Yaghi’s New York Pizzeria

THIS is true, NY style pizza, and great, friendly employees. A lil piece of heaven in the PF.

The pizza is good but they are short staffed & the girl spent time on her cell before starting my pizza. Irritated. It should have been ready 10 minutes ago!

This place is very good. It’s not really what I would call NY pizza but it’s better than the thick doughy crust you find at most places.
I would say that so far this is my favorite local pizza in PVille.
The pepperoni is a little lacking. But I see other people complaining about that too. We bought pepperoni and added it on at home.

Should fix your website so that you can not place an online order outside of your delivery area

Love Yaghi’s! My husband and I order it all the time. Great pizza for great prices!

Never, Never, Ever, Again.
I walked into the place to order pizzas to be delivered to my house, and they told me I had to call in! I am standing right there, and they make me call them. So I called them, and while i am standing there they put me on hold.
What a crazy event. The pizza itself was underwhelming — tomato sauce with little to no seasoning, and little effort into making the pizza good. It came highly recommended, and sad to say, it was far from anything i could have imagined.

Our family loves this pizza! Great crust — not too thick not too thin, service and ingredients. They also have awesome specialty options (our favorite so far is the chicken pesto with feta, sun-​dried tomatoes, and red onions… But there are so many more to try!).

I first tried this place in 2015 with a co-​worker. He and another coworker from Georgetown kept telling me to try the food.
After getting chided for not having tried it one of my coworkers and I met in the pflugerville location. We arrived and I was able to park up front. The business isn’t very large and is part of a plaza off 685 just downhill from wally world.
They had a lunch special with two slices and a drink. I got a pepperoni and burger. The crust was a little chewy but the dough was still decent. The meats tasted decent and I was okay with the cheese. I know it’s pizza but a little greasy for my taste.
The ladies working there were cool. My coworker said one of the ladies is the owners wife. It’s not the best New York/​Jersey style pizza but it’s not the worst. You may like it if given a chance.

Food ok, BROOKLYN PIE CO wayyyy better! Cust serv good, except for one. The mgr who is probably in her 40s, but she looks like she’s in her 60s. She’s Not gracious kind or apologetic. Had this experience w her multiple times. She’s condescending and rude. Dodge her if possible. Plus a long hair was cooked into my pizza one time smh

The pizza is good if you like clumps of hair baked into it. I didn’t realize that I had hair in my pizza until I got home. I immediately called and told them and wanted either a refund or a whole mew pizza. They said that they could not do either and implied that I put the hair there myself. I was going to bring back the pizza so that they could see it. I mean the clump to hair was BAKED into the rest of the ingredients.
On another occasion, i ordered the pepperoni special and they gave me cheese instead. I had to go back in and have that corrected. Instead of being apologetic the manager lady is very rude. I don’t know if she is in need of a vacation, but she seriously needs to work on her customer service. Rolling eyes and rude behavior is just uncalled for. Whatever happened to the «customer is always right??» I should’ve stayed away after the hair incident.

I ordered pizza here. They are alright. Not close enough to New York slices. I born and raised in Brooklyn. So I know. One time there was misunderstanding because their website was little vague (not clear) on what size to get a special order. And they still won’t give me the price as I thought after explained it was not clear. I asked for refund. It took 5 days to get money back. The manager had to give me cash. Today, it was the final straw. I wanted pepperoni slice. But they only put 4 on a slice and another had 3 on it. I told the lady it is not acceptable to pay an additional charge for topping. She suggested me to pay more than additional and will add more on it. Huh! I took a pic of it and photo on their wall that mislead customer. A photo on their wall has 6 – 8 pepperoni on each slice. Take a look at those.
What I’m giving 2 stars are 2 things: the cheese are so-​so a little better than other places. The crust and bottom bread of pizza is too thick. However, their salad dressing is good.

Awesome pizza, meatball subs, and Buffalo wings. Our go-​to for game days and parties.
4 stars for three reasons: This location does not participate in the online coupon promotions that the other area Yaghi’s offer, they did away with the meatball lunch special and now only offer the pizza slice special, and on a few occasions our delivery orders have not been accurate (each time it was a beverage issue, not food).
But the food is delish!

