Jimmy Jims Deli

Jimmy Jim’s has been a great addition to the area from the moment it arrived. As a longtime Noyac resident I can tell you that living in Noyac has its positives and negatives; and one of the negatives has long been lack of retail convenience.
Well I’m delighted to announce that the days of driving into Sag Harbor for a cup of coffee are gone. This is the niche JJ’s fills. Here you’ll find all the standards — breakfast sandwiches, coffee, lunch sandwiches/​wraps etc.
Yet JJ’s brings some unexpected variety to the table. Their ice cream is off the hook, and you can buy by the pint or quart as well. But they also have some outstanding Mexican specialties — particularly tortas (Mexican sandwich, which is just like a sandwich except a bazillion times better). Long a staple of local work-​a-​day contractors, these are quickly becoming a crossover hit. Kinda like Shakira when she started also singing in English.
I’m awarding an additional star for stocking: a) Valentina hot sauce (including the hard-​to-​find extra spicy version) and b) Yucateco green habanero hot sauce. The owner gave me a sample of their homemade tomatillo hot sauce, and I would rate it up there with the best I’ve had.

I just paid $ 10 to get a smoothie that is disgusting. I’ve been here before and had a good smoothie, but I asked for a substitution because of an allergy (as I always do) and this person gave me a cup of Unblended kale water. I can’t even drink it because they did not take out the almond milk like I asked.
I called and said that I was unhappy and they didn’t seem to care much. Not surprised.

Does Jimmy Jims have a comprehensive menu of combo sandwiches?
Do they also offer salads, chips, drinks, smoothies, ice cream, salads, and more?
Do they need a better system of ordering (a line, perhaps?)?
Did a little girl inexplicably punch me in the butt as I waited?
Are the ‘Euro’ baguettes great options (#s 13 & 15)?
Did I claim that I was trying to be healthy, and then order a chicken cutlet with bacon, melted cheddar, and ranch dressing?
The answer to all of these questions is «Yes.»

Love this place! Everything is made fresh on site, even the pastries! Many, many healthy options including organic juices and smoothies. The coconut ice cream is worth the trip alone!

Stopped here for a quick breakfast sandwich and coffee. The food was delicious, coffee was great and the prices aren’t too bad either! I would recommend and go back — everything is well made and fresh and the service was good too.

Vegan chocolate, assortment of morning hot breakfast, kombucha, plus HEMP MILK half the price of provisions! AND to top it all off right around the corner.
Plus the lady behind the counter was a dear. Nice homey, local owned shop. I love me some community supporting so I’ll definitely be back!

$ 18 For BLT and spinach and egg whites. No toast no juice no coffee! No way I will ever go there again! The service leaves much to be desired! I could go to the Golden Pear at these prices And the food would actually be good!

I always come here for great breakfast sandwiches when I stay in Sag Harbor. Im really pleased to see nice updates to the shop since last summer. Love it! Will be back next summer!