Nostalgia House Bakery and Deli

Get there early as many baked items sell out. Lots of doughnuts!
This is a small family operation. The décor isn’t fancy, tables are second hand, and the magazines are donated. That said, this team works really hard each day to provide good service, grow the business they dreamed, and support the community.
If you want lunch they offer sandwiches and fries. They have coffee on and you pick your mug. There is a small seating area inside or on the patio, though there isn’t really a waiter. Order at the counter and pick it up when it’s ready.
Request a cake or cupcakes for your special event. They also cater!

Uh. Ya. No. Not again. First of all, my Port Orchard friends kept telling me that I have to try this place because they have gluten free donuts! I was stoked!
I tried calling them multiple times to make sure they still had stock. No one answered.
When I went there, I asked about their gf doughnuts. The employee walked over to the freezer, dug around in there, and pulled out an old box of packaged, frozen doughnuts. What?! I don’t think so.
The regular doughnuts that I bought for my family were less than impressive and didn’t taste fresh.
Won’t return.

Great people who responded quickly by making a special occasion cake in less than one hour. The cake looked and tasted amazing. The price was very fair. The event was great and everyone was impressed that it was baked at a real bakery. No Costco cakes needed.

We ordered a bunch of sandwiches to feed the wedding party the day of our wedding. I never ended up eating one of them, but I heard nothing but good things about them! Thank you so much!

There’s few varieties of donuts. The apple fritters are alright can’t really taste the apple flavor that much. There’s a lady ordering in front of us with 5 kids and they are taking the whole display cabinet. this boy trying to get my order and rushing me even tho I can’t see what kind of donuts they have. When we went to the register to pay u can sense that they just want to get u out of there. Customer service needs improvement.

Positives: The doughnuts are great, everything is fresh
Negatives: They are frequently out of doughnuts. The hash browns were undercooked, as was the biscuit for the «Biscuits and Gravy». We ordered our eggs over-​medium, and they were definitely over-​easy (way too runny).
Overall, they have great food — but when they get busy, I think they feel rushed. Id rather wait the extra few minutes, and have my order cooked right, then get an undercooked order quickly.
I hope they can improve because I would really love to see this business stay open

So I’ve been among to come here for a while and haven’t because they’ve always sold out so fast! I heard they had to best donuts in town. I went with my mom very early this morning right when they opened. We got the dozen for $ 12 deal. We got one of a different kind; maple bar, some extra fried cake thing with glaze, bunch of doughnuts… And last but not least… I decided to grab a fruity pebbles dipped doughnut. I’ve always been skeptical of outlandish desserts but oh… My god… It was SO good. And I got mad because my husband almost ate the whole thing after I only got like 3 bites!!! Will definitely be going back for more of those. Otherwise, the rest of the food was pretty over average good.
One thing though; the apple fritters. I’ve had them a couple times now. And I would highly recommend adding more apple. Both times I’ve eaten one I didn’t taste as much apple as I would have liked.

Went recently for my first visit to this Bakery.
I have heard such good reviews.
Keep in mind — I am a foodie and a baker.
I got a half dozen honey wheat dinner rolls.
They were amazing!
I also got a doughnut (based on reviews)
Chocolate glazed doughnut.
Honestly it was not good.
I threw it away.
It tasted kind of greasy/​pasty.
It left a film in my mouth.
Like I said I’m a foodie– I’m picky about baked goods.
I will return for breads– but not for sweets/​pastries.

Best bakery in town. My son love love the lemon crêpe. I haven’t tried the cake that they make, the donuts are awesome! !

Great donuts, and sandwiches, best Philly cheese steak sandwich I’ve had a a long time yummy ! real steak and real cheese. !! AWESOMENESS! Good coffee too!

Nostalgia’s doughnuts never disappoint. Always fresh and delicious. The service is always super friendly. Their new location is nice and spacious, good for a sit down breakfast, but we usually just get the doughnuts.

Just went to pick up doughnuts this morning for my daughters birthday. Delicious as always! Chewy, perfect home style donuts. Never be able to stomach a grocery store donut again!

My boyfriend and I were in search for a gluten free cupcake and we believed that we’ve found the right place since someone on th phone said they carry it. Wrong! They didn’t even check until AFTER that phone call. We walked from the ferry to the bakery in the rain and almost missed the bus to find that they didn’t have it. They pointed us to the freezer that had gluten free, factory made breads and english muffins. False advertisement at it’s best.

I love this little gem. I have ordered both of my daughter’s birthday cakes here and they are beautiful, delicious, and completely affordable. I’m always taken aback when they tell me the price because I expect their cakes to be so much more expensive based upon the quality. They have numerous cake, icing, and filler flavors available. I’ve done buttercream icing for both cakes but they also do fondant.
I also love their donuts, and we have gotten hot sandwiches for lunch. Their donuts are awesome and cheap. I also usually buy a bag of donut holes to take home with me… I think a dozen is only like a dollar or something.
The ladies who run it are super sweet every time we go in, and I love to support this local business.

I went to their old location the first time and my husband went the second time– I had a good experience– his was less than stellar. When I went the ladies behind the counter were helpful, patient, and nice. When my husband went today they treated him as if they were too busy to be bothered by a customer. He asked about hot food (that was on the menu) and they flat out told him they were too busy to make anything. Any questions he asked were treated as he shouldn’t even need to ask. As much as we like supporting local businesses because of his experience I’ll be throwing away the «frequent» buyer cards. We’ll make sure to think ahead Sunday morning and buy from «That One Bakery» on Saturdays.

After an ongoing craving of fresh donuts for the past few weeks, I finally gave in to temptation and looked up a place to go pick up a couple.
Found this place, and oh my god, the donuts here are so delicious. My husband and I bought six, and they were gone within the day. The donuts were pretty cheap, and tasted amazing.
This is definitely a place I would come back to. Best donuts in Port Orchard.

Though this is their new location, the donuts are the same excellent product they’ve been making for years. Awesome fritters… especially the Black Forest… and maple bacon bars. They don’t have cutesy names or weird combos, just honest, well-​made donuts at a good price. Isn’t that what you really want? :-)