Mario’s Pizzeria of Oyster Bay

There is not a better pizza place in the world than Marios! They have the best food IN THE WORLD. I have tried everything on the menu and the food is incredible. From pizza to garlic knots to Greek salad, these guys know how to provide their customers with a tasty plate. I have been coming here for years and order it at least once a week. Would give it ten stars if I could

Reliable, consistent, very good pizza and entrees. Salads need a little work. Quick friendly delivery and a comfortable dining room. There are a few terrific pizzerias in OB. Mario’s and Saggio’s are my top two.

Love marios. Irene is amazing, so caring. Great food, great staff! Very family friendly!

Some real down-​home good cooking at this pizza restaurant. Tonight I just went with slices, a regular and a barbeque chicken. Both tasting fantastic.
The combination of the marinara with the barbeque sauce and some small crispy nuggets of chicken throughout made the specialty slice extra special.
And of course I try a regular slice at every New joint I patronize. At Mario’s they have excellent sauce the right cheese crust is pretty perfect and it all comes together because the chefs there know how to cook a slice well done and crispy, without having to be told. Mangia!

Best Eggplant Parmesan on the planet. Having a party call Mario’s. I remember the last day of 6^th grade a group of us girls road our bikes to school and at lunch time we cutout and went to Mario’s as a last Hurrah!!!, to middle school. It was great then and great now. That was 40 years ago. 40ish :) Smiley Faces very big in the 70’s!

I received the wrong order when my food was delivered. I called when I noticed and got a very nasty attitude. I explained that I ordered lentil soup but got barley. I was then yelled by the rep who picked up the phone. His exact words «I took the call and you ordered Barley» in a very angry voice. so I guess I all of a sudden eat meat. I didn’t bother to try an explain since he already decided I was a liar. I said thanks and hung up. ILL NEVER ORDER FROM THIS PLACE AGAIN.

Mario’s does not deliver that is why I had to give them one star off. But Mario’s has fantastic food and pizza. They have so many specialty slices to choose from at any given time. I recommend the ravioli slice, the chicken bacon ranch, and the ziti slice. If you’re in the area I definitely suggest going to Mario’s for pizza over the other pizzerias nearby.

My number 1 go-​to place for pizza, pasta, salads and everything else. The service is so great, they are fast, and the food is always delicious. I have been going to Mario’s for years and I can confidently say the food has never tasted better. Clean, friendly, and delicious. Doesn’t get better than that

Love going into marios where there is good food and decent service. However last night went I went into the establishment there was a dog. I’m cool with dogs and all, however I don’t want them in a restaurant eating with me.
Immediately I went up to the counter who then told me that the dog was a service dog. Ok fine that is a different story. But now I notice that the dog which is sitting a few booths away had its head two inches away from the table and was drinking a cup of water from off the table. This is gross in the fact that this is where I put my food. So I went back up and mentioned that the dog was eating from the table where the employee then said that saying there was nothing he could do.
He could have asked the patron who by every right should get to stay, to please put there dog on the floor as other patrons eat and drink out of the booth. However he did not.
I’m seriously grossed out and no longer want to eat inside of marios, which was a shame bc I enjoy eating in there. Next time I will be taking my food to go as I do not want to eat where a dog has been eating and licking off the table.
Gross, and not ok.

I’ve been going here forever so it’s about time I give Mario’s it’s due. Came in to a well lite, clean, and very organized place. It is run very well and has been for years. Clean floors, dusted counters, and wiped table are what I see on my way to the counter. They have plenty of staff that services you quick. «What can I get you» was asked when I walked up to order. I normally do buffalo slices but wanted more meat. It came by the way of a stuffed chicken parmigiana slice. My mind told me to get one, but my stomach won the battle, so I ordered two! They where priced a little on the high end, but I would soon find out why. I was impressed with how much chicken they packed into one slice! The sauce that they used had great flavor and the nail on the coffin was it came out hot. The amount of cheese they put into it complemented the pizza well too! I don’t think I need to remind you Unilocalers about my love for CHEESE (Moving on). Not many people know they have a area downstairs. I went downstairs but the lights were off so I had to turn them on. I guess that was one negative. If you are ever in Oyster Bay and are in need of food, great service, and a great store layout, then look no more, I have shown you the gem of Oyster Bay.

