Pine Lake Pizzeria

I love pine lake pizza but it is something I get on occasion. It is a minimal wait which I like and has great crust. I hope everybody can try their great pizza

Great pizzas — love their crust! Sometimes the wait can be a bit longer then anticipated on a particularly busy night.

Update: ⁵⁰⁄₅₀ chances of getting what you ordered, reduced to 25%… C’mon guys, the food is good but are you not listening when I say sauce on the SIDE? Ever heard of acid reflux? Too much tomato ruins my meal and causes pain! I guess I’m done trying to call in my order. I might have just given up all together though.

Wasn’t impressed. I was a walk in, and the kid at the counter told me there was a 10 minute wait, not bad I figured. Well, where he came up with that I have no idea. try 40 minutes later, I finally got my pizza, with no apologies, nothing. Come to find out the crust is horrible and tastes like cardboard. As I waited I watched a few other mess ups happening. The same kid accidently hung up on a guy and then also charged the wrong card for another lady that was on hold waiting to pay. I realize young high school kids need to make money at a job, but don’t put them behind the counter without the proper training, much less some basic people and customer service skills!

Reminds me of Papa John’s, for more than twice the price. Started with the combo pizza, but had them take off 2 items and then add 1 different topping. Of course, got charged more for the «extra» topping.

Please PERMANENTLY expand delivery to the Highlands and I’ll upgrade to five stars!
You’re better than Round Table, you’re even better than Zeke’s, and I can’t stand Amante or Flying Pie. Not that my opinions are all that interesting, but if there are others in IH who feel like we do that our pizza delivery options are woefully limited, it might be worth your investment to add driver capacity and reliably provide some better products and service to us over here just to the south. As it is, it feels pretty awkward to call and place an order, only to find out you’re doing us a favor by delivering to our home, which Yahoo Maps tells me is 2.08 miles from your shop. And that’s when you agree to deliver at all, which you don’t always do!

There are several options in Issaquah and why anyone would go here more than once is a mystery to me. The woman who answered the phone and took our order seemed to care less (and ended up getting it wrong) and was borderline rude. We did a pick up and brought it home. This is by far the most tasteless pizza I’ve had the displeasure of eating. Honestly when my boyfriend asked how I liked it I could only say «it tastes like water» as in no taste whatsoever. We ordered a half/​half and they managed to leave off half the toppings we requested. Oh yeah, I ordered a couple of tiramisu’s and come to find out they’re not made there but kept frozen in a little plastic container. Took 30 mins. to thaw out and the amount of cocoa on top had me gagging. They shouldn’t be allowed to call it pizza. Seriously, go elsewhere.

Wow! They make the BEST pizzas I’ve ever had! It’s cool to watch them toss the dough in the air! Friendly staff and also fast home delivery. Pizza arrives hot. I especially love the BBQ Chicken and also the Sausage pizzas. Highly recommend!

Sooo… I’m not one for pizza. But I wanted something that I THOUGHT would be better than Papa Johns and Dominoes. but unfortunately its all the same crap.
This place is not great.
The pizza is… ok. the prices suck and way to expensive for what it is. but in Sammamish I guess a business can get away with that.
The Alfredo sauce cheeese pizza was pretty good, but thats just cheese. can’t really mess that up.
Sauce sucked, bread was not up to par.
Did not at all compare to the pizzas I had in Italy and France… BTW in France the pizza was wayyy better than Italy.
Anyways, I will not be coming back.

Great pizza… Andrew runs a great place in Sammamish. Very helpful and supportive of local schools — invovled in the community. Ask him sometime about the pictures of him and Jennifer Lawrence :)

I can’t understand the bad reviews?
We had the combo pizza and it was one of the very best we’ve ever tried and we come from a very Italian area and we know our pizza. Service was quick and friendly!

I’m not particular about pizza so much but my girlfriend is, I asked her what in particular was the issue, she said It was a «hot circle of garbage». I didn’t think it was great or anything, was certainly expensive for what it was… meh, they employ people and its probably not poison, I don’t have an issue with them.

Average pizza at best with high premium pricing. Recommend other options.

Great pizza! Their wings are awesome too! A little pricey but the pizza is definitely worth it.

We have just moved to the area and have tried every pizza place in town, trying to find our «go-​to» pizza place. This place takes first place. I like my pizza to be balanced, not too much crust, not too many toppings, not too much sauce… Crust was on the thin side but not like cracker crusts. It was cooked thoroughly and had a nice crunch with a soft interior. The sauce was a tad sweet but not over powering. The toppings were fresh and plentiful. I placed the order to go and it was ready in 20 minutes. The service was good and the gentleman that took my order was friendly. We will be back! :)

We were in the area on several occasions, the girl at front counter was blah not the friendliest and pizza is rather on the expensive side. 6 pack of soda was almost $ 4. We don’t plan on going back anytime soon… it wasn’t horrible but it wasn’t great. They could stand to brush their pizza crust with some flavor too.

The absolute worst.
Slow delivery, unfair prices, crap pizza.
The sauce is plain awful. The pizza is a joke. I could microwave some cardboard, throw some garlic powder on and it would taste 100x better than the slop their serving up here. The management is also terrible and the manager yells at their paying customers who are left unsatisfied.
Stay far, far away.

Huge fan of Pine Lake Pizzeria. In my opinion its a cut above the standard fare at the likes of Dominos and Pizza Hut. The price is a bit higher but its worth it for me. Definitely recommended for those looking for a change of pace from the large pizza chains

We’re a big fan of Pine Lake Pizzeria. Although I feel it’s a bit on the pricey side for pizza, I have to say, it’s our favorite pizza joint around here. The crust and sauce is really what makes this top notch. We live outside the delivery zone, so we drive up to the plateau from Issaquah. If you like Pagliacci Pizza, then you’ll like Pine Lake.

I am surprised to be the first to write a review. This pizzeria is one of the better ones on the Eastside. I drive to the plateau from Issaquah to get their pie. Other than Tutta Bella, Issaquah does not have any good pizza. Flying Pizza seems to think that if they make their pizza weight a ton and add a lot of garlic the pizza will taste better.
I know this pizza isn’t the best.
One gets this pizza because it is close by, reliable in quality, has tasty ingedients and the folks there are friendly.