Lucy’s Pizza

Simply the best pizza in Westchester with good prices.

By far the best pizza in Ossining and Northern Westchester in general …
If you want to school in Ossining then you already understand, but if you you didn’t why haven’t you eaten here yet?
There pepperoni sticks are awesome and a great deal with just the right amount of dough cheese and pepperoni.
The cheese steak pizza is unbelievably good. Order it topped with peppers and onions, and don’t be afraid to tell them to make it the way Josh likes it!
Their Sicilian slices are incredible and no place around has even come close they are often failed attempt to even make Sicilian pie that’s worth stopping in your pie hole. Sicily’s places have this marvelous on the outside they give them a flavor that’s just amazing I always order a corner slice.
They make party hero’s and a delishous chicken parm.

I stalled about trying this spot for a long time after moving to the area, but always heard good things. So, I finally tried it out… then again in the same week. I’ve only had three things on the menu so far, a plain regular slice, a Sicilian, and their signature pepperoni roll (twice), but all have been surprisingly great!
I’d fallen into the trap of thinking that their pizza would taste as generic as the place looks, but I was terribly mistaken, and really wish I’d tried this place much sooner.
If you’re looking for a great slice spot in Ossining, skip Capri, Sal’s, and maybe even Ossining Pizzeria, because this is the best you can find in town, believe dat!

I love Lucy’s and always have. I used to go there all the time since I went to high school across the street and they have always been great. Of course their pizza is amazing but their salads are good too. They have great prices and fantastic service. An overall great pizza place to go to!

one of the better places in the area, solid pizza and entrees

I live 5 mins walking from here. I am glad I live near a decent pizza joint! Good place when I am too tired to cook.

my favorite pizza ever. when I was in high school I went to this place every single day for lunch. now that I have moved out of Ossining everytime I have the oppurtunity to visit I do. I love the food so much and the staff is great.

This is my favorite pizza place in Westchester. The pizza’s delicious; I’ve never had a single complaint with it or any of the food. It’s the best pizza I’ve had in the county, and maybe beyond.

Gave it 1 star, because they do have pizza. Went there hoping this was my new pizza find near ossining. Simply put, this place sucks! Plain old tired pizza on display. A new plain pizza had just come out of the oven and they sliced it up for slices. I asked for 2 sausage slices and asked if he could use the fresh slices since there were no sausage slices made. He said no, first they use the old pizza. Really? The place was almost empty at 5PM, so I asked if he could please throw the sausage on some foil and cook it b4 putting on the (tired) slices. He said it is already cooked so he wasn’t doing that. I did a slow burn, then he presented me with 2 old crap slices with undercooked sausage on them. I protested and he said «you want your money back?» Damned right I did, and I will never go back assholes! Really was hoping for a good local pizza place. Seriously, if we don’t demand some customer satisfaction places like this will continue. Even if not for this experience, the parking sit. sucks and the pizza looks so old and tired. Probably fine at lunch for the student from ossining HS — what do they know, and what other choice do they have? Don’t ever go to this dump!

Just doing this again because it showed 0 stars before which is not true, Wrong on Unilocal part… Lucy’s is the best… The service, The food, the owners and workers are very courteous…
They make you feel welcomed… I dont trust this Unilocal website… Hopefully they will put this thru…

Best pizza in the ossining area. They’re the only guys that use real pizza dough. They’ve messed up a time or two but always did the right thing and made the best of the situation
The entrees are pretty good too, better than Capri and the other «Italian» spots around.

the worst service and pizza ever! first of all i ordered a small pie that took 52 minutes to deliver and when it finally arrived it was too damn salt and cold??? never ever again!!!

Average pizza. Nothing special.

Great pizza and amazing galic knots. They also have salads, pasta, and more. But there are a few flies during the Summer: they sty up to date and change their decorations twice or one a month

Pizza is not good, crust is very thin and slices are way 2 small just do not look fresh. If you want a quick slice when you r at OHS watching a game it is convenient other than that I would not recommend this pizza shop

Awesome classic pizza take out joint!
One of the Best pizzas I’ve ever had!
Simply put, the crust is awesome! and the sauce is a home run.
The Garlic Knots are also a 10
The Male owner is nice, accommodating and courteous wile the younger counter guy seems a bit scatter brained. (he’s screwed up my order more than once)
Be that as it may, this is still the only place I buy pizza from.

Definitely decent pizza for a quick lunch. Around noon its full of kids from the high school but its no biggy bc that leaves enough meter parking since most of them walk. That is the only downside tho– having to park along the street and risk your vehicle getting any dings or scratches from losers on the road. $ 10 for 3 slices and 2 drinks for two, on a sunny afternoon. The white slice was slammin and hearty. Next time i would try their chicken bacon ranch fo sho

I don’t know what the other reviewers are talking about but there’s only one and I mean one best pizza in Ossining and this is it. just ask around Ossining and see where they direct you.

Excellent pizza and great service. The rooms are generous and the food fresh!

I haven’t been in a year. But as I begin to draft Unilocal reviews I’m compelled to tell the world how great the single slices are at lucys.
I loved them when I was in high school across the street; in college when good pizza was hard to find; when I moved to Brooklyn, no one believed I was serious that lucys was still among the best. And still after the reopening when the same Tony was there to greet me and ask what I’d been up to in the years since graduating (and amazingly to remember who my siblings were and ask how they were).
I didn’t learn much in high school, but I learned there’s no better sausage slice around.