Brooklyn NYC Pizza

How can two small soggy pieces of pepperoni pizza cost $ 9.00 without a drink? Never again for me! No thanks.

We came here to eat lunch. The server gave our pizza to the wrong people; a family with kids. Once the mistake was brought to their attention, they simply brought the pizza to us — something which is against health code! I’m sure the family picked through it and touched it — slices looked freshley pulled apart and returned to the plate. After a 40+ minute wait, I was unwilling to wait for a remake. They offered a refund. Frankly, I can’t return to a place where they would violate health codes like that. The other people in my group are more tolerant of germs and whatnot than I am; they said the pizza was terrible. I’m sure they will be serving the slices we left behind to the next customers to order a pepperoni pizza.

Not very good at all. Pizza gross. Salad taste as they tossed in water ranch. Wings okay. Only one guy working at lunch and on game day. Save your money.

If pizza is what you do, you need to do better than this. Slice was charred and so overly sweet. The crust managed to be simultaneously too thick and too thin — and burned.
Staff was super friendly and accommodating. But although that was nice, it fell a good deal short of «must return»… Especially considering the food.

Been to this place a few times and was never satisfied, the pizza is decent but the service is terrible. The owner turned off all of the lights and locked the doors while I was still sitting outside eating and drinking. They also try to nickel and dime there customers, after spending 10 dollars on 2 slice and a
beer I was asked for some ranch and was told it was 25cents, not a big deal but I didn’t have any cash on me and was told sorry nothing we can do. Much better places with in walking distance!

This place sucks. Their pizza isn’t very good, the service stinks. They reheat all the pizza slices until burn your mouth hot. Really not very good pizza.

AVOID– Appalling… We went on a Sunday afternoon, after 5 fun hrs at the science center & the kids wanted pizza, & were told we couldn’t order a whole pizza. «Because only the owner can make them & he isn’t here» so we were forced to order by the slice. Then to make matters worse I watched the young woman behind the counter touch her hair & then a piece of pizza. The icing on the cake? The food was reminiscent of something I ate in the elementary school cafeteria. NEVER. EVER. AGAIN.

Absolutely worst customer service possible
And this came from the manager/​owner of the place do yourself a favor and don’t go here like many others have said.

Ok stopped in here after comicon today. Pizza was ok, but it took forever to just order three slices! They will not take your order until the previous orders are filled and com out. I never heard of such a thing for a pizza joint. I complained to the cashier about it and she said we have a system in place that works. I said, for who? Not your customers! This place is a joke! Don’t waste your time.

Tried this place during a conference at the convention center. Just around the corner.

First I would like to address some of the other reviews complaining about greasy pizza. Do not order pepperoni if you do not want to deal with grease. This is common pizza knowledge that should be double accounted for when a place like Brooklyn NYC Pizza puts an entire pigs worth of pepperoni on one slice.
I ordered to combo. For $ 5.50 I received a slice of pepperoni, a house salad and a drink. I would have preferred 2 slices and a drink but figured I could attempt to eat healthier for a change. Thank you, house salad.
The pizza was okay. The out crust was crisp but doughy towards, what would be, the center of the pie. NYC style is often flimsy but I’ve never had a slice this doughy before. This was my first visit so I cannot say if this is the norm or not.
I was not overly impressed on the first visit but it was not bad. I would have no problem giving them another chance to see if the pizza improves. Even in it’s doughy state it wasn’t all bad but I can get better at other places.

I give this place 4 stars. The pizza was the best I’ve had in awhile here in Phoenix. The slice of pepperoni I got was huge, thin crust, with lots of pepperoni. A little greasy but so delicious it didn’t matter. One slice is the equivalent of two normal slices. I left wanting more it was so tasty. The wings were decent, not the best but not the worst, and you got 10 for $ 5.00. The place was packed on a Saturday, as there were three big events going on downtown, but the service was pretty quick. Overall, I would love to eat here again.

Decent food at a good price. We paid $ 21 and got 2 big slices of pizza, (packed with pepperoni) 2 salads, 10 wings, and 2 beers. What else could you want? (you can even munch on free popcorn while you wait) Service is efficient and friendly.
Maybe it’s not the best pizza in the metro area but it sure ain’t the worst and it’s much better there than paying three times that amount for something at the game.
I’ll definitely be stopping there again

This is a great spot to hit before going to a Phoenix Suns/​Diamondbacks game. The best reason being that they have $ 10 pitchers of beer and decent pizza for a great deal. I have been here a number of times and it’s usually packed before games so plan accordingly. The owners and staff are always very nice and sometimes too efficient (they try to take plates before you’re finished). I have never had a bad experience and I love sitting outside when the weather is nice.

