The Ultimate Cookie

a few of their products are very good — the chocolate cake, the pecan bar and the brownie w nuts. The rest of the items – and I’ve tried most of them are pretty mediocre – mini cupcakes are extremely dry and lacking flavor, most of the cookies are not distinctive, pretty much on par with Safeway brand. They’ve been around a long time so clearly many people like what their doing – go figure.

I have not dealt with this company directly, however, they supply the local Glenview supermarket on Fruitvale, Farmer Joe’s. I’ve had their chocolate brownies twice, and they are phenomenal, chewy and dense and chocolatey and not too sweet, just yummy. Farmer Joe’s has some other options which I will be trying if I can get past the brownies.

(See pic)
Review #1007.
The door is usually closed and it’s like a secret cookie factory, except the cinnamon and butter aroma is so strong that it pulls you there even if you are across the street!
Cookie Monster would completely take over this place if he finds this place!
They usually have cookies available on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Fridays if you do not want to call ahead and order.
The cookies are very, very delicious and something to dream of before, during and after.
Must come back for the cakes too.

My local corner store carries a lot of Ultimate Cookie treats and on my way home from work I decided to pick up a couple.
I tried the Apple Cinnamon oatcake. It was delicious, but sooo filling. I ate half and saved the rest for the next day. The dried apple was amazing (hands-​down the best part) and it felt really healthy. Unfortunately, after some googling it looks like oatcakes are highly caloric. It makes sense given how dense and thick they are.
Paired with a cup of coffee, it is seriously, the best.

MM snickerdoodle cookies! they sell a lot at the mills peninsula hospital on trousdale (burlingame). mostly of their cookies and a few muffins.

This is the best chocolate chip cookie I’ve ever had in my life! It was moist, not too buttery, not too oily, and perfect amount of chocolate and cookie! It was amazing.
Not a fan of the Molasses cookie but I just don’t really like that flavor and appreciated the workmanship into the cookie!
I can’t wait to try other things.

i just wanna say u guys r the best no other bakery holds a candle over them… ive been purchasing products from there for my business for over 14 years and there amazing i love the new york crumb cake and oat jacks and pumpkin cheese cupcakes… they would get 5 stars if there werent so exspensive!!! o well… when i think about there price i would give them actually 3.8

Another adventure in wholesale land. Ultimate Cookie is, in fact, not famous for its cookies but its pumpkin cream cheese muffins and apricot oat cakes. But as they only sell them by the dozen (and you have to call ahead), I had to wait until I had a good excuse (in this case, Bay to Breakers). The verdict? The muffins are super-​moist and taste just as good as they sound (and to me, they sound incredibly good). The oat cakes aren’t nearly as sinfully appealing, but they pack enough oats to power a horse, and following Jen D’s suggestion (heating, buttering, and jamming) will turn them into a drool-​worthy delight as well.
And hey, if you really don’t want to wait, you could always just buy 12, eat 3, and surprise your 9 coworkers with fresh-​baked goodness one morning.

Had a chocolate cookie from here and it was as good as a simple chocolate cookie could be. Prices were still a little bit high for what I was expecting.

very rude customer service!!!

I saved review #400 for Ultimate Cookie. And the funny thing is — I’ve never had one of their cookies yet! But I have had their Oat Cakes, which are pretty much my favorite pretty-​healthy food going. They’re fat free, obviously full of oats and dried fruit, and taste amazing. Freaking amazing. Here’s how I prefer them: nuked 30 seconds in the microwave, cut in half, and put a bit of low fat butter (Brummel and Brown) and no-​sugar added jam on it. Remains low-​guilt and tastes even better.
I was guilty after trying half of one of their pumpkin cream cheese muffins, but it was 1000% worth it. That was pretty damn fabulous like another reviewer has mentioned.

I should say first that my rating is based on the service I receive from Ultimate Cookie and the response I’ve gotten from the people to whom I’ve sent cookies.
Ordering is easy and the staff is helpful. They were helpful describing their different treats to me when I was placing an order.
I have a brother in Chico who has a subplot to the story of his life: the search for the best peanut butter cookie. I sent him a mixed box of peanut butter and chocolate dipped PB cookies from Ultimate Cookie. He loved them. He says they were right up there with the best he’s ever had.
Another time I shared one of Ultimate Cookie’s treats with my sister. I unfortunately don’t remember what cookie it was because they gave it to me when I was receiving an order from them for my work. All I can say is that it didn’t look like your typical flour based cookie. My sister called me a few days later because she had to tell me how much she and her husband LOVED the cookie. She admits that’s she’s not that much of a cookie person anymore (I think four years at Mrs. Fields did her in) but she was blown away by this cookie. She had to resort to expletives to convey how much she liked the cookie. For the record, she excused herself for the foul language but she was compelled by the power of the cookie.
So I believe my siblings when they tell me how impressed they have been with what comes out of the Ulitimate Cookie kitchen. And I’ve always been impressed with their service. Treat yourself, have a cookie. (or an oat cake, if you’re into that kind of stuff)

Warning:
This is a wholesale place. Trust me on this point: you cannot just walk in and buy stuff (well you can try but what you’ll get is just too random). Your best bet is check out their website and order stuff.
Why you really must order stuff from this place:
They have the BEST Pumpkin Cream Cheese Cupcakes and Chocolate Cream Cheese Cupcakes. I don’t know how they keep the cream cheese from baking to the point of dried out grossness, but they do. If you ever get the chance to try either cupcake (ideally you’d have both), you must. It’s so so good you’ll be going to their SF HQ and try to buy some: again, trust me on this point.