Reily Pizza

Great rural dive atmosphere. Sauce and toppings are above average quality. Pizza is cooked in 30 year old oven. They should Buy one level up on crust, or better yet make their own crust and charge $ 1 more per pizza and the rank goes to 4+ stars. Oh and on Mondays dollar domestic cans. Other days $ 2. Make the drive. Worth the adventure

OK Riley pizzas is not fast a food restaurant so have a beer or two while you wait. y If you’re in a hurry or just plain rude or inpatient you may want to go somewhere else. This one of the best places you could ever get a pizza or a steak hoagie its considered one of the best hole in the walls in Butler County…

Hear a great deal about the place and since its next to Indian Ridge, thought we’d try the pizza people were talking about. The service was alright, greeted right away, but the pizza did take about an hour to make and get. The pizza oven is small, so they can only handle a couple at a time. Nothing spectacular about the pizza, the longer it sat, the soggier the crust. Not what I expected after all the talk I heard…

Best pizza in town! Great atmosphere. Not built for the uptight white collar folk. Great service, great people! Nothing better than going out to Reilly’s, phoning in a pick up order and enjoying a cold beer while waiting for the best darn pizza in the land.
To those who only gave it one try, please go back and give it another go around. You won’t be disappointed at all!

This place just stinks! From the service to the ciggy smoke they still allow! Heck, the people making the pizzas were smoking!
I had heard so many good things about the place I had to check it out. I took my wife and three kids there last Mother’s Day. When we got there the place had about three other people in the place. I had a beer and ordered one large and one small pizza. After an hour of waiting a large group from Indiana came in. Their pizzas came right out hot and straight to their tables. Apparently they called their order in. I waited a total of one hour and forty five minutes for two pizzas!
I sent my family to the car right before our pizzas came out. After the bill came, which they offered to take nothing off the bill, I politely asked the man that rang me up if I could speak to him outside. After I got him and his mother outside I began to explain how I had heard great things about their place and had to try it out. I explained that I had to wait 1 hour and 45 minutes for two pizzas. They explained the large group phoned their order in just prior to my arrival. I told them I understand, but a mention of that when I ordered my pizza would have been nice, as I would have left had I known I was gonna have to wait almost 2 hours for pizza. I then explained that they could have comp’ed me at least some appetizers as we waited! The guy then told me that it was Mothers Day and they were short staffed, and kept making excuses for the unacceptable service. I let them know I wouldn’t be back, and then they finally offered to make it up to me by giving me a pizza «next time»! Sorry there won’t be a «next time» for this family!
Don’t bother wasting your time on this place!

I’ve heard from so many people that Reily Pizza is some of the best around. It’s definitely true. The toppings are so generous and it’s not super greasy. I would try the steak hoagie as well, and the wings look great.
This place has been around a very long time and has a lot of character, with its original wood and ovens. Good for a casual hang out and cheap beer. Smoking is still allowed inside but it’s not overwhelming. This is an ideal escape from the expensive, noisy Oxford establishments.