Sicilia’s Pizzeria

What a great place in all of my 45 years of living to have pizza! I had the original crust cheese pizza, and my son had the cheese stuffed… amazing looking his was! A true deep dish with oozing cheese and sauce, with a light crust. Mine was so delightful! Im happy to have tried this for the first time! Parking is tough here to find! I have no answers for it?

I got this as a home deliviery, was pretty mediocre. The box was all wet when the delivered it to me and so the pizza had gotten soggy… poor delivery.
The taste could have been much better as well

Outstanding pizza just simply the best in Rhode Island. Whether you’re a resident, tourist, or a wonderer. You’ll soon be a regular like me. The staff is friendly my favorite waiter is Wayne ask for him. He takes the cake. When you’re in town next time go. You won’t be disappointed.

I have to stop here every time I’m in town!!! Stuffed pizza is the way to go… sauce on top lots of great mozzarella cheese, salt crust.
One thing to know about deep dish pizza is, it takes a long time in the oven… you’re going to wait a while for it so you shouldn’t really complain about it taking long when they are up front about the time in oven. Just think you know you’re getting fresh pizza!
If you haven’t had it yet, they are very filling slices so unless you want leftovers order the smaller pies.

This is in the heart of Little Italy in Providence Rhode Island. Who would have thought it? Not I! I braved –34 degree wind chill to come out here and grab some authentic Italian food. This place did not disappoint! If you like pizza, especially deep dish Chicago style, definitely swing by here, and you will not be disappointed

Stuffed pizza is amazing! I don’t know where else I can get it in R.I. ~ so whenever I’m around Federal Hill ~ I always make a point to grab one. Soooo good!

Bought a large pie (8 slice) w mushroom, saysage, onion, pepper. Box was very heavy, and the pie was very tasty. Lots of tomato sauce and ingredients were tasty. Can’t really have more than one piece., as the crust is thick and filling. Liked it, but thin crust is our preference.

+Obviously delivery is an issue based on the reviews below but we were fortunate that our order came in within minutes of the estimated ten minutes time frame. Meaning it took about 50 minutes which was estimated on grubhub.
+Ordered a large Hawaiian pizza with pepperoni, pineapple, and mushrooms. It was SO GOOD. Normally I dont eat pizza but I couldn’t help myself from eating two slices. We had the «regular» but know that means its still pretty thick. Its not going to be the size of your ordinary pizza slice.
+Steak Salad with Blue Cheese Most of the steak pieces were pretty good but others tasted a little more on the raw side. But overall it was a very filling salad. it was really large included tomatoes, banana peppers, blue cheese, and the blue cheese dressing was really good.
–Sicilian Salad: I had a bite of my coworkers and this was pretty average. She wasn’t too impressed with it but among the many salad shops we’ve been to in Rhode Island this is definitely better than average.
+You definitely get a lot of food for the price so if you’re hungry you can be expected to be more than satisfied.

Dumpy old pizza place on Atwells. But hey, they do what they do as well as anyone. They don’t pretend to be anything that they’re not. They make a fantastic deep dish pie, that has a value level off the charts. A large pie for $ 20 will feed 4 people easy! Haven’t eaten in there, only take out, but there is ample room to sit and grab a beer with your meal.

I was really intrigued by this «stuffed pizza» so I decided to give it a shot.
My friend and me decided to get a large stuffed pizza with pepperoni. It says it would feed 4 – 5 people… I don’t think it would feed 5 people. It was a pizza with 8 slices. You may be wondering why I am telling you this? Well honestly when I’m looking up reviews I like to see if the large is worth getting.
Anyhow, lets talk pizza. So this pizza is interesting. I liked it but I’m more into thin crust so this probably wasn’t the best pizza for me. I did enjoy it because it was filled with cheesy, pepperoni goodness. The crust was a bit bland but nothing some ranch can’t fix. Also they have all the red sauce on the top so you could dip it in that too. I would definitely try this pizza because honestly THERE IS NOTHING LIKE IT… Well that I have seen.

Delicious deep dish pizza with great service. The waiter was friendly, efficient, and answered all of our questions, and the pizza was authentic and tasty.

Pizza was ok not great not good just ok. Mozz stick had weird texture. Tasted like arcade food cheap ingredients

Over an hour wait for deep dish pepperoni delivery + (My address is linked up to my phone number btw) I had to direct the delivery guy towards my house, I was so I enraged that I ended up meeting him a few blocks away from my home in the cold rain. This pizza place DOES NOT stand up to a pregnant woman’s NEEDS!

Absolutely will NOT order from here again. I used their online system for a very, very simple (medium, 2 topping pizza plus some chicken tenders) order. Got confirmation via email, got notification from my credit card that my card had been charged, and I waited.
OVER 2 HOURS!!! Still no pizza. I called after and hour and a half, was put on hold multiple times, asked for my address, phone number and order details (which was all provided online, when i ordered) and then was told they were out delivering so it would arrive shortly. That was ½ hour again and still no sign of them.
If I didn’t have a really hungry kid, I would call back and cancel and demand a refund.
Ridiculous. There are way too many other places for pizza for a place to be able to get away with such horrendous service.

