Ameti’s Gourmet Pizza

Great pizza! Ordered on a whim on Seemless. Priced reasonably. The pizza was delivered hot and in about a half hour. Will definitely order again!!!

My family and I ordered dinner here for their 5 buck subs… You get what you pay for. Very empty sandwich… I’d be pissed if I paid the regular price of $ 7.25. I ordered the cheese steak and my wife the chicken parm… blah blah blah… We also ordered a plain cheese calzone which had barely any cheese in it at all that came with an extremely runny sauce. We’ll try someplace else next time…

Ordered the Family Special #1, XL pizza, any sandwich, Caesar salad, 2 liter soda for $ 21. Not a bad deal if you ask me. The quality of the pizza was average but it arrived cold which was crappy. The meatball parm was warm upon arrival, I didn’t personally taste it but others said it was decent. The salad was standard and good, decent size. And the added in bottle of coke was nice. We were told delivery was going to take 45 minutes and it took about 50 minutes (no biggie) but making sure the food arrives at least warm is key. Cold pizza upon arrival is a big bummer. We nuked it in the microwave and still ate it but it’s not the same.
Overall, I thought the price was good for all we ordered but the quality overall was just mediocre. Maybe I would order from here again in a pinch but there are many other pizza places in the area that deliver better quality overall.
P. S. — forgot to take pictures of the food, sorry!

Updated review from 2012.
I’m now feeling disappointment with Ameti’s now. Over the past two years, there has been a noticeable drop off in the quality of their pizza. To me, it appears they are now using inferior (cheaper) ingredients. The taste difference is that noticeable.
The use of cheaper ingredients, while still increasing the costs does increase profits, but I grow tired and am looking for another local pizza joint.
My previous rating, when Ameti’s opened up, was a good review.

Wonderful, not-​super-​grungy pizzaria. Good pizza is good, but average pizza is also pretty good. Delicious black cherry soda too!

Ordered vegetarian and penne pasta pizza pies and they were delicious. I highly recommend them. Will order from them again.

Decent pizza, as in pizzeria style, not bad but not great. Food is just okay. Good chicken cutlets, thin and cracker coating but find prices a bit steep for certain items on menu. Slices are overpriced for their small size, not worth 1.65. Careful in that staff does not use gloves when they cook/​prep food and it is required under food safety code and regulations.

Ameti’s is your average pizzeria. The food is decent, prices are average. One time when I came up a dollar short on my order, the guy behind the counter was super nice about it. I offered
to put on my charge card since I didn’t have enough cash, and he said just don’t worry about it (I am in there a lot though).

Just moved into neighborhood. Ordered Grandma pie last week, totally not a Gma pie. Tonight, chicken parm lasagna with a side of meatballs… the meatballs tasted frozen, which would be fine, BUT they tasted horrible ! The chicken parm was lil pieces of chicken instead of full piece. When I can say I cook better than this, it sad! I will cook from now on, no matter what time I get home! Not worth the money!

Great round pizza stay away from Sicilian pizza soggy cardboard has better taste wings are good as we’ll, and the round pies are always a favorite

They’re pretty good. Your average busy pizzeria BUT, try someof their other food and be quite surprised. The pizza isn’t great but their «diner food «is top notch.

Ameti’s food is awesome! I love their chicken parm pizza.

Pizza was very tasty! They are currently doing dollar slices-​which is great (and cheap) for a quick bite! They also offer great lunch specials for $ 5 and they sound amazing! Can’t wait to try more!

Ordered from them multiple times. They take OVER an hour and a half to deliver 2 pieces of chicken and bread!!!
I called to check on my order and the guys says «Driver is on his way» and proceeds to hang up on me. I called back and told him that he just hung up on a customer and he did not care at all that there was a disgruntled customer that he just hung up on.
Much like their customer service, their food SUCKS!!!

Stopped in here on a friday night with my kids after hanging out in the NJ hotspot-​Pequannock (actually I was just with some friends at a fundraiser for my daughter’s softball team). First thing out of my daughter’s mouth when we took off was «Is there a pizza place around here?» I had no idea, but drove about 500 feet and what was there… yep, Ameti’s Gourmet Pizza.
So, full disclosure here-​we only had some slices so take this review for what it’s worth. Amita’s «gourmet’ slices were a bit small, but they were also only $ 0.99 each so I guess the price was right. Pizza was ok, it wasn’t the best slice I’ve ever had, but it was pretty good. I loved te sauce-​tasty with a good balance between sweet and savory, but the cheese seemed a bit bland. Crust was just ok, a little small, but the right thickness… but not outstanding-​a little too well done for my liking. I’m sure there are other pizza joints in the area that
If I was back in the area, I’d stop back in for a pie-​service was good, price was right, and the pizza was pretty good.

Tried the pizza here for the first time tonight, not a fan. It was very bland tasting.

Pizza is good, not the best, but good. 99 cent plain slices are a great deal and can’t be beat! Not a lot of seating if you choose to eat there, best for take-​out or delivery.
The best are their dinners though! MMMM Eggplant or Chicken Parm! Do it up. Delivery has always been quick for me, no issues there

I’m not a pizza person normally. but I love theirs!

Pizza is good, but they took about an hour and a half to deliver it. We called and the delivery guy was back at the pizza shop. He said he knocked on the screen door or something. They didn’t even call us!