Insomnia Cookies

Ordered one cookie a la mode. One hour later, still not delivered. Called, they said ti would be here soon. One hour later, finally arrived. Cookie old and hard. Ice cream melted. No.

Awesome! Cookies were warm and soft with just a very little crispness on the edges. Forget the reviews about not being greeted and go enjoy cookies fresh from the oven!

What’s better on a cold wet windy evening than a fresh warm cookie. I hadn’t been to this cookie ship before, so figured I’d drive over and give it a try. Had a white chocolate macadamia nut and a peanut butter cookie. They were pretty decent. They were not anything special to write home about, but decent cookies. I can see more stars from others for delivery service. Just the fact someone will deliver fresh cookies to you is deserving of a few extra stars. However, the cookies themselves, I’ll give them three stars.

The cookies are absolutely wonderful… but since we ordered for delivery rather than take-​out, it took longer than we’d expected for us to get our cookies. Despite the slow delivery speed it was all fine :)

What is better than fresh baked, still warm cookies delivered to your door? Nothing. I ordered the chocolate chunk, oatmeal raisin, double chocolate chunk, snickerdoodle and even a double chocolate brownie. Yeah I know but if you’re going to order at least make it worth it. These are all amazing tasting cookies. I prefer a lot more cinnamon on my snickerdoodle but they were still pretty tasty & I’ll definitely order again.

Just had these for the first time. Got the snicker doodle and Reece’s Cup. AMAZING for a dec price. This is the pink box of St Louis

For my 400^th review I would like to write about cookies.
Warm and gooey cookies are hard to resist! I have visited Insomnia a few times now and each time I have had a pleasant experience.
I remember walking by Insomnia the first time and just smelling the aroma of freshly baked cookies. It already had me planning for dessert. I was meeting a friend down the street from Insomnia Cookies and so I couldn’t stop right away, so instead I went to dinner and discussed cookies for dessert. Thankfully I have a friend who appreciates a good cookie and so it wasn’t hard to convince her to go with me! We walked in and were greeted right away. The girl behind the counter provided us information about the cookies and made a few suggestions. I think my first cookie was the M&M (obviously)! So warm and gooey. So good. She even put it in a cool little box since she knew I would be saving it for later (or so I said). I did actaully only eat half right away so it was a good thing to have the box. I also was thinking ahead and I picked one out for my bf. He deserved a cookie too; I ordered him the PB Choc. Chip Jumbo cookie. Yum!
For my most recent visit, I went with a friend who lives in U-​City. I recommended going here for a snack. We took a short walk and arrived around 7 p.m. She was planning on visiting a friend later that night and wanted to bring snacks to her as well. So I ordered my S’mores cookie and my friend ordered a few of the other kinds. I can’t remember which ones, but I know they all sounded and looked good. I am so glad I have a friend who lives so close because I really do want to have a girls night and order cookies for delivery. I can’t believe they deliver cookies! I have to try it.
The cookies aren’t that expensive and since they are fresh and warm I am willing to pay for them. Next time I go I plan to add some ice cream and make a sandwich!

Ordered at 10:30 on a Sunday night with an estimate of thirty to forty-​five minutes. An hour and a half later as we were debating calling to see what had happened, the cookies arrived. In a gesture of apology, the delivery guy gave us an entire second box of cookies that apparently were extras in the store… thus doubling our supply. Needless to say, the quality matches the quantity. TY Insomnia. TY.

What can I say about a place that will deliver warm, fresh from the oven cookies with a nice cold bottle of milk? O. M. G — thank god there is not one near me or I’d weigh another 100lbs.
They have a large selection of fresh made cookies that you can order with or with out ice cream. I sampled the Deluxe Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, the Triple Chocolate Chip, and the Smores. Each was warm and gooey that went down perfectly well with the chilled glass of milk.
They are open until 3am and will deliver within a certain radius. Do yourself a favour and if you are in the area, stop by and sample the goods!

The novelty of a cookie delivery place is definitely exciting. That’s why I expected more from their options – a cookie restaurant should have unique cookies, not classics like m&m, chocolate chip or double chocolate. Why not something crazy? That being said, I like desserts, and even though they were a bit generic they were good. This visit I went into the store and got a brownie a la mode, pretty amazing. I think I have to try a cookiewich soon.