I’m not crazy about deep dish ‘Chicago style’ pizzas, but Sicilia’s is so yummy! Most deep dish pizzas feel more like a casserole on dough, but theirs retains that ‘pizza’ quality. It’s nice and chewy. So so good. My only advice for those wanting to try a stuffed pizza would be to order early. It takes them about an hour (maybe more) to make it. It’s worth it though! :-)
The other favorite of mine is their burger. Omg… It’s huge! The patty is like a steak-​burger hybrid. It’s thick, but isn’t tough. I get mine with everything on it and by everything, think of what’s on a Whopper. Speaking of Whoppers, if you love those. then THIS is your burger. It tastes like a Whopper, but better, and much more substantial! The fries are superb too. Super crispy and salty. I’m making my mouth water.

Sicilia’s is my go-​to place for wings after a night at a bar. I order them without sauce, or sauce on the side. They are really crispy without being dry, and have a generous amount of meat on them. The sauce is hot without being overwhelming, but I prefer to use it as a dip, along with the blue cheese.
Last time I went, I also had a slice of pepperoni, which was tasty but since I’m not a fan of cold pizza, I didn’t eat the whole (very large) slice before it cooled. I did eat the pepperoni off of it, though. Yum!
Another note about this place. The service is consistently friendly. Not overly. Just enough.

Love this casual version of Italian on the Hill!
While parking on the Hill can be a nightmare — their location has always allowed me to find an on-​street spot within a blocks walking distance!
I know many Sicilia’s stuffed pizza lovers — but this is my go to spot for grilled chicken over fettuccine alfredo! It is so creamy and delicious that it is hard for me to stop eating it! The serving is plenty for two meals but sometimes, you just want to stuff yourself!
I love that it is casual and you can dine in (always had great service even though this does seem to be the starting point for servers on the Hill) or just call ahead and take it to go.
I have even stopped in late night and ordered at the counter then took it to go and was very happily surprised at how quickly they got our order out.
They have delivery (not sure of area covered) and a full bar with beer and spirits if you want a drink while you wait.
Is it fancy? No, but that’s not my thing most nights anyway!

Hey Sicilia’s you’re my new go to!
So, for some reason I was expecting a bit nicer of an interior, but I was just picking up food, not looking to hang out. It looked like every pizza joint in the suburbs. Bar on one side, booths towards the back, and pick up right as you walk in.
The staff was a little bewildered because we placed 2 orders under the same online account and despite reiterating like 4 times we needed to be rang up separately our orders kept getting combined.
Now most people have said the wait for their food is dreadful, our food was actually ready before we got there, 33 minutes after hitting send on our orders. So their 30 minute window might be accurate for off peak times/​days.
For the food. The baby size pizzas really are the way to go. I got the baby classic stuffed pizza with zucchini and mushrooms. The crust was flaky and perfect, and had that soft just cooked feeling where it touch the veggies stuffing it. The cheese was an awesome layer, fully coating the pizza. The only thing I could have asked for was more sauce, maybe put sauce in with the stuffing and on top of the cheese? A few times i felt i would have liked more sauce to offset the amount of crust. My baby pizza was cut, albet not too well, but I think part of that is so the insides don’t spill out, it was easy enough to trasnfer onto a plate and cute. I suggest using real utensils to eat this too.

Why I like you, Sicilia’s:
A. You’re open late.
B. Your phone number is perma-​pressed into my head thanks to a clever, albeit more offensive than the depictions in Sopranos, radio spot.
C. Your bathroom is crazy-​seedy, which oftentimes is fun to joke about. Like, «was it just me or did it seem like there was about to be some spontaneous dude-​on-​dude action about to erupt at any moment in there?» or «can’t you just picture Michael reaching into the toilet to pull the plant Clemenza left there for him, as you go?», type-​activity.
Why I dislike you, Sicilia’s:
A. Your delivery takes longer than forever. The order always arrives cold and the driver could give two flying mozzarella sticks.
B. Just because you’re open doesn’t automatically make your stuffed pizza worth the wait.
C. Your bathroom is crazy-​seedy. Which in all reality, is terrifying.
Having had friends who lived on Fed Hill for years, I’m no stranger to ordering delivery, walking over for pick-​up or pulling up a booth, drinking too much soda and then having to hold it for fear of using the bathroom.
Then again, 2−7−3, 9-​ah2-​ah2-​ah2.

Living so close by, I figured I would give these guys a shot. Can’t beat the prices for stuffed pizza, at least the baby cheese pizza.
The order was a little late when we went to pick it up, but the woman at the front was polite and even walked our order over to us as we were sitting at the bar.
The baby pizza could have been sliced a little more, as I had to get a kitchen knife to slice it and because it’s in a styrofoam box it got a little messy. I totally get why it’s in a small box, but please cut up the slices! A five star would be so achievable if the wait times were more accurate and the pie was sliced.
The pizza was great. Cheese totally complemented the stuffed crust. I can see where others are frustrated by the somewhat bland sauce, but honestly, it wasn’t that bad and tasted great next day cold.
As a new found resident of the hill, I know I’ll be coming here for my pizza pie.