Vinnie’s Pizza

wings are excellant.
pizza flavor very good.
didn’t care for the garlic knots.
gave us a free pizza on cardinal game day. nice people

Since this establishment is close by, my family and I felt like trying it out. First of all, I ordered the veggie pizza without onions, but when I got home found out they put the onions on anyway. There’s strike one for an incorrect order. Next, my family isn’t very partial to cheddar cheese on pizza, and one of my sons even grew up with a slight intolerance to it, so it would be nice if they labeled the types of cheese used on their pizzas. Another point about the toppings: use fresh ingredients, not canned mushrooms! I also ordered cinnamon knots, but were surprised when we actually received doughy, oily garlic knots instead. Strike two on an incorrect order. Hoping that their pasta wouldn’t be bad as well, we then went on to try the «baked» ziti. Unfortunately, an alright pasta was covered in completely bland tomato sauce (I wouldn’t even call it a marinara) and essentially no cheese at all. Also, it wasn’t baked, hence the quotations. Save your money and go elsewhere.

I’m always looking for NY/​NJ style pizza. Vinnies is the closest thing! Staff is friendly, the pizza is amazingly good, priced fairly. I’m a pepperoni girl, but I have tried and LOVED the sausage and also the chicken teriyaki pizzas. This seriously beats the competitors in the area.

If you think your calling Fuzzys your not. Same number as they took over Fuzzys and the phone was answered with «please hold» … Not thank you for calling Vinnies. We ordered our regular Fuzzys thin crust (thinking we were calling Fuzzys as usual!) and thought all was good until the pizza was delivered. It was not thin crust or cut in Fuzzys squares. that was our first clue. when I called to tell them the crust was wrong, I was informed they were no longer Fuzzys and they didn’t have thin crust… Only hand tossed. Oh really??? You would think that at least the phone would be answered «Vinnies» to let people know they are no longer Fuzzys… Also why not tell us when we ordered thin crust that they don’t have it? The pizza was cold and the crust was not cooked all the way and tasted like raw flour… yuck! The sauce tasted like spagettios… Yuck! They even forgot the requested crushed pepper. Fuzzys thin crust and great sauce will be missed… As for Vinnies… I thought it was very misleading and I was very disappointed with the pizza. If I could ask for my money back I would.

It’s not surprising to me to hear this place’s original location is known as the «Best Pizza in Cottonwood Arizona» because Cottonwood isn’t exactly a mecca for great pizza or food.
The most honest review I could give this place is that I think they should have taken their time and not rushed so quickly to open. They just don’t seem ready and polished at this point.
I really loved Fuzzy’s, and am sad to see them go. Because I live right across the street, I will keep giving Vinnie’s another try until they truly disappoint me, but so far everything I’ve gotten from here has been decidedly «meh».

Great food and even better people! A huge improvement over Fuzzys. The veggie pizza was amazing, and wings were fantastic. Will definitely be coming back. It’s a breath of fresh air having a great pizza joint in the neighborhood.

This was the location of the original Fuzzy’s Pizza which was outstanding! Gave it a try. Its pretty good. Worth a try