Who would have ever thought that a pizza place in Saugerties would have good pizza. It was by far the best NY style pizza I have had. It compares to the best I have had in The Bronx. I would go out of my way for this pizza. Service was great, Atmosphere is very good. Highly recommend.
Niv S.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Short Hills, NJ
The pizza is tight and all the other items on the menu are pretty good. Would highly recommend the grilled Chicken Sub and the Italian wedding soup. A great NY pizza establishment. Swag OD. 9⁄11 was an inside job. end the NWO
Lea C.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Hastings-on-Hudson, NY
Very nice pizza by guys who are fast and meticulous. Clean. Only down side and it’s a deal breaker in my world, there are 4 large blaring TVs in the place all tuned to different channels. It’s painful to be in the place. The lights are overly bright and by ½ way through the meal I’m exhausted. 1TV near the staff, IFTHEYMUST, is a bummer.
Jeremy K.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Glastonbury, CT
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA this is why Unilocal is the sauce, cause pizza star is the sauce! i do remember coming here, like when there was a caldors next door, whose with me?! yaaaaaaaaaa
Rodriguez R.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 Morrisville, PA
Pizza was a little greasy , Pepperoni was excellent as was the garlic knots I hate a place where you have to pay for refills Wish they had English ESPN on too Perhaps this is how NY style pizza is supposed to be
George G.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Carteret, NJ
Looking at a business card, it says ‘Starway Café’. I was really confused as it has been over a week and I dont remember going to a café/diner. Well, the pizza portion of the business is in the back. Parked there in the thunderstorm and went inside to order. They had Sicilian pizza on the menu, so ordered one of those. It was about 14 $ and filled up 2 guys for both dinner and breakfast the next day. While I waited, the employees were nice enough to refill a water bottle for me. Before I left, loaded the pizza with garlic, oregano, and red pepper flakes. Its good to know this place exists for future trips to the Catskills for hiking. Pretty decent pizza!
Amanda M.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Long Island, NY
Gave this place a try after a few people recommended it. Great crust and flavor. The cheese didn’t seem gooey, but that was after the 15 min drive home before I ate it, so maybe it was from the wait? Will try again.
Mandie V.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Catskill, NY
It astonishes me that I have yet to review Pizza Star! So here we go… I really like Pizza Star. It’s SUPER consistent, reasonably priced and quick. I’ve never gotten anything bad there(although their garlic knots are nowhere near as AWESOME as Tori G’s…seriously, check out their pepperoni garlic knots!!). The service is really great too. I once was there and saw a dad and his probably 4 year old son come in and order slices, and the owner(I think?) cut up the one slice and brought it to the kid, which I thought was really sweet and thoughtful. As far as I’m concerned, Pizza Star is my pizza preference!
Violet R.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Garrison, NY
Pretty good pizza, but I love the eggplant parm. Also the antipasto salad was REALLY good!
Justin T.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Saugerties, NY
If you want to find some authentic New York pizza in Saugerties look no further. This place has awesome pizza — thin, cripsy bottom with a great sauce and just enough cheese. Their sausage rolls are amazing as well. Pizza Star has been a Saugerties landmark for over 20 years. There is definately a reason behind their longevity.