Just because someone can cook, doesn’t mean they can run a good restaurant.
8 of us went for lunch at 1:30 Sunday. 5 of us got our order. 3 had to wait. And wait. And wait some more. 2 of us were brought our order about 7 minutes later. Most of us were polite enough to wait for everyone to be served before eating. 7 minutes doesn’t sound like a lot of time, but try sitting for that long. Time it. It’s a loong time. One meal remained– my mother’s Pizzetta. (She’s 87). Another 10 minutes went by. At some point, I touched the bread on my Sausage and Pepper sub. It was cool. (Possibly from the cool breeze (January) blowing down on the table.
Since the 8^th order was still on «back order», I opted to have my plate and another one reheated while we waited. The disgusted look I got from «Frank» when I brought it to the counter was classy. Another 10 minutes. Ahh, finally plates are arriving. Oh, except my mother’s. What a debacle. Too bad we paid in advance because at that point it would have sent an appropriate message to just walk out of the place. But we waited. And finally, in what amounted to be about 45 min, my mother’s plate arrived.
Look, even if we ALL had to wait, and all meals arrived after 45 minutes, AT LEAST that’s what a restaurant is supposed to do. Deliver meals AT THE SAME TIME! not spread out over 30 minutes. It’s not as if they all worked in an office and were suddenly assigned to run a pizzeria for a day. THAT’S THEIR EVERYDAY JOB!
Terrible.
Ok, exhale. The food tasted pretty good. ⁷⁄₁₀. If all else was normal, this would be a ⁴⁄₅ rating. The 2 was due to pretty good food. That’s it.
So… If you are considering this place (I won’t see you there) do one of two things–
Specifically request that ALL FOOD is delivered at the same time, or…
Go there alone.

3 star NY pizza, close to 5 star compared to the rest of the country. Its a chain, but still has that hometown feel. Huge, diverse selection, reheated quickly for not too bad of a price.
I went weird with it. Chicken, bacon, ranch. And another that I don’t quite recall the name of, maybe Grandma’s? Auntie something’s? I don’t know, they said it was a top seller. The second one was a great mix of veg and cheese. That chicken bacon ranch was way too rich though. I guess that’s what I was asking for with a pizza named like that.
If in the area and its convienent, I’ll be back, but so many other places in the area worth trying as well.

A lot of pizza choices, they were ok but nothing overly special. A pretty cheap place considering the area is pretty expensive overall. Quick service.

We always going to Bayville for swimming, and on our way back to Queens we always stop at Mario’s pizza and take something to go, either is it pizza pasta or just salad, we are always very happy ! This stuff is friendly also. :-)

Highly recommend this place. My family and I love this place. They have the best pies that I have ever tasted. Love their eggplant slices and their broccoli rabe pies excellent. My kids also love their Chicken Marsala square pies. Very well managed place. Wish they opened one in Glen Cove

This place is amazing there food is awesome and the service is amazing I’m always joking around with the guys that work here I love this place

This is my favorite food here in Oyster Bay. They are so nice. They love my husband Louis. They are always willing to do whatever you need for that night. One night they forgot to give us salad dressing. We got a knock on the door 10 mins later with the owner bringing us salad dressing to our home. Now that is truly going over and beyond for your clients. Right on guys. Thank you!!!

This pizza place is the go to spot in Oyster bay. The quality of the food is incredible impressive.
Everything is fresh and this place only serves food with top quality ingredients.
In the pictures I got the buffalo chicken calzone which is my favorite and they serve it to you with real blue cheese chunks and all. The Gorgonzola salad was delicious and I got garlic knots which are arguably some of the best garlic knots I have ever had.
If you are looking for a pizza place in oyster bay that you can rely on for quality pizza and Italian dishes look no further just go here.

Love the variety of pies here! Everything is always fresh. It’s always busy here but the staff is very efficient & friendly! There’s a pizza place a mile from my house but the six mile drive each way is worth the drive for Mario’s!

I’ve only ever had the food from Mario’s Great Neck location, which I was never a fan of… the pizza was always soggy and the food was mediocre at best.
HOWEVER, this past weekend I was at a party that catered from the Oyster Bay location and Oyster Bay FTW! They had baked ziti (which I didn’t try), fettuccine alfredo, baked ravioli, and eggplant parmesan.
I haven’t had an alfredo dish in years because alfredo sauce is always my dietary demise, but theirs was not overly creamy and perfectly tasty. The baked ravioli was standard. I only had one ravioli because they were huge, but it was good and stuffed with plenty of cheese, which is always a plus in my book.
The star of the meal though was the eggplant parm. I love eggplant, but was never a fan of it in parm form until this past weekend, when I helped myself to two platefuls. I may need eggplant detox. Bravo, Mr. Mario, bravo!