The chocolate chip cookie and peanut butter cookie were DELICIOUSSSS, warm, crumbly and sweet.
What I don’t like was the cashier who worked behind the register. She didn’t smile or acknowledge us coming in. She didn’t say hello to us. She kept a poker face while we deliberated on which cookies to buy. She wasn’t helpful at all and she looked like she’d rather be home! In fact, I didn’t want to order from her because I felt that by being in the store, I was making her time even more bothersome.
The management should fire her ass and hire someone who’s actually friendly, bubbly, and outgoing. I ate at other places on the Delmar Loop on that same day and I can tell you that everyone else working were very friendly and had good attitudes.

OK, but not that great. Definitely expensive for cookies that are just so-​so. Service was kind of slow and definitely unenthusiastic. We stopped in after a concert since we wanted a snack and everything else was closed. Took care of the immediate craving but not somewhere I’d seek out again.

Insomnia cookies, more like insane cookies. Tonight I was in the Delmar loop having dinner and wanted to go to insomnia cookies to satisfy my sweet tooth. As soon as I walked in I was immediately overwhelmed by the 10 people standing in front of the register not being helped. Finally someone with long uncovered hair walked to the register and slowly took the order of the people in front of me. After she took their order she twirled her long hair/​extensions and without gloves got the customers their cookies. We were so disgusted by the level of uncleanliness we walked out.
We went back home, which is with in the delivery radius and decided we still wanted the cookies. I spent 30 minutes googling and even called 411 and they could not find the number. How could a business not have a store number easily accessible on the INTERNET ?! We finally found their 800 number which was not even on their website! When I called I was so confused that I had to talk to someone in a call center in PA to order a cookie in MO?!? I’m not calling for dell tech support or ordering an exotic pet! I’m ordering cookies from a store less than 4 minutes away! The call center didn’t know what cookies were made in my local store. They had to go on line and literally look up what was on the menu. They didn’t have the prices or any information on specials. I chose to make my own after the level of incompetence I experienced tonight.
I really like the cookies, especially the smores cookies. Its a shame they were unable to have a ordering model that made sense. Why can’t you have a local number? Every legitimate business has a phone number. If I wanted to order cookies for a party or check my order status, how would I be able to do so in a timely fashion. I would be a regular customer if I could call the store and speak to someone in my area.

I LOVE COOKIES! Warm cookies too. So as my Friday night dinner group was strolling down The Delmar Loop, I opted to try a few Insomnia Cookies at 6301 Delmar Blvd. in St. Louis.
I had the chocolate chip and also the Snickerdoodle cookies. Yes, they were warm. As I continued to eat the cookies. .. I discovered that I was not getting any taste of the cookie. The cookies had NO taste. .. Period.
I understand that the rent in the Delmar Loop is some of the most expensive rent in St. Louis for retail space. .. but I could seriously get better tasting cookies from the grocery store with the cookie dough tube and slice it/​bake it myself.
Will not be returning to Insomnia Cookies. But I will be going to the grocery store to buy raw cookie dough. ..

My curiosity was peaked when passing Insomnia Cookies one evening in the Loop, so I stopped in and grabbed a few cookies to go. Your basic cookies start at $ 1.35 each, however discounts are available if you purchase a dozen or more. Jumbo Deluxe cookies are $ 2.75, which is rather high for a cookie however once you bite into one you will see why! I ordered a two Deluxe cookies, one Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup and a S’mores, both were moist, soft and very delicious however still felt that $ 3.00 for a cookie was a bit much. The store itself is in a prime location, and I am sure it will do well, however I will pass and opt for something more local than a national cookie chain.

Oh my those were some delicious cookies! Tried a white chocolate macadamia nut and a triple chocolate chunk after a show at the Pageant. Restored all the calories we burned off dancing! Great place for a late night sweet treat :)

