Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

After coming a few times, the food is just okay. I think there are just too many other pizza places around that are much better, for 2/​3rds the price. On the bright side, it doesn’t smell like garbage in there anymore.

Tonight I had an amazing experience at Anthony’s I placed and order for pick up and when I arrived they didn’t have the order in there system but with no hesitation the manger Mary was prompt and professional and was on top of it before I could even make a frown over the situation she placed a new order and had it out to us in less than ten minutes and told us it was on the house it’s so good to know with businesses growing so big these days that just good old fashion customer service is not lost with amazing management like Mary… Thank you so much… my dear.

good atmosphere, service
meatball pizza — very good

I’ve recently developed a taste for this pizza and I 100% love the coal fired taste. The thin pizza adds a nice crunch and flavor to whatever toppings you decide on and it is fast becoming my new favorite pizza. As someone who doesn’t eat crusts I find I can scarf down these. The large pies are great and you can even ask for a personalized portion just in case you like something different. This location is also great and of course because of the popularity of this pizza the place gets packed at night so get there early if you want to beat a 30 min wait!

The eggplant marino (not the pizza) with focaccia on the side was filling. I tried not to eat it too fast, very hard. The meat eater in our group loved it too. The service could’ve been more prompt.

Used to be reasonably good food and almost reasonable prices. Tonight we found they’ve moved to meaningfully higher prices, food was not special, pizza really was mediocre, lacked spices and flavor and was undercooked and service was poor. Small (and I mean SMALL) overly heavily coated Caesar dressing salad is $ 7 and truly over priced. Pizza came finally so late my wife had finished her food. Really very disappointing experience. Location is good so they have lots of customers and clearly decided to push profits with unreasonable price bumps on everything. Will not return.

I’m not sure what they have against sauce. I have to order my mozzarella and tomato pizza WITH sauce and I have to buy sauce from the restaurant next door to eat the wings.
With that said, I love the pizza and wings! Lol… but I gotta have the sauce.

Horrible pizza! It was so thin and watery with I don’t even know. Having a lot of meat is usually a good thing but not with this it was a bad overload. The wings were bitten caus they were burnt and they didn’t even have any time of sauce which I thought was retarded. The best part of the meal was the Diet Coke I ordered. But on the good side the waiter was nice.

Ordered take out, large mozzarella basil with tomato: D yum yum yum! Loved it ! The hostess was very attentive, food came out fast. I’ve never ordered this pizza before here & will definitely order from here again :)

Very good thin crust pizza with coal crispiness on the crust — so crisp the crust is almost burnt — but for some strange reason it makes the pizza very, very tasty. Big selection of toppings and they are all freshly made — I like lots of toppings on my pizza and this place has a big variety.
As good as the pizza is here I think I might like the chicken wings even more. Their Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings are the best chicken wings I have ever had. They come with a side of Caramelized Onions & Focaccia Bread. DELICIOUS!
Food is the best, prices are a little on the high side, service is usually good but inconsistent.
Sure hope I saved enough room for tomorrow’s Honey Baked ham! HO, HO, HO !

This Anthony’s is my favorite and I’ve been to many around south Florida…
The ambiance and staff are great… Always a good visit especially when Barby is taking care of me, her recommendations are always on point… Hast let me down yet. She’s very familiar with the menu and explains everything well and most important to me she’s very honest… Definitely a place to come to visit and don’t hesitate, also remember to ask for Barby.

I love Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza and have been coming here for years. The service is always friendly and welcoming. I’ve always been a huge fan of the chicken wings, they’re baked and aren’t a greasy mess like they serve at other places. I always get a pepperoni pizza with prosciutto and sausage, delish! This is one of the very few places that I’ll eat the pizza from bottom to crust. Pizza isn’t greasy either and comes with a really thin crust.

Anthony’s pizza not as good as it was before. I haven’t been to this place in a while, but I was in thw area and remembered really liking it. I ordered the roasted cauliflower and garlic pizza, since it looked so good in the picture. Sadly the pizza dough was hard and bland. The garlic was nonexistent, the only thing good about it was the cauliflower itself. Never going back again.