Awesome staff and great food. Our server on Thursday after noon, Joshua B rocked it out

Swung by for the first time on a must-​have-​NY-​style-​pizza whim. I ordered a Pepperoni with double sauce and olives. I was greeted and the customer service was pretty satisfactory. The pie itself, while tasty, was severely lacking in sauce. Barely a regular portion of sauce anywhere else, chains included. The crust was tasty but pretty saggy/​soggy for a NY style pizza.
The pizza was good, and would undoubtedly be better with at least SOME sauce on it. Not impressed, but not necessarily disappointed either. I imagine I’ll find myself back there again at some point, but with those prices and my initial ‘meh’ experience I’m in no hurry.

Excellent pizza and wings! Great customer service! Everyone here is very friendly and you get your food in no time! They’re all very fast, quick, and efficient. Will be coming back!

I love Yaghi’s… in Georgetown and Bee Caves. The GT and BC locations have always been fast and friendly. Emphasis on the friendly. We’ve ordered from the P-​ville location for take out before and were pleased, but today was the first time I stayed to eat here.
First of all, we drive up at 11:25 am and the Open sign is off. I commented that maybe they don’t open until noon (?). My brother said he checked the website and their lunch special runs from 10 am-​2 pm. So we checked the door and a woman inside said hello. That was pretty much where the friendliness ended.
We were the only people there, aside from the lady at the counter (we’ll call her Jen*, dressed in yoga gear, and not looking like she work there) and one other lady in the back (we’ll call her Gina*). We order the lunch special and had three pizza options: pepperoni, cheese, sausage. My brother ordered: one cheese and one sausage. Jen yelled out the order to Gina, but she got it wrong (two pepperoni she said) and my brother corrected her. I order two cheese. Gina came to the counter and Jen again got my brother’s order wrong, I told my brother and he just shrugged it off. The lunch special came with a drink, but we were not given cups and there was no fountain drink machine in sight. So we ask, «does this come with a drink?» Gina said, «Yeah» and went about her work. So we asked, «from where? The canned sodas?» «Yeah.» I usually expect this kind of service from awkward teens working during the summer, but not from grown ass women.
Fine. We sat and were super uncomfortable. No one was in there and the ladies were talking. My brother commented that maybe they do more take out and deliveries, but the phone only rang once and no one came it in to pick up.
Gina brought out our pizza and mine was good. My brother’s was too burned for his liking. The pizza was warm, not hot, but I like mine that way. The crust was chewy and yummy and the pizza was very cheesy. We ate quickly and took the second slice to go. As I asked for a to-​go box and I noticed Jen is heading out on a delivery.
One star for a great lunch special: two slices and a drink $ 5.
One star for yummy chewy crust and great pizza.
I really want to give Yaghi’s more stars, but I can’t, not for this location.
My advice, take it to go.
*Names have been changed to protect the innocent. Also I didn’t get their names.

I like this place. Like it a lot. My last visit really rubbed me the wrong way.
We were running late on Sunday and showed up about 2:15. Their lunch special runs til 2. So we asked if it was too late to get a lunch special, and the girl behind the counter said it would be «no problem, but only what was in the display.» The pizza looked pretty old, but I like the place so much and I know it usually looks and tastes great after it’s heated.
We started to order… out of the bathroom comes a red headed lady and tells the cashier, «not for the lunch special price, or did you already tell them?» She was pretty rude to the cashier and didn’t even say a word to us. She went on to sit next to some folk she knew in the lobby and we ended up walking out. I’m gonna have to find me a new spot for pizza slices. Won’t be going back here again.

I know it sounds dumb to say this, but this was probably the best pizza I’ve ever had. We ordered pepperoni and double extra cheese, with some manicotti. Unfortunately on this very night we got Yaghi’s, we accidentally locked our keys in the car in the parking lot to pick up our order. That sucked. Fortunately for us, while waiting for the Pop-​a-​lock dude we got to enjoy the tastiest, best, cheesiest pizza ever. It was delicious, despite the situation. We’ve had a lot of pizza, from all different types of places. We both agree this was probably the best.
Service is friendly and nice, a little slow but that’s okay if that’s what it takes for great food.
Husband always gets the manicotti, he likes it but I don’t think that dish is the best manicotti he’s ever had.
We’ve tried the one in Georgetown and the 1^st time it was decent, but not as good as this location. The second time it wasn’t very good. :/

They’re great to me today. Came in wanting a meatball sub with no bread. They’re totally making it for me! HUZZAH! Happy Kim today.

This place is quite tiny for starters. But they have some pretty good lunch specials. Two massive slices and a drink. I got the spinach calzone. It had garlic and lots of cheese. The part was the marinara sauce. It was delish. The right mix of spices, not too chunky but not too liquid either.