Amish Country Market At The Feed Mill

What a great store! First, it 100% starts with the friendly staff. Next, it is important that every good business has a good product. The first time I looked at their homemade products, I could see how each batch was cared for individually because everything looked delicious. We decided to get the cinnamon rolls. If you haven’t had these things, then you need to get out and get yourself some.
They had everything from brittle, jams, freshly baked breads, and something that looked really interesting I might have to grab the next time I’m in there. It was a everyday healthy shot filled with numerous antioxidants. Looking forward to my next visit

Great place to stop for a sandwich or to pick up cinnamon rolls. People are friendly. Chicken salad is delicious!

Sweet staff and great products. Haven’t had the sandwiches but hear they are killer. Will be going back to try the chicken salad !

I love this place. Everything is good, especially the chicken salad. it’s the best I’ve ever had. If you’ve never been here do yourself a favor, stop in and just take a look. Oh, and don’t leave without trying one of the little ice cream treats up front next to the register. You’re welcome. :)

Over priced but tasty. Wouldn’t go again. Had a chicken salad sandwich. Bought some cinnamon rolls to take home. They were good.

Chicken cranberry pecan salad was delicious, however the inside could be so much cuter. The tables were scattered with folding chairs. Table cloth was stained. The interior could still be rustic but needs an update. Not a cute place for lunch. Would rather grab take out next time than eat in. Very cute area for shops but this restaurant needs and interior update and cleaning.

Fresh and good but a bit pricey.

I have purchased Cinnamon Rolls, farm fresh eggs, produce in season, cheese, and several other items. Always been top quality and excellent taste. Highly recommend.
Glenn

Living in Boston, it’s hard to find wholesome cooking like this. The food was more than what we can eat. I miss the South!

We wandered in here for the first time while exploring the local antique shops, not sure what to expect. What we found was a GEM! We were there at an odd time, just before dinner… not a soul was in there other than us and a single employee. She allowed us to sample several of their meats, cheeses, cinnamon rolls and chicken salads. Everything was SO delicious that we ordered a ham for the holidays from them! We took home some cinnamon rolls that day, but we’re still planning to get back over there with a cooler so that we can stock up on some meats and cheese!

THIS. PLACE.
When my wife and I walked in here, we didn’t expect to have our taste buds literally explode. Yes, I know what ‘literally’ means. If you walk in there now, you will find them, scattered about the floors and walls of this establishment. We purchased a sampling of several things, and continued our merry way of taste explosions until we had consumed all the things we purchased, and now we’re planning to go back soon, with a cooler in tow, so that we can purchase more and safely transport it back to our home (an hour away).
If you want some good wholesome local eats: this is your stop.

Get there early !!! It gets crowded and will lower your experience. The food was the very best simple breakfast I have ever had. Everything was fresh from the farm and simple delicious. The buffet is 12.99 and unless you are starving one trip will fill you up at 8.99. The pimento cheese in the store is awesome. The chocolate milk if you have had better I would be very surprised. Take a trip its worth it.

It’s easy to work up an appetite looking at antiques The Amish County Market makes greats sandwiches at a very reasonable price. I also love their fried pies and usually take some home whenever we’re in the area.

Went in for their all you can eat breakfast. It was ok. Nothing I couldn’t make at home. Price was decent. Make you get there early limited seating.

the store is adorable! I was extremely impressed with the fantastic customer service I received from the very nice woman working there today. she immediately offered samples of the chicken salad and cinnamon rolls which were out of this world! I was only passing by but before I knew it I bought pies (yes in plural form) chicken salad, and their fresh white bread. 5 stars!

I hate doing this given all the great reviews but for the first time ever, Unilocal has led me astray. This place is no more Amish than Cool Springs Galleria. Maybe my expectation was way too high because of the reviews but I was far from impressed.
My wife, two kids and I went on a Saturday morning for the buffet. The adult «buffet» is $ 6.99 but it’s one trip only and the variety is limited to eggs, bacon vs sausage and pancakes vs biscuits. You can pay $ 9.99 for an all you can eat adult buffet but are still only allowed to pick from either bacon or sausage and pancakes or biscuits the first go around. The kids buffet was $ 3.99 and basically offers the same thing just smaller helpings. Not a bad value for the kids but they are making a killing off the adults. I must say, the food is better than average but far from outstanding and it’s definitely not worth what I paid.
The drink situation was frustrating as well. The kids milk was über expensive ($ 2.00 +) and my coffee was $ 1.75 which wasn’t horrible but if you have 3 carafes available and you sell 10+ varieties in your store, offer more than one roast variety.
The ambiance was far from what I had envisioned as well. It features oversized tables arranged very close together making it cramped with very uncomfortable chairs, many of which are metal folding chairs. There is a market feel but pretty disorganized. My other frustration is when a self serve establishment leaves tip jars everywhere when I do all the work. The counter, each table, the buffet table, the condiment table, everywhere had a tip jar. Also, leave each type of jam and condiments on the tables. Don’t make me work for everything including cleaning my tables and then expect a tip especially at those prices. EVERYTHING is spread out. The food is on one side, the drinks on the other and frankly, it just leads for a confusing experience if you have never been there. Even if you are a regular it would be exhausting.
After reading a post from someone earlier saying this place made them «want to be Amish» I guess I was just expecting something else. If this was a market where I grabbed a biscuit sandwich to-​go, I’d be all over it but it’s just not a good dine-​in type place. I seems from the reviews that this place has a pretty stellar lunch menu but unfortunately, a second chance for this place is not in the cards.
Lebanon Levi would not approve!

yay! i love this place. i want to camp behind it and live there. i want to become amish for this place.
it’s like the amish table at the farmers markets, but bigger and better!
all kinds of homemade amish great! amish cheese! amish butter! pickled everything! amish meats and sausages! turnovers and pies! milk (not raw, because that’s illegal :(), and other snackies!
oh! and they have a glorious breakfast there on saturdays!

As has been stated before me, it’s one of those places so special you hesitate to write a review about it.
Everything about this place is magical, the smell, the food, the décor. Everything is fresh and top quality. The cheese, bread, and butter make excellent staples to have in your home… everything else is literally icing on the cake.
Don’t miss the Orange Juice Cake, the Amish Rolls, or the fried fruit pies.

Sometimes there are places that are just as cute as a button and the Amish Country Market at the Feed Mill is just that. The old timey exterior and warm, friendly interior, and yummy food has made this one of my favorite spots to dine in Nolensville.
My favorite sammy is the Buggy Wagon. The fresh turkey, sourdough bread and spicy fruit spread was so tasty. My mom loved her chicken salad too! It had big chunks of chicken with great flavor!
Also, there is a wide variety of food to take home with you. Bread, jams, Hatcher milk, and fresh meat all for the taking. I would totally stop at this place before going to Arrington Vineyards to pack a lunch of dreams to pair with wine!

Come here for the breakfast on Saturday or the fresh sandwiches, baked goods, or Amish goods. The breakfast served on Saturdays is good and very filling, despite it’s relatively limited variety. Who knew Amish sausage was so good? The pancakes were rich and thick.
The rustic interior is charming, as is the staff. They provided samples of various hand made treats, from cheeses to cinnamon rolls. The store has a variety of local and organic honeys, butters, cheeses, pickles, pastas, candies, and snacks. I probably left some stuff out, so check it out yourself. It’s worth the scenic drive.