Village Pizza and Grille

$ 8.99 for a delicious pepperoni pizza! How can you beat that?!

My only memory of this restaurant is a stop by after the fireworks at East Lyme Day with friends. We loaded up on multiple appetizers and felt so full that we almost fell asleep in the restaurant. Great memory and great food.

Best pizza place in montauk! My family has been going for years and it wouldn’t be a night on the beach without village pizza, garlic/​Broccoli pasta and some wine.

Went to the Book Barn in Niantic and they recommended Village Pizza and Grille. We ordered a large pepperoni and green pepper pizza and salad. The pizza was delicious and cooked perfectly. Rarely do we finish our pizza crusts but we dipped it in the house made creamy garlic dressing and it was addicting to say the least. Service was great, from the servers to the cute mom and pop owners who came out of the kitchen to check on all the tables. Definitely coming back!

Best steak and cheese grinder I’ve EVER had. So much flavor to it.

Terrible, tasteless pizza. I am in the area for business and I really wanted pizza to watch the NFL Draft tonight. I am sorry I chose this place. I called up and ordered a large cheese pizza — was told it would be ready in 10 – 15 minutes. I arrived after 20 minutes and stood in the tiny eating area for 4 minutes before someone acknowledged me.
The pizza finally came out, 29 minutes after ordering… I couldn’t believe they consider this a large pizza — it is the size of most mediums and some smalls! I wish I knew how small this thing was going to be so I could have ordered two! Too late, I wasn’t going to wait another ~30 minutes for another pizza. I stopped by Subway on the way back to my hotel room so I had enough food.
The pizza is absolutely dreadful: tasteless, bland, just absolutely horrible. It tastes like a frozen pizza. The cheese is burnt and there is no tomatoe sauce to be seen. I would rather have spent twice the price and bought a decent-​tasting pizza than this piece of junk. They should be ashamed for serving customers such junk!

Great food, a little pricey. I was a regular but haven’t gone in about two months due to being away for work… Usually the staff is so helpful however I was there Tuesday night, October 14^th to pick up a to go order and the young girl was very rude with me on the phone and in the restaurant. When I ordered and thanked her for taking my order she responded «yup» and hung up the phone, did not tell me when to pick it up and did not say bye. Just disappointing because their customer service use to be amazing.

This is a great local joint. I’ve been going here since they opened and have yet to have a bad experience. Only issue is it gets really busy during lunch hours in beach season. But busy is a good thing.
This is a local favorite for lunch. The salads are awesome. You can’t go wrong w any of the choices from the crispy chicken to the buffalo chicken. They are all fresh and satisfying.
If you get a grinder, I recommend the pita bread. Any sandwich on pita is awesome. The chicken bomb and steak and cheese are favs, and the California chicken sandwich is pretty awesome. I’m not a tuna person but a couple of my coworkers love the tuna. No matter your choice, you can’t go wrong.
The best part and the most important is they love their customers. They take the time to know you and remember your name. I love walking in and being greeted by my first name. That is true customer service!!!

First time yesterday. Kicking myself for driving by this little gem for years!
Ordered a small pizza and a Sam Adams. Pizza was ready in 15 minutes and it was really delicious!
I had 3 slices and brought the rest home. This did not last long with teenage daughters!
I will add Village Pizza and Grille to my list, for sure!

This was my wife’s and I first visit. She had a Chef Salad and I had Lasagna. Both meals where «very satisfying» to say the least. And the server was «outstanding». Would certainly go back again.