The Pie Pizzeria

I love the Pie. I truly do. Actually, I thought I had written a review for it a long time ago.
Anyway, their cheese pull aparts are amazing!!!
I’ve had their chicken and bacon pizza, which is good but what keeps me hooked is their cheese pull apart and their chicken ceasar salad.
Prior to today, I would’ve given them 5 stars but as I’m eating their delicious chicken cesar salad, I find a bug in it :/​Not cool. So I’m not sure if I’d get a salad ever again but I can’t fully promise to keep away from that place.
Besides, have you tasted that Ranch sauce. It’s the only Ranch I live by.

Fantastic pizza? Check. Great beers on draft? Check. Extremely satisfying meal for 4 with alcohol for $ 30? Big check.
When I said I would be vacationing in Salt Lake City, locals and some friends had all consistently suggested The Pie as a classic for anyone near the U. Walking around, we did get a little confused because there’s a location that does delivery only just around the block, but they kindly pointed us in the direction of where we should be going.
The pizzas were huge, and everyone overestimated how much we could eat so a 14″ pizza would have been close to perfect for the 4 of us. The ambience reminds me of a college bar or an NYC pizza hot spot with low lighting, exposed brick walls, graffiti all over, and the basement entrance. Would definitely recommend to the next SLC tourist I run into.

We get takeout from here all the time. I really like thick crust pizza and this place delivers every time. It’s consistently good so you know you’re going to be having a good pizza every time and there’s no letdown of, oh they forgot to put cheese on part of the pizza or sauce on half the pizza like some other spots that I’ve had issues with. The quality of the ingredients is always top notch if you’re not into the crust they also have thin crust options and just really great toppings.

Oops wrong review. I’ll update this next since I can’t seem to delete it.

Delicious take out pizza and super nice people. We ordered and picked up 15 minutes later, nice & hot, and full of flavor!
We ordered BBQ pizza and it was great and full of chicken.

I don’t understand the high reviews as I absolutely do not like their pizza. Loaded with all kinds of toppings it’s still lacking taste and flavor. Costco pizza is ten times better.

Best pizza I had in this town… My pizza had just the right amount of ingredients and the quality of it came across in every bite. I highly recommend this place to any pizza lover.

Yes. Everything about this place, yes. I’d like to take this moment to thank my cousin Nikhi for introducing me to this place. lol jk but really, if you want good pizza/​sides for a decent price then you can’t go wrong.

Good pizza but this place uses and wastes so much styrofoam that its offensive in this day and age. They will lose my business until compostable or paper products are used for their carry out pizza slices. The individual slices are placed in a huge styrofoam container which are too big and awkward to carry, and also extremely wasteful and toxic. Please consider being more environmentally friendly and replace all of your styrofoam.

So good and it really is one of the best places to eat in town! Try the cheese bread and be ready to be stuffed!

The Pi Pizzeria is a great spot for visitors from out of town and college students to hang out and enjoy some pizza, however the quality of the pizza is in my opinion very overrated. It’s your typical pizza similar in taste to papa johns or little ceasars. It’s decent but it doesn’t deserve the praise it receives.

Out of towners visiting the area, craving some good pizza.
Picked this place due to the great reviews.
This place was ok… Sauce & crust were good, but the cheese was so thick & greasy it ruined it for me.
Napkins & plates were saturated with grease, wouldn’t recommend the cheese pizza. Maybe the others options are better…

The Pie rules! Amazing pizza and beyond amazing ranch. The service is always great and fast, and the pizza is always out of this world even if it’s just cheese pizza! The cheese pull aparts are amazing, and don’t get me started on the cinnasticks. The Pie will always be my favorite pizza spot.

Don’t bother going to the crowded, pretty dark and dirty sit-​down location around the corner — The Pie is all about their pizzas and you want to enjoy these beauties in a nice, peaceful environment to soak up the pizza goodness.
Some of our favorite pizza in Utah but the restaurant is a little gross so just grab the takeout at this location and enjoy on the lawn at the U around the corner or at home on your couch with a good movie.

Love the cheese pull a part! It’s huge and yummy. The pizza is kinda salty. They have pizza in slice as well. We didn’t know that…

This is the take-​out/​delivery only outlet of The Pie, necessary as the original place on 200 S., while unbeatable for ambiance and the actual pies themselves, was just not really ever conducive to take-​out or delivery. Of all of The Pies, this is the one I probably utilize most and like all of the locations, for over 20 years running, this restaurant chain has never done me wrong. Not only not once, but never even close to once. They are, in point of fact, a very model of consistency.
One major thing going for these guys in their favor is that they are dead on as far as timing. If they tell you a specific time, bet your bottom dollar that pie will be waiting for you, fresh, hot and likely as not, already boxed and just waiting for you to plunk down your shekels and fight the urge all the way home to dip into that hot gooey goodness, to contend with the debate of burning of the mouth and dripping grease all over your shirt as you try to slug down that dipping front end of the triangle before the whole thing busts loose and plunges into your lap or to gnaw your lower lip raw trying to hold back the urge to lift up that lid just a touch to see if there’s any pieces hot and/​or loose enough to free easily. Sometimes I get smart and put it in the backseat, but then my mind convinces me that if I have to brake suddenly, I won’t be able to save it careening to the floor and that is an unacceptable risk. It’s the kind of pie that must be protected at all costs and get to the destination safely… if a bit smaller than it left.

Still like this place, even more so now that they offer a vegan cheese option. We brought some out of town family here and it was a huge hit. Loved the extreme veggie and can’t wait to try the wise guy. Balsamic on pizza? Yes please.

Love it! They have vegan pizza and vegan pull-​a parts it’s so delicious. Great place to end a good night of partying.

I don’t normally write reviews, but we had such great customer service at Pie Pizzeria Delivery that I just have to. Zach was the MAN! Seriously, best customer service for takeout I’ve ever had. Skip Pie Hole, hit up the Pie. Oh, and the pizza was incredible. Thai Pie and Wise Guy, just do it.

The pizza was okay. I had pineapple & ham, where I ate three slices there & two of the remaining three slices after the last round. I ate here on ¹⁰⁄₂₅.
The layout of the restaurant downstairs was cramped & a bit confusing — I actually got lost trying to find where they put out the pizza for you to pickup. I felt like the tables pushed in on you a lot even when people weren’t at the tables. The restaurant did fill up due to the Utah vs. USC football game later that night.
The pizza was okay, but after hearing everyone at the University of Utah talk about this place in their recommendations, I expected to fully enjoy this place & want to come back. Unfortunately, I have neither feeling.