility was clean, and perfect for littles.

The pizza here is very delicious and reasonably priced. We had the Cobblestone Combo– salami, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, sausage, mushrooms, and olives. Typically, I shy away from thicker crusts in favor of the thinner New York-​style, but this crust was tasty. The toppings are generously piled high, and an additional layer of cheese sprinkled on top of said mountain, creates a helpful net to prevent an otherwise avalanche of goodness. This allows for more civilized consumption. We also had the garlic knots/​rolls and at $ 3.75 for a dozen, you’d be a fool to resist the temptation of an order (or two). They came out piping hot, buttery, and emanating a gloriously pungent garlic fragrance. As far as cleanliness goes, we happened to be there when this facility was being inspected by the state. I passed the inspector on my way out and asked how they fared. He said the owner, who’s been at this for over a decade, is consistently in compliance with all health codes, which is nice. Overall, a positive experience!

Decent cheap pizza if you have low expectations.
We got a 14 inch Buffalo with blue cheese dressing. The crust was delicious, definitely the best part.
The sauce was decent, hard to go wrong with Buffalo and blue cheese.
The chicken was unflavoured and breaded poorly, the pieces looked like they were cheap fingers from the grocery store, blech.
Maybe… Just maybe a different type (Margarita?) would be better.

I’m not from the area and was lucky to find this place. I had the alfredo chicken garlic pizza and it was fantastic. Wish they had other drinks on the menu. Pepsi is horrible. Service was decent. Overall I would probably go back when I am in town again.

While on vacation we had a pizza delivered to our room, it was hot and fresh, and we were surprised by the quality. The sauce was delicious, we had pancetta on it and it was wonderful. Just the right amount of cheese and meat. Im not a thick crust fan, but it was very tasty! The whole family enjoyed it!

If you like fresh hand tossed pizza with flavor, over loaded with fresh toppings, then this is the place! We ordered a large #13 Pesto (Italian sausage, pancetta, sun dried tomato, ricotta cheese and peso) we added artichoke hearts and a large #1 Cobblestone Combo (pepperoni, salami, Italian sausage, bell pepper, onion, mushroom and black olives) delivered for $ 50. Awesome place!!!

We were visiting the Newport area and ordered in during one of our nights. The reviews of this restaurant and the hotel front desk drew us into ordering delivery. The pizza was good, the service was average. We ordered ½ All Meat and ½ Combo. If in the area, we would order in from this pizzeria again.

Called in my order on a Thursday evening, my order was ready in 20min. The staff was friendly and fast. The food was good, I had a pepperoni pizza and a side of the garlic balls. The food was a little greasy, but tasty. I’ll go back again.

The food is great. The do not skimp on toppings. The calzones are big enough for 2 people. The pizza was delicious. We would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for good food! Plus the staff is very friendly.

Got calzones. If I had to do it again, would have gotten pizza. I also would have had it delivered to our room, or ordered ahead, as it took 45 minutes to arrive. The garlic rolls were great.