I go to Anthony’s in Aventura all the time, but this was my first time @ the one in Pines, I must say it had the best service! I sat at the bar and my bartender was «Barbie» and she was very nice and sweet and very attentive! My food came out very fast! I was pretty impressed. It was also my fathers first time there and he loved it!
Also as we were leaving the hostess opened the exit door for us

Everything on the menu is excellent ! The staff is always friendly.
The only reason that I am giving 4 stars instead of 5 is because of the high sodium content.
Be ready to drink a lot a of water afterwards.

I heard about this place so much but never had the chance to try it until today.
The place is nice not too big not too small, the service is excellent and the pizza is amazing.
We ordered a large pizza with mushrooms and prosciutto, each slice had a slice of prosciutto and not tiny slices, I have never seen other pizzeria do that. I tried one of their crafted beers ‘d-​cigar city maduro’ which was amazing too with a special smokey flavour.
The service was excellent, server was attendant and they would serve you the first pizza slices which was a nice touch.
Great place, prices, and true Italian coal fired pizza.

Da bomb!
This is the best pizza AND wings in Pines, hands down. On top of that, the beer menu is sick.
There are lots of national chain places around here that will sell you a standard pizza for an average price, but who wants standard and average? Not this fella!
The pizza is coal fired, so it has that nice, crispy bottom. The signature pies are unique and tasty. The ingredients are fresh and robust. That alone would bring in a 5 star rating, but the wings are just, whoa. Boom. Incrediballs. They are crispy and coal-​fired as well, so they don’t come out soggy and mushy. They come out delish.
The feel in the place is quaint and kinda dark, so it has a fun vibe.
Check it out, you will not be disappointed.

This location is just as great as the other ones!
The service is really fast and friendly. And the pizza is so good it is making my mouth water just thinking about it. I love the fact that they keep the lights nice and dim in there. It really sets the mood for that intimate date with coal fired pizza. If you are a peperoni fan you will love the peperoni pizza, they double and triple stack them. I highly recommend you try them out and also try out the coal fired wings! They definitely aren’t your run of the mill chicken wings!

This is an AWESOME Place… Would be 5 stars, but didn’t know who I «had to hump around there» to get a refill on water. It’s bad when a glass sits so long that the ice melts in order to create a refill…
Other than that, the pizza is ABSOLUTELY AWESOME. The pizza is «well done» and tasty. Good Crust. I love the fact that the manager came by, and when he found out that it was our first time, offered us a sample of the wings, which are MIGHTY tasty.
If the other locations are similar in class and taste to this one, then this is DEFINITELY a bucket list place. Will frequent often.

In the spirit of true transparency it’s only fair to let you know that the bf did used to work at an Anthony’s many years ago. Because of that, we do have the insight to customize some of the menu items and we receive above average service since he’s always recognized. Before meeting my bf I was a fan of several of the menu items so I’d still give Anthony’s a thumbs up either way.
Let me start by saying, I don’t like the pizza. Shocking yes, but I was raised with Dominos and Pizza Hut being the only two pizza options on the island and 17 years of loyalty to Dominos has somewhat clouded my pizza judgment. I appreciate Anthony’s for offering some interesting pizza toppings — broccoli rabe, cauliflower etc… but it’s just not the Dominos I’m used to and I tend to stay away from the pizza options.
On this particular visit (forgive me for being greedy and forgetting to take all the pictures) we ordered almost the full menu.
The salad — I’m a huge fan! I love it with the lettuce, but the insiders will let you know that you can order it with arugula only.
The chicken wings — not much of a wing girl, but everyone else I know swears these are top notch.
The eggplant marino — one of my favorites! The insider tip is to ask for it well done and get that extra crunch on the edges.
The meatballs — again huge fan, but I may be biased by my love of ricotta cheese.
The pizza — like I said I’m not crazy about it, mostly due to the coal fire grilling technique. On this particular visit we did half broccoli rabe and sausage and half fresh mozzarella and tomato and PRO TIP — we added prosciutto and asked for balsamic to dip it in.
Dessert — my first time ordering dessert here, and the cheesecake did not let me down, plus it’s huge (or at least our slice was… hmmm).