I’m somewhat embarrassed to admit I’ve ordered cookies delivered to my place. For just myself. Twice. I never thought I would be so decadent. But when you’re staying in and working on a cold night, hot fresh cookies delivered to your door is a nice little way to reward yourself. Unfortunately now I have a new vice in my ever-​growing quiver of self-​indulgence. Just knowing this stuff is available till 3AM every day is dangerous. If you have problems w/​compulsive eating, read no further.
Insomina cookies solves a tough first-​world problem I call The Freshness/​Variety Cookie Conundrum. Generally, you can have fresh cookies, or you can have a variety of cookies, but it’s hard to have both at the same time. Insomnia solves this problem by constantly baking lots of different cookies all the time, and bringing them to your door while they are still warm. Just opening the box (similar style to a pizza-​box) and seeing an assortment of delicious fresh cookies is enough to make you extremely patriotic.
The ordering process through the website is very efficient. Once you create an account, you’re a couple clicks away from cookies at your doorstep.
My first time I went for a dozen standard cookies ($ 14) I did 2 of the following — Chocolate Chunk, Double Chocolate Chunk, Double Chocolate Mint, Oatmeal Raisin, White Choc Macadamia, Peanut Butter Chip. They were all pretty good. I was hoping for a little more creative options, but you can’t mess with the classics. I was very excited when I opened that box. I’d just take little nibbles of each cookie. It’s more fun that way.
The second time I tried out some of their deluxe cookies ($ 2.75 apiece) The Smores cookie and The Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup cookie were pretty great. The Smores in particular, all warm and gooey (pause).it left an impression.
Both times the orders arrived within 30 – 45 mins. I’m not sure if there is a minimum delivery amount but it’s probably pretty low.
Enjoy responsibly.

Saw this place while walking around Loop. Obviously can’t stop myself from trying out new cookie store, so I went in. It first reminded me of Dominos pizza delivery store, it seemed like majority of their sales were delivery. I don’t have any problem with that after all I wasn’t planning on eating it there.
However, I do expect a good service. The girl at the counter seemed annoyed when I came in. anyway, I got three different cookies, she took it out from a draw. I think its a place where it stays warm, so I have no idea when it was made. All I know is it was warm. I tried the white chocolate and macadamia and it tasted great, however after few bites it had this strange aftertaste. I felt like it was made from poor quality ingredients and/​or sitting in that draw for little too long. I am no expert on cookies but I have had very unhealthy level of cookies in my lifetime.
Anyway, after trying the first cookie I gave up. Didn’t try the other two.
Tip to Customers: If u do go to this store, know that the little larger cookies are twice the price of the smaller ones, so get two smaller ones. However, I think some of the cookies are not in smaller version.
Tip to the Owner: You are selling cookies not chicken wings, appropriate environment with proper seating and smiling employees will go a long way to build loyal customer base. Review your pricing, use better ingredients and you can charge more.

I was really excited when I heard that The Loop was going to get a cookie shop! I miss the cookie connection back home dearly and have yet to find anything in St. Louis that is comparable but I think… MAYBE…Insomnia Cookies can compare.
First of all I am not crazy about the name, its not that catchy and kind of hard to store in my mind for when I am thinking of cookies. Secondly the shop is really small, its right next to Snarf’s. The interior is kind of plain jane. Nothing really stands out and makes me go wow. Not a lot of character going on. The display of cookies is a bit pitiful, they could have done something else to make the display more appealing to the eye and appetite since I am shelling out almost $ 3 for a cookie. Oh the price! what were they thinking??? I personally think the cookies should be a lot cheaper… a lot cheaper.
So are the cookies good? YES YES YES. I had the chocolate chunk and the S’mores cookie. They pull them out of a warmer so the cookies are literally right out of the oven feeling. The chocolate is gooey, the marshmallow was sticky and all of it just melts in your mouth. One of the supreme size cookies is very filling and I do not think I could eat two of them without feeling sick.
I am a very big fan of the cookies! I like that they are open really late. Everything else I do not care for and I really wish the prices were better, but that wont stop me from coming here again in the future.

I was pretty stoked to find out that the Loop was bringing in Insomnia Cookies, a late-​night bakery chain that specializes in warm, gooey cookies. My first experience was at my undergrad at UIUC, munching on eight cookies for a $ 4.20 special on ⁴⁄₂₀.
In general these cookies are expensive. $ 1.35 for a traditional cookie and $ 2.75 for a deluxe cookie. My favorite is the S’mores deluxe cookie which taste like a cozy campfire in your mouth. I love the melted marshmallows and chocolate chips that melts in your mouth. Also the hits of graham cracker chunks in between bites. Since there was a $ 5 credit card limit, I ordered a Snickerdoodle which was a tasteless disappointment.
If you want to pimp up your cookie, get the cookie a la mode or the cookiewhich. Pick your favorite cookie and the ice cream to give you a major sugar rush.
Insomnia Cookies, it was nice knowing ya and reminisce my college days. You definitely fit the Loop scene.