Johnny’s New York Style Pizza

Sorry to see Johnny’s close, I hear management will reopen as a sports food and bar!

how or why does the phone not get answered at a this place, like, never. absurd and extremely irritating. get it together, johnny.

great food /​good value. friendly staff. bronx bomber was the bomb!

Dry tasteless, over baked, we had a white pizza, not enough cheese to taste if the different types were on the pizza

Have had carry out here before and the pizza was very good so we decided to try dining in this time — bad move. They weren’t busy at all at 530pm Thursday evening so we thought we could get in and out with our two young children. The garlic bread came quickly but after that things really slowed down and when our 4 slices of pizza came out half the order was wrong but they didn’t really do anything to correct it. So at the end of the day we spent $ 40 on 4 sodas and 4 slices of pizza (plus garlic bread). Not a lot of value there when the service was slow. Maybe we will just stick to carry out next time.

Food came quickly and was delicious. Had lasagna and my husband had pizza. Really good

When we moved to Peachtree Corners after living in Grant Park and then, Buckhead, we were very sad to lose our proximity to Fellini’s Pizza. We were very hopeful that we would find a new, casual pizza spot to enjoy pie by the slice. Thankfully, we found it at Johnny’s. We love the casual vibe, the speed, and the tasty pie. We also love the support they give to local athletics. You can count on us to be frequent visitors.

Had the lunch special stromboli with two toppings and a soda (7.95) and it was delicious. Good size side of marinara sauce for dipping and free refills on the beverage. Really good deal. The service was quick and the server was pleasant. I would definitely come back here.

My co-​workers and I were in serious need of pizza for lunch so someone suggested this place. Well it took one hour and forty minutes to get to us, which was horrible. Then the driver went around in circles because he was upset that he had to make change and he stated that the restaurant didn’t give him any change and it was coming out of his own pocket. After that 10 minute conversation we finally got down to eating. we got the House special pizza and it was… how shall I say this politely? I think Atrocious would be a great description. The pizza was not hot, it hardly had any sauce on it which made it VERY dry and it left an unusual after taste in all of our mouths. For a large pizza to cost almost $ 25.00 the quality and the whole experience of trying to get our food was not good.
I personally will NEVER order another thing from this place and neither will my co-​workers. The chef really needs find other employment seeing that he/​she cannot even make a good pizza pie. We would have been better off calling Dominoes.
I still can’t get this foul taste outta my mouth… Ewwwwwww!!! Never again!!!

Today my wife and I tried this pizza place and we were very impressed. The pizza was crisp and full of flavor, the crust was good enough to eat by itself. The garlic knots were very good as well. The menu was huge and had several options from pizza, wings, pasta, calzones among great choices. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. You owe it to yourself to go check out this out.

Very good lunch specials. Very good to-​go cups!

Food is ok, but their professionalism sucks. My son was hired there and told he would start in a week (Monday). A worker — not management — calls my son today and says that he doesn’t have the job any longer because someone came in looking for a job who had previous experience there. Jerking the rug out from someone like that. Sucks.

We never even actually got around to getting the food. My roommate called and asked for eggplant on their pizza, they charged her and told her the delivery time, and then an hour later still hadn’t shown up.
She called back and said her food still hadn’t been delivered.
Apparently they don’t have eggplant… so why charge her card in the first place?
They blamed her phone, and said they tried calling back many times to inform her of this.
Because it’s SO much more likely that her phone was glitching all those times instead of them taking down the number incorrectly– right?
Maybe it had something to do with the fact that the person on the phone could hardly hear her, since their music was so loud in the store.
They gave her a credit to her card by cancelling the order, but we won’t be repeating this experience.

Not quite NY pizza but it’s ok. It’s a small, quaint place with a full menu.
FOOD: I can’t say for the other foods, so I’m giving 3 stars for their pizza. I had their cheese pizza which was a thin, soft crust with plenty of cheese and decent amount of sauce. It was ok… meaning I wouldn’t say NO to coming back.

I went on Trivia night. The place is rather small on the inside. Waiter came over to our table after we sat ourselves. Ordered a salad and Spaghetti w/​bread. The salad had way too many onion.
The main course was large and cooked well. The prices were on point for this type of eatery. The server seemed to forget about filling our drinks.
I guess I would go back again.

They have a decent selection of food to order. I usually order pizza by the slice when I go to Johnny’s. The toppings they use are pretty fresh. My only complaint about this particular place is that service can be iffy based on which server you get. Some of the best servers I’ve had work here, and others, not so much.
They serve beer and wine, too, in case you want to pair that with your meal. The prices are decent.

All the goods you have come to expect from a Johnny’ Pizza and Sub Shop. It’s subs and slices and on a Monday at lunch it’s a great place to see all your SportsCenter highlights on a big screen.
I had a tasty «Johnny’s Sub», and the toast-​up in the oven was a nice touch. See you again.
Cheers!

So I walk in after 2pm on a Saturday afternoon to an empty restaurant — minus another couple. My guess at that point was that we would have either an incredible service or a horrible service. Surprisingly, the service wasn’t too bad, although I wasn’t happy about the fact that after we placed our order, our waitress stopped by the other table immediately and talked for about (at least) 5 minutes before putting our order in the kitchen. Regardless, I enjoyed the garlic knots basket and waited patiently for our pizza — which turned out very salty and we did not particularly enjoy it much. Somehow this visit was not good from the start, whereas other times I’ve eaten here, the food was good.
My suggestion is that if you’re going to get some pizza here, don’t go at 2pm on a Saturday afternoon. But make sure you get those garlic knots!

I guess it’s alright. I think it’s standard pizza. It’s good for people who like thin crust but I like it extra thick and lots of toppings. I didn’t get that at Johnny’s, but the ingredients were fresh. I liked that.

Recently my office had ordered their pizza delivery to cater lunch, twice. It’s been over two years since I had anything at this place, and the pizzas have clearly improved. They are not even recognizable from the absolute sewage crap that I remembered. In fact, they are better than average now in terms of taste, and very nicely constructed with great textural balance of chewy and crispy. I’ll take this over most chains now. Kudos for the impressive improvements.