Rob’s Pizza

Pizza was unimpressive. The crust was burnt. Worse service ever. Charged more than menu price… and told us they raised it and menu is wrong. Had to wait twice as long as they said for the takeout pizza.

If I could give a negative star I definitely would. We’ve lived in the area our entire lives and NEVER ordered food from this place before, now I realize we should’ve never started. We called and ordered a large pie, wings, and a meatball parm sub for delivery. We had a $ 15.99 coupon for the pizza and wings and the sub was $ 7.25. My wife asked the price and was told $ 31. We asked them to check again and we got a new price of $ 25. Upon delivery the driver told us the price was now $ 28. I asked him why it was so high and he said he has no idea. Being that we waited about 40 minutes for our order my kids were hungry and I just wanted to let them eat. We immediately called the establishment and asked why the bill went up. We were told delivery was an extra three dollars. We asked where that was written on the menu and we were informed that it wasn’t, but they’ve been doing it for years and that’s just the way it was. Upon opening our disgusting and highly disappointing food we found the wings with an indistinguishable amount of sauce (served with Italian dressing!), and the meatball parm sub had no sauce at all!!! This place has got to be the nastiest pizza joint in the area and you’d think they would try a little harder with competition so close.
AVOID AVOID AVOID!!!
Try Toscos or anyone else!!!

I’m really only giving this place one star because pizza can never be bad enough to earn zero. I called for pizza and wings to pickup and was told they were out of wings. So I asked for chicken fingers which they were also apparently out of. I should have just assumed they were out of pizza too and left it at that. The pizza was flat out burnt. I couldn’t believe they would even serve that, they should be ashamed. All the pizza places in Pine Bush and Walden make better pizza, I can’t believe people actually think this is the best around. Hardly any sauce, skimped on the cheese and flavorless dough– except the crunchy black bottom. I don’t think that just being burnt was the only problem either, some spots were just brown and those were also devoid of taste. I was looking forward to this place because of the Unilocal!reviews, but was sadly disappointed.
*Just FYI, the picture doesn’t really do justice for the color. Also, a TripAdvisor review confirms their notorious pattern for burnt pies.

THE MAP LOCATION ON Unilocal is wrong. Hopefully this is not a case of Unilocal sweating them for money! Excellent pizza and heroes! Service was great as well. The restaurant was clean and the décor was pleasant. No beer or wine is the only reason this is not a 5. Would definitely go there again.

Visiting Wallkill from the South we wanted really good Italian food. We saw Rob’s and decided to give it a try. Are we glad we did! The Chicken Parm, Lasagne and Spaghetti with meat sauces was excellent. The portions were huge.
We returned the next day for pizza and it, too, was authentic and very good.

The pizza was just okay. NY style, good sauce, tasty crust, but the crust was very thin. They really skimped on the cheese and toppings. The staff was not very friendly or attentive, you could expect better even if it were in a big city. We ate pizza, but we’ll look elsewhere in the future.

The pizza is good as is the location. The owners are very nice, and the restaurant is clean and spacious.

The Buffalo Chicken Salad was delicious. It was a good size and really fresh. The pizza slices were very tempting. I’ll definitely be back next time I’m in the area.

Went in with low expectations but it was quite good. Mac and cheese pizza was one I had never seen before and it was good. Sicilian slice was more sauce heavy than cheese but still tasted good. Pleasantly surprised

Don’t waste your time: the pizza’s mediocre, and the other items on the menu were terrible. The best pizzerias don’t need to advertise: they have a big billboard. You do the math.