Teddy’s New Yorker Pizza

I found this place on GrubHub and it said that they delivered to my office. I ordered mozzarella sticks, chicken strips, fries, and jalapeño poppers for myself and one other person. It took about an hour which for a Friday afternoon is pretty good. I also ordered a can of Pepsi. I asked for marinara and lots of ketchup. The guy, Rasheed came and was super nice. I went to my office and threw down on some yummy food. The fries were seasoned and super thick. All of the food was your typical delivery fare, but it was pretty good. I would order from here again because the food is good and the prices aren’t bad at all.

I was in the mood for some true New York pizza. The price was right and I needed delivery to my office. Unfortunately this tasted more like ordering from Papa John’s. I ended up giving it to the rest of my office. I’ll go back to Randy’s or Johnny’s next time.

Really good stuff!

I basically used Grub Hub to order this and it came in 40 minutes. I had the dozen wings and a dozen garlic knots.
The wings were tiny, like 3 inches. They’re not in buffalo sauce but it does have a little spice to it. Not too spicy though. I’m not complaining about the price.
The garlic knots were absolutely horrible. They had the taste of a stale NY Pretzel with a little bit of garlic salt. Not good at all. I had about 4 out of my 12 before I left them out for my drunk roommates.
Overall, not ordering the garlic knots ever again, but I will order the wings if I absolutely have no other options and are craving wings.

Ok, let’s talk Teddy’s pizza. they have a good thing going on over there as far as the Cheese Steak goes. As for the fast delivery that’s a flat out lie, and i’m going to tell you why.
I have ordered delivery a few times before and each time i was told it will be at least an hour and each time we were only ten minutes away from the restaurant.
Now that does not go to say that the food is not good, just don’t think your getting it anytime soon after ordering it. lol
but for the most part teddy’s is a good place to grab a bite to eat if your in the area. they have the basic pizzeria dishes and just how good is up to your personal taste. but i think they are ok, just make sure your order in otherwise get ready to wait.

Ordered delivery while staying at a local hotel. Fast and friendly. Chicken wings were decently sized and tasted great. Lots of pita wedges withe hummus, big thumbs up for that. My wife loved the pepperoni roll. Thin shell with the perfect amount of meat and cheese.

The service was very bad. The guy who answered the phone had a very bad attitude and is not willing to service his customer or to explain things on his menu. Ah, also, when I told the guy (who I believe is the owner as well) about his attitude, he acted as it is normal and he did not care. The food did not taste good either. If there is less than one star, I would give them that. It will be my last time there.

Ordered in from here last night & will not be doing it again. Unlike others, my delivery time was not a problem. But the food was awful. Garlic knots that were so greasy, they were sitting in a pool that literally filled up half the box. Pasta that was just not good — had a weird taste to the cheese and sauce. It was just not an enjoyable meal with tons of regret for trying and paying for something so disgusting.

Very disappointing. I was excited to find a place that delivers. It showed up 30 minutes after they said it would be there. It was cold. The pasta was overcooked and the sauce underwhelming. All in all not a success.
Wouldn’t bother going back.

I am from St. Louis and can tell you I am going to crave this place when I go home. The fresh vegetables mixed with the feta cheese and their dressing may have been the best I ever had. The delivery was not fast, but it also wasn’t slow by any means. I also got the chicken Parmesan. This was good, but my only complaint would be for more sauce. They also threw in a free order of there garlic knots. They were outstanding. I plan on getting this again before I return to St. Louis, and every time I come back.

First time eating here and got delivery from them and I live very close. It took over an hour to get here said a half hour estimated time, food arrived cold had to reheat it and the noodles were soggy and calzone had barely any filling. I may give them another shot since I live so close and read some decent reviews but I was not impressed :(

I’ve ordered from Teddy’s for a while now, and they’re great. They always get my order right, and their wings are okay – not great, but not bad. I haven’t tried the pizza, but I’ve tried the garlic knots (good, but a bit too oily for my taste); the mozzarella sticks (yum!) and the greek salad (very good). Their portions are ridiculously generous, and they always deliver within the amount of time they say they wil (30 – 40 minutes). Their prices are also very reasonable.
The first time I ordered from Teddy’s, I was nervous about how spicy the wings might be. On the menu, it just says «hot wings.» The guy on the phone said that they weren’t too hot (which was true; they’re mild, just a little kick, which is perfect for me), but he said that just in case, he’d throw in extra ranch and some baklava for free, so that at least I could finish off with something sweet if it was too hot for my taste. That kind of thing always impresses me. Plus, the baklava was fantastic, which helped.

Have used delivery several times, food has been good and arrived hot. The garlic knots are a must try if you like garlic bread as much as I, and very economical.

I’ve lived next to Teddy’s for a year and although it isn’t New York style pizza (I’m a NY’er) it is pretty damn good. It’s worth nothing that their pizza is better than Domino’s & all the other pizza restaurants catering to college aged kids in this area. Plus they’re located next to a Subway and I always choose one of Teddy’s sub’s over Subways. I like that they have a small case of specialty drinks like root beers & snapples, and more than everything else, I like that they’re a small, independently owned restaurant. That’s the kind that always gets my vote.

This is the closest pizza shop to our office. The pizza is not New York style at all, and this is coming from a New Yorker. Sorry, Teddy, whoever you are. But, I will say, it’s tasty. The crust is chewy, but one thing that definitely makes it not New York style is the size of the slices. They are more like Papa John’s size or Dominio’s. A New York slice is large and in charge, and often, you only NEED to eat one, which of course, doesn’t mean you will only eat one.
They have a wide variety of toppings, and for some reason, you can even get French fries here. I haven’t had anything but pizza, and I have never stepped inside to comment on the restaurant itself. The delivery guys have always been friendly and the prices seem reasonable, though I don’t ever pay for it myself. A lot of the guys in the office will get the lasagna and spaghetti and meatballs and seemed please. Also, the garlic knots are usually ooey-​gooey good!

I hit Teddy’s up one time when I was visiting a friend in Raleigh and was too… Well, too drunk to drive home. I said it. I get drunk and eat pizza. Care to join me?
Teddy’s bears a lot of resemblance to other local NY-​themed pizza joints. Unfortunately they just don’t have the edge that the places I’m used to do (I Love NY Pizza, for one). The pizza slices aren’t as large or as flavorful (I can’t speak for the pastas). They don’t come out as fast or as hot, and the guys working there aren’t nearly as nice.
Are these unfair comparisons? I don’t think so. Who else should I compare Teddy’s to? It’s far from the best around.

A lot of the pizza places in the area don’t offer as varied of a selection as Teddy’s does. They’ve got pizza, cheese sticks, salads, pasta and more. I’ve probably tried it all over the course of the last few years that this has been my pizza delivery place of choice, and I still continue to order from here.
A lot of what they serve is great – the pizza especially. Some other dishes can be hit or miss. I’ve never been knocked out by any of the pasta dishes, for example. It’s still a lot better than Papa John or Dominos.
I’ve only had one problem with the delivery, and that was when I ordered once and my pizza didn’t show up till like an hour and fifteen minutes later. Again, that’s one time out of probably two dozen. I’ve ordered from them since and had no problems.