We chose this disaster during Phoenix Comicon 2012, with 8 total guests. when we walked in, there were crumbs on all the tables that were free. Happily, BNYCP has a roll of paper towels on each table-​when they bother to put a fresh roll out. We waited For. Ev. Er. to order. We were finally able to order our 8 slices-​we couldn’t decide whether to get whole pies or not, and reading some of the reviews, I’m glad we didn’t. They put two slices on one «plate,» so not everyone got a plate.
The pizza itself was not that great. There was lots of sticky, sweet sauce soaking through the crust and dripping off the large and flimsy slices. I’m glad to see someone was able to get a fork-​we tried, but we were told we could only get a fork if we ordered a salad. Nice touch! Meanwhile, sauce is dripping off the pizza to land on my shirt or the table.
My husband and I chose ham and pineapple slices. I don’t know what kind of «ham» this was, but it was actually soggy, with a texture like cheap, generic bologna. Terribly gross. They were also very skimpy with the cheese, so I’m not really sure how that tasted.
As we were finishing up, a man came in carrying a toddler and asked if he could use the restroom. Apparently they said no, because he threw a fit, and told the manager (or whoever he was) that it was pretty bad they wouldn’t let a little girl use the restroom.
Very slow service, not terribly clean, not terribly well-​stocked, bad pizza, and no forks or restrooms. I think I’ll pass!

Frankly, I was starving when I ate here so it was amazing in my book. Looking back, the pizza is pretty flimsy. I did get a sweet lunch deal of a salad (which was good), slice of pizza, and a drink for $ 5.50. Overall, not horrible but not awesome.

The only good thing about this place is the location. It’s less than a block away from US Airways Arena.
We decided to eat at this Pizza joint because we just finished watching Disney on Ice and my nephew was hungry. The guy behind the counter was very rude and pushy on selling his «Combo Deal» which includes a Slice of Pizza, Salad and a Drink for $ 5.50. I told him I didn’t want to order the Combo deal but wanted to order a Whole Pie. He says it takes about 45 minutes to make a Whole pie. Answer me this: What Whole Pie takes 45 minutes to make? Since, he made it seem that I had no other option, so instead I ordered 5 slices and two soft drinks. Each slice had to be reheated in the oven. It took 15 minutes til our pizza was finally ready to eat .At least, that’s what I thought. The Pizza was extremely hot, greasy and tasteless. I wish I read the reviews prior and would’ve just waited to eat somewhere closer to home with better pizza.

The pizza is okay but unfortunately it does not make up for the wait time and fiasco of an ordering process. We were second in line to order, however it took longer than acceptable to be asked our slice selections then several minutes to actually receive our meal. The price point is disappointingly higher than the quality of product with limited lunch specials.
Z Pizza is two blocks west with lunch specials running about a buck fifty less so I’ll be sticking with them from here on out.

I think my family from Brooklyn would be offended with the vain use of their borough’s name for sub standard pizza.
I went here for a late lunch with a coworker looking to try something new. When we walked in at 1pm it was dead, they seemed excited to have us as customers and were happy to show us how their lunch specials worked. I opted for a single slice of cheese pizza, my usual test case for a pizza place. My coworker went for the lunch special that included a small side salad and a fountain drink.
My pizza was not fresh, and a bit too soggy and floppy, I made liberal use of the red peeper, Parmesan and black pepper to cover up what the pizza lacked in flavor.
There was a popcorn machine in the back with free popcorn, however it seemed empty and infrequently visited.
They do have many special on beer, and i think the only time this place is busy is before and after a basketball game at the adjacent arena.

This Pizza is LAME. I should have gone with my instinct that a downtown «pizza by the slice» pizza joint shouldn’t be completely empty at 11:30am on a weekday and gone somewhere else, but I didn’t.
The place was completely empty and it still took them 12 minutes to get me my two slices (which were huge).
I hate to say it, but the pizza completely sucked. The crust was so rubbery that I couldn’t pick up the slice without it flopping over.
For two slices and a coke I paid nearly $ 8 but I wouldn’t have paid $ 2 for that «food». I forced myself to eat one slice and then threw out the other.
Yuck