Pizza Plus

Quite possibly the best pizza I’ve ever had! And that’s saying quite a bit! Great atmosphere and service!

I have gone to this establishment several times with my wife and two small children. The quality of my dinner and service has varied. Sometimes very good, sometimes down right bad. The most recent visit was so frustrating that I will not go back. I ordered a meat Stromboli with mushrooms. I have ordered this from them several times. It was burnt on the bottom. Not just a bit more done than my liking, but down right crispy and black.
I said something to the waitress. She said she would show it to the cook. Upon returning to my table the waitress explained to me that it was actually not burnt, it was the way the oven cooked it. They would not be able to make another one. Wow! I was taken aback. Now burnt food is not the responsibility of the cook, rather the fault of the oven. Why not use tinfoil to stop it from burning. I can teach you how if you need me to. It is also funny how they used that oven to make me several Stromboli’s in the recent past.
It was insulting and frustrating. I know the difference between black from the oven and burnt. It looked burnt, it tasted burnt, and the bottom peeled off like it was burnt. I am not the only person to complain about burnt food here. Avoid at all costs!

Yummy, just had the penne a la vodka with chicken. The service was excellent and food prepared perfectly. My salad was made just the way I like it.

My first time eating here and the food was delicious and our waitress was attentive! Great job pizza plus I’ll be coming here from now on!

My boyfriend and I love to eat here. Their pizzas are delicious and the crust is always made just the way I like it.

Got their menu w/​coupons in the mail recently so I decided to give them a shot. Somehow a small pizza (half margherita/​half hawaiian), a tuscan panini, and a bottle of coke turned into $ 31 dollars and change. I called them up when I got home, and she said «Oh sorry, we charged you for a large pie by mistake, so we owe you $ 2. Next time you order, we will take $ 2 off». I did the math quite a few times — and even still I can’t see how it was $ 31 — it just doesn’t add up. I’ll be going in tomorrow to get my $ 2 back and to see what the actual breakdown was. (not to order more food). Regardless — this is just unacceptable in my opinion.
Now, my experience with the food:
My pizza was half margherita/​half hawaiian (big kahuna). The whole pizza was a little underdone. The hawaiian half was pretty good. Wish I tasted the ham a little more. The margherita half was not what I’m used to. With margherita — I’m used to big fresh tomatoes, fresh basil leaves, garlic, and fresh round slices of mozzerella. That was not the case here — there was no basil, no fresh mozzerella, and the sauce they used was a white ricotta sauce. Weird.
The best part of the meal was the tuscan panini — Breaded eggplant, prosciutto, on sesame bread. Absolutely delicious.
Bottom line: I won’t be going back — Pudgy’s has much better tasting pizza in my opinion — although even then, not really too great.

I been to this place three times now. My first experience was awesome. I had great service, food was good. The past two time have completely sucked. Tonight there was three waitresses and I could not get service to save my life. They say at the counter and jaw jacked. I literally had to walk to the counter to order. Then she asked if it was for here or to go. I said I’m sitting right there. They brought my food in a to go tray. This starts my frustration. Secondly I order a cheese steak. I get roast beef with cheese whiz on it. What the heck!!! Then as I’m trying to eat there is a guy with a dog who is smelling my crotch, trying to get to my food. How rude could people be, and how could the owner/​manager allow this to happen. I would highly recommend to go somewhere else, at least a place that is proud of their job and can handle customer service. I am very disappointed!!!
Well after tonight’s dinner at Pizza Plus I feel that the food was not prepared well. My stomach is completely upset. I feel as if I am going to throw up. I feel that the kids that work there are not properly supervised. Highly recommend this place be check for cleanliness, handling of the food, and properly trained in customer service.

The pizza is great, thin crust, well worth the price. We will definitely come here again. They also have a discount night. The service was good.

We heard about another new pizza place in town so we decided to give it a try. the first time we ordered from here, it was good. we ordered the fried ravioli and a pizza. the fried ravioli and the sauce was really good. The pizza wasn’t bad either. when we ordered the second time, we got another pizza and the sampler platter which came with mozzarella sticks, chicken fingers and fried ravioli. the pizza was below average and the chicken was the only thing edible from the sampler. the fried ravioli was clearly burnt and instead of making new ones, they served them to us anyway. the mozzarella sticks were under cooked. the cheese wasnt even melted and they were soggy. we may give them one more shot. sometimes everyone has bad days…

We used Pizza Plus to cater an event for around 80 people. We ordered about five trays of food plus a tray of salad. All the food was very good. The servings were generous. Several people at the event asked me who we had used.
They were very easy to deal with and very reasonably priced. For this area, I say — as good as it gets.