MJ Dowlings

Everything is good. Food portion is generous and delicious (steak salad). Bartender is friendly, as are the waitress and wait staff. Beer is fresh on tap. Hope it stays this way, as I’m a local.

MJ’s is an excellent go-​to for me. My favorite thing on the menu is the mount misery burger; 2^nd would be the fajitas or the buffalo wings. You really can’t go wrong here.
They also have an arugula salad with fried goat cheese balls that is amazing for any fellow goat cheese lovers. When in town this should definitely be a stop on your list.

BEST chill bar in the hamptons. Eddie was so cool as a bartender and super vigilant when it was packed– literally every time we needed a drink, he was there. And. At the end of the night, he played WU-​TANG.

Today we’re started with the potato skins stuffed with pulled pork and topped with muenster cheese. It had a kick so there must be chilies in there too.
They must have some sort of evil genius working in the kitchen.

Out for dinner treat this dark November night in the Hamptons and immediately on entering this local fine pub/​steak house, one is immersed in a friendly and happy place which quickly lifts the Autumn gloom from one’s tired spirit. Tap beers from Montauk and Brooklyn served just right. Great curry beef lentil soup, deliciously thick and hearty. Perfect (discounted Thursday’s) burgers with interesting fixings. Fries particularly full of great home made taste. Chocolate lava and pumpkin crême brûlée to wrap up excellent dinner served by attentive warm staff. Large mugs of excellent coffee. Reasonably priced. Cheerful owner known to us from previous excellent restaurant One Ocean, present on site and clearly has another highly successful place that locals and tourists are drawn to!

We went 2x this summer.
Both times with a crowd. One time just moms & kids, another time it was 2 families. Both times the service was awesome, the food was awesome and the place was lively without being too noisy. I always call for a reservation and we were seated immediately. I highly recommend MJ Dowlings and will surely come back next summer when we return to the Hamptons!

Heading home craving a steak but not wanting to sit at a restaurant, I check Unilocal to see what was enroute and this popped up. I called in and ordered the hanger steak with mashed potatoes and veggies.
Pick up was a breeze! Got home and was pleasantly surprised!!! Oh my goodness!!! The steak was perfection!
Perfectly seasoned and cooked to order and topped with fried onions. it was delicious. Every bite more delectable than the last. The mashed potatoes were real potatoes and had a bit of lumpiness to give it that home made feel and the veggies were steamed Al dente then sautéed in a bit of garlic and salt and pepper.
A simple steak dinner. What more could you ask for?
I can’t wait to come back and order more!

MJ Dowlings is my «go to» spot when I want something good for dinner but I don’t know what. The burgers are fantastic, the calamari without equal, I love the wedge salad, and the steak is terrific. I know I can go there any night of the week and get the special, and it will be delicious, filling and priced in such a way that I don’t feel robbed. I’m there at least three times a month. Very good and very affordable. Great selection of beers on tap, and generous spirits pours. You definitely should go there.

Was their last nite for dinner, happened to be fajita nite, they hit the spot with a Margarita, you can tell it’s a locals hang out, lots of t.v.s over the bar, live music, will definitely be back

Fajita night. They were delicious. Nice casual place to eat with a variety of options. Service could have been a bit more cheerful and the overly drunk men at the bar could have been told to pipe down.

Really nice staff, but food was so/​so. We ordered calamari and french onion soup which was fine. Then I had a veggie burger, wife had corned beef and my daughter had chicken fingers and mozz sticks. Everything was well seasoned and fresh, but it was all overcooked and some burnt. Too bad, really nice place, but the chef has to take it easy. A little pricey too, but OK for Sag Harbor I guess.

If you like a good quality burger this is the place. First class meat cooked to perfection charbroiled. Top off with home cut fries… Heaven!

MJ’s is an okay pub-​food bar joint. The food was terrible, and service mediocre. I would come here for drinks and the atmosphere, but would certainly eat elsewhere. I’d be surprised if anything is homemade.

Me and my 2 friends went their for dinner 2 of us ordered the same burger asked for medium rare burger both came out super raw when i asked waiter to send it back came back yelling at me that is was medium rare you dont yell at people buying food then to top it off desert the brownie was burnt /​when he brought our check he had a attitude 97 dollars rip off dont waste your money

I read review a few down «Best $ 9 burgers»
They must have changed the prices. I was recently there and paid $ 16!!!
Sautéed onions, mushrooms and Swiss cheese, $ 16. Really?
It was a small hockey puck. Not even close to being worth $ 16, $ 6 maybe.
Unacceptable!
Baked clams $ 11. I was served 3 of them. In all my years ordering baked clams I never got served 3… That is just a weird amount. I can see 4 or 5. But 3??? And they were cold… Strike 2
She ordered their prime rib. $ 30. It was tasteless. Strike 3. Your out!
The saving grace was the New England clam chowder. $ 9. Excellent taste
Home run, 5 stars…
I had 3 beers and she had a Malibu bay breeze.
Summary, I paid $ 102 for New England clam chowder, 3 beers and a Malibu bay breeze. And the kicker is: I drove 50 miles to this place… What am I, a schmuck on wheels.

So delicious. Priced excellent. Staff is very polite and attentive… Mussels a must… Garlic bread too. Burgers and roasted chicken, mashed potatoes… Yummy.

Great burgers! However the owner that was there needs to pay attention to the amount of drinks they sell to patrons for one group was loud and obnoxious. She knew it and didn’t say anything. Shame on you for these people need to drive home.

Nice local restaurant in Sag Harbor. The food is very good, but a little pricey and the ambiance isn’t great. It’s a bit too bright, but a nice place to come for some good home cookin food.

Everything there is great, the food, drinks and service (the quality of both is great.)
A great place for friends and family. they have pool and games.

Now been twice. Up to five stars from four. Quality pub food at a reasonable price. I am a fan.