Broadway Pizza

Great pizza! We ate-​in one time and picked up another. Friendly staff, quick service (10 – 15 min for take out, but I did hear that delivery was an hour out cuz they were very busy on a Friday night), and consistently good pizza. This will become one of our regular pizza take out places.

I went in for the first time once, so this review is for this one experience. I used the buffet, which is all you can eat I think for approx 9.00. It happened to be I was craving exactly that basic lettuce salad bar and ranch, (DELICIOUS) and the various pizza slices were DELICIOUS, and the PASTA with garlic bread was EXCELLENT tasting and hot. I will be back for that buffet.
I didn’t get any more than that, which looked like soda, cookie and soup options. The manager helped me out with the fact that I needed to actually get it to go on a rare one time trip, he was very helpful in getting me what I was requesting, and I’m glad he did as it made my day.
He does seem to have a loud voice, he needed me to repeat and speak up for him to hear me correctly, although he was standing right next to me as I asked my question, he said I was talking to softly for him to hear me, (which is what most hearing loss people say to talkers when they don’t want to admit to themselves a hearing loss) after reading some other reviews, I have a feeling he just has some hearing loss, like me, it can cause someone to talk much louder in general, and the mistakes and giving info and numbers to him over the phone more than once likely were due to his hearing I assume. All the signs are there in my opinion as I am familiar with hearing loss symptoms. :)

Placed an order for delivery over the phone and gave the gentleman my credit card info. We’re less than a mile from this location, so when he said 30 – 45 min, I was pleased.
Got a call back 5 minutes later, and he needed to verify my address. After giving him my information for the third time, he informed me it would now be 2 hours before they could deliver.
I cancelled the order and now have an order in for Tasty Pizza. Will be here in 30 – 45 min.
Consider me a lost customer. Won’t make that mistake again.

I ordered a pizza from here for the first time for delivery and was happy with my order. It was very hot, fresh, and delicious! For delivery of pizza, that is a first time that I’ve had hot, and delicious pizza so good. I’ve ordered from other pizza places for delivery but Broadway pizza really delivered a great first impression on me. I will definitely order from here again! Great job!

Ordered my pizza and paid by card. Repeated myself three times over the phone for my order. 10 minutes later the guy calls back and needs my card again, turns out he entered the wrong order, so now wanted to enter the right one and charge my card twice. A twenty dollar order turned into a fifty dollar order! He said I’ll get my money back on the first order but it would take three days. I tried to make it clear I wasn’t happy about being out $ 30 for the weekend but he didn’t seem to get it. Finally after about an hour delay due to this process my pizza finally showed up and guess what. It was still wrong!!! And cold! Had I wanted to make my own pizza I would have. Oh, and the best part is the guy I talked to was the manager. No coupons, no comp, nothing. Haven’t ordered here since then. I’ve given my business to tasty pizza and parkway pizza.

It’s reasonably priced and close by but blah. Very un memorable. I’ll pay $ 6 more somewhere and get something decent.

I love Broadway Pizza! This location shocked me. As we were the youngest people there. The other downside is that there isn’t one closer. I like the fact that they have a Buffet. It should be in the evening too.

DON“T SUPPORT THIS BUSINESS!
After my experience yesterday I will never go to ANY of the Broadway Pizzas (I do realize that they are probably owned by different people-​but don’t care)
After carefully pulling into the parking spot in the strip mall that contains Broadway Pizza, Jersey Mikes Sub, a liquor store and a few other businesses, a cranky man came running out, screaming that I could not park in the spot because it was for take out only, I said that there was no sign in front of the spot, like the other 2 spots??? as this was going on another Broadway Pizza employee came out and said that we should be fine if we were just going to get a quick sandwhich next door. So my friend and I continued on with our day, and went to go grab lunch, thinking to ourselves how could one guy be so angry about a parking spot– GEEZ… Keep in mind I was NOT in front of a no parking sign and there were SEVERAL other open parking spaces including the 2 that he had his take-​out only signs infront of.
We chose the window seat at the sub shop to watch and see if this was «normal» behavior for this guy and to see if he did it to others. as we watched, we saw him get into his car and pull up behind mine to «block» me in and then went back into the pizza place. we were both in shock. We sat waited about 10 minutes to see if he was going to return to his car. he did not, so I went up the one of the employees at the sub shop and told him what was going on and asked if he would escort us to our car because we were scared of this unstable individual. the sub guy said he does this a lot and is just looking for an apology. THERE WAS NO WAY I WAS APOLOGIZING BECAUSE I DID NOTHING WRONG! The sub guy went into the pizza place with us and asked him to move his car for us, he started screaming at this guy saying «he was going to move his car when he was damn well ready, and that we needed to show him some respect!!» –keep in mind he did this in the middle of the pizza place, with the few individuals who were eating to witness.
At this point I said I would just call the Police if he would not move his car, he told me to go right ahead, so I did. We went out and sat in my car (locked the doors because we were scared of what he might do now, and because he was still blocking me in) and waited for the Police to show. about 5 minutes later he came out and took off in his car. shortly after that the Police showed up. They told me I did nothing wrong and even if I was in front of one of his take-​out only signs (which I wasn’t) they could not enforce it… We all agreed that this guy is a loose cannon and told us we should leave and they would take care of it from there. They went into the Pizza place to talk to the guy, but he was already gone.
We left, and will never be back to any Broadway Pizza. Our Safety felt threatened and all over a parking spot (with no sign).This guy has issues and I recommend that everyone stay away from BROADWAY PIZZA in St Anthony for your own safety!!!
Oh Ya-I’m assuming this person is the owner/​manager because I can’t imagine any business putting up with this type of behavior from an employee.
Cheers:)