Munchies on the Key

The pizza we got was just OK. We’re from the Philadelphia area and have vibrant, addictive pizza there; so the benchmark. The shell and the cheese was good but the sauce was ho-​hum. We’re still searching for a truly Northeast caliber pizza nearby. Also the pizza was overcooked as the cheese was generally blackened and crispy.

Great food and super friendly owners. The philly cheese steak sandwich was yummy and onion rings!

Read the reviews so we decided to try it. We have been to Siesta Key several times and this is the best pizza we have had here. The fountain drinks are Pepsi products. My wife doesn’t care for Pepsi so we bought two cans of Diet Coke out of the cooler. The girl who took our order came over and asked us if would like a couple of cups of ice and straws. As for the TV being on Fox News we were told we could watch something else if we wanted. The girl brought us the remote so we could choose what we wanted to watch since there wasn’t anyone else in the dining area. They were plenty busy though taking delivery calls. We ordered the white pizza with pepperoni. It was delicious. I personally liked the crust. There was plenty of cheese on it. Since it was a large pizza and there was just the two of us, we had enough leftover for tomorrow’s lunch. In our opinion a great place and we are definitely going back there when we want pizza. The girl also gave us a quarter because we didn’t have any change when we ordered an extra drink.

Fantastic pizza! We ordered cheese sausage and mushroom pizza. It was some of the best pizza we have ever had. We will probably order again while we are here in Siesta Key.

Wow. Called them to order a pizza about 30 mins before closing. They delivered it in 15 mins. Glad not ordered from them before. Great pizza. They recommended the Chicken Parmesan and it hit the spot. We had a sleeping baby, they called when they left the store so we could meet them outside. Thanks guys. Great customer service and pizza.

Great pizza and hot dog. The owners even gave me a slice of their breakfast pizza and it was delish! Great family owned business!

Great little family owned place. The food is delicious and no corners are cut when it comes to the quality. Siri told me to come here. I was on siesta beach and I ask her to find me a ace that delivers to my current location. Brilliant !

Un petit restaurant à la déco kitsh, géré par un couple de retraités très acceuillants ! Vous pouvez y déguster des pizzas, des pâtes, des salades, des calzones…
Nous avons pris une pizza personnalisée de 16″ (soit 8 grosses parts, nous étions 5 gourmands pour la manger) qui était délicieuse ! Bien garnie et peu coûteuse (16,50 $) !

Amazing!!! Smells so good right when you walk in the door! Don’t be tempted to goto the competition next door! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time!

We here over the 4^th weekend and hadn’t known of this place and «tried» to order from another pizza place 100 ft from here. 15 minutes on hold and hung up on led to here. Just a «Mom n Pop» place but you won’t find nicer people who haven’t forgotten about customer service. We loved their pizza but it could have been days old and I would have eaten it because they are so nice.

Sweet older couple who provide the type of service that make you feel like you’re at grandma’s house — helpful, polite, and pleasant! Great subs, probably would avoid the pizza if you’re at all snobby about it. But fresh and fits the bill for munchies!

Pizza was way to greasy. Thought it would be good since it was a small place but I was wrong. Food was awful.

Upon walking in we should have known what we were getting ourselves into. On the outside the place looks inviting and like a great local shop to pop in and grab a bite to eat. The building is painted with bright Key West style colors (which a friend had compared to a used car dealership). He was not far off! The ambience is that of a hospital cafeteria! Flat/​white/​lifeless. The owner was sitting inside drinking a beer – which was kind of funny, it’s as if he were treating the place as his living room. They had FOX NEWS running… Which is not the most appetizing of channels. We came here to escape from reality! Ordered two large pizzas and order of wings… Can’t go wrong. But we were wrong!
Didn’t feel the urge to dine in as we were staying across the street in a much finer environment. We popped the boxes open to make sure we had the toppings we requested… Only to find two pizzas which to put simply… Resembled DIGORNIOS! Like… Honestly. They claim their pizza is freshly made… I highly doubt this. I have friends who have made better pizzas in the comfort of their own homes! For the price and location I figured there would be a little more attention put into their pies. Not sure if they’re frozen, but is definitely not authentic tasting at all. The wings were. Wings. Hot sauce was nothing to write home about. Next time I will chuck up the extra few bucks and try the pizza shop next door. The smell of pizza lured me in but their quality drew me out. Must have been The City Pizza we were smelling. –_–

Ordered take out pizza & salad… good food & very reasonable prices. Did notice the place isn’t very updated, and maybe seemed a bit chaotic but wasn’t really an issue for me as I was only getting a take-​out order.

I was travelling and in the area and tried this place on a recommendation. First impression was that the front of the store was a bit disorganized. The place opened recently and it was clear that they were still getting signage and the dining area put together. The food, on the other hand, is top notch. The pizza was excellent and I had some great garlic bread too. Great flavor, top quality ingredients, and a very friendly staff.

Great little spot! A friend of mine who’s renting a place down here told me about this place, said it was kinda new, so I stopped in for lunch. Cute older couple owns this place and said they’ve been there about 3 months! I had a roast beef sub and it was delicious! Generous portions and very satisfying! The place smells exactly how you want a sub/​pizza place to smell! Great food, reasonably priced and the couple who own the place are just as nice as can be! I’ll definitely be back!

Ordered the white pizza. Great cheesy flavor. It was that authentic quality cheese flavor. Nice to have the BYOB option too with a store next door.