Lulu Cake Boutique

I got my wedding cake from Lulu’s last year and I am so glad I did! Not only was it the best wedding cake I’ve ever had, but it was the best tasting cake I’ve ever had (this is coming from someone who bakes a lot and has been on a mission to try every famous cupcake place in NYC and DC). Additionally, they translated a beautiful design I saw on Martha Stewart’s website to a gorgeous cake (as a side note I highly recommend that brides check out her website for inspiration)!
They also provide a service whereby they provide you with a fresh topper for your one year anniversary, which I thought was a very nice touch. They were incredibly accomodating and kind when we asked for a second topper and then had to change our order again at the last minute. Best bakery around and my husband and I will be buying all our special occassion cakes from here from now on! Thank you Lulu’s :-)

This Place Is The BEST! I strongly recommend lulu cake boutique. We used them for my bridal shower and wedding a year ago and then our one year anniversary this weekend. All their products are easily the best I’ve ever had (and that means a lot because we go to Michelin star restaurants regularly with the best food in the world, and still this place has then best desserts). Not only is everything delicious but their work is so beautiful I have had nothing but compliments on my wedding cake day of and pictures a year later. My final product was amazing and I wouldn’t choose any other cake in the world over what I had.
In addition the owner and all of his employees are the kindest most considerate people I have ever encountered, they are super accommodating and make a genuine effort to make your experience with them so easy.
I can not wait for more events to arise in our life so so we can buy more from them. Even though it’s a little bit of a ride for us I will gladly continue to use them over any other bakery especially for special events.
Thank you Lu Lu for making this anniversary so great!

Skip the cookies, go for the cake. There’s a reason it’s called a «cake boutique.» This place is all about the cake — pricey, yes, but moist and flavorful. I was considering ordering a birthday cake from Lulu’s so I stopped by to taste test a cupcake — delicious! Just make sure to follow their directions and allow them to come to room temp first.
The cookies by the pound were enticing, so I picked up a few to sample as well. They were so disappointing. Everything looked amazing, but the ones I tried were flavorless and seemed a few days old.

The cupcakes here are AMAZING. Actually, everything I’ve had from this bakery has been both delicious and beautiful. These are great pastries to bring over to someone’s house or get for a special occasion. Coffee is solid as well. I recommend getting a cupcake and coffee and sitting in the park :) Also their window displays are always gorgeous.

When you walk into Lulu’s you they make you feel like the most special person in the room! Their staff is friendly, and so talented. A big Thank you to the team at Lulu’s for creating a what can only be described as a masterpiece for my daughters baptism! It was the centerpiece of the party and admired by all! The banana cake was so moist and delicious! I can’t wait to see what you will create for her first birthday!

I think i have eaten every single thing there. There is little space to eat so it is definitely more of a take out place. Everyone is so nice there service presentation and fast. I personally love the twinkies but if they have pieces of cake available GET IT! I literally begged for a birthday cake from there and I’m 22… This place is a dream come true so if your special day is fast approaching, you need some comfort food or just want cake for lunch head to Lulus.

Bought a cake from here for my bf’s mom’s birthday. The cake was gorgeous and soooo delicious. It wasn’t overly sweet or anything. It was perfect. We didn’t order the cake, but we just walked in and took what they had available. Everyone enjoyed the cake for days. We will probably order from here next time.

Lulu Cake Boutique!
My absolute favorite cake & pastry boutique in ALL of Westchester county. We have been using Lulu’s for years now! Every single celebratory occasion we go to Lulu’s! No question. All of our family and friends rave about the cakes we bring! Everytime we visit the boutique we are received by an artist with a smile and a warm welcome; Always! Their customer service is outstanding from beginning to end. We have literally tried all their cake options and we love all them! The flavors; textures and execution of their product is worth every penny! My favorite is coconut dream cake & country red velvet. We love Lulus cake boutique so much we have chosen them to make our wedding cake! Because they are the simply best!

I’ve had Lulu cakes for many special occasions and I’ve always had a great experience working with them.
My favorite thing about their cake is that it’s not terribly sweet and the cake is really moist. I’ve tried the hazelnut, the salted caramel and my favorite, the coconut. Their cakes look good and taste even better. The buttercream flowers are gorgeous. Always friendly service with a smile, Lulu has sweetened many milestones for our family.

After ordering my second cake from here, its only right i give them due praise
This cake boutique, shop, bakery, what have you is on top of their ish. They make excellent cakes and you can tell they take pride in their work. The designs are flawless, cute, and the cake flavors are amazing. I’ve ordered the brooklyn black out, and recently the boston cream for my brothers birthday. Moist cake, great flavors, great layering, cakes are huge! And well worth the money. I will def be recommending this place to ppl in the near future for weddings and celebrations etc. im happy i tried them and will continue to use them for many events to come. And im sure their pastries are up to par as well, havent gotten my hands on those yet though

I did it all for the cookies! About once every other month I pop in a get a small box of assorted cookies. Pretty much one or two of each kind. I usually can’t remember what kind I get but they are all amazing. Creative and delicious. It’s all good!

I went to this cake place just based on their amazing reviews. I usually do not disagree with these types of reviews. I have to admit I was impressed with all of the flavors they offer for cakes. I emailed someone from the site… I think it was Jay who emailed me back and said he «could fit me in on Saturday if they had no other bookings». This is not the only cake place in town honey! If you are not happy… go somewhere else.
Someone was nice enough to call me from a message I left on their voicemail. And we booked a tasting. The woman who greeted us the day of the tasting seemed very cold and strange… not warm at all. Second turn off.
Tasted the cakes… they were good… but way too sweet! I had a stomachache after the tasting for hours.
A lot of other bakeries offer these different flavors and are much nicer.
Honestly if the service was better then my decision would have been a lot harder.

I only sampled a small piece of rugelach, but it was delicious. I was surprised that it contained raisins (maybe this is standard practice) but I enjoyed the thorough mix of nuttiness, sugar, cinnamon, and raspberry (my chosen flavor).
Looking forward to trying the $ 4 cupcakes next time. Guess I’ll shell out the dough (sorry, pun).

Wow… this cake almost stole the show… surprise birthday party for my wife… honestly, every guest asked about this cake… more than a few thought it was a real bag before they were told otherwise.
Thank you so much to Jay and his wonderful team of artists and chefs… the look of the cake ALMOST beats the TASTE, which was fantastic!
Thank you!

We ordered our 3-​tier wedding cake and additional satellite/​sheet cake for our September 2014 wedding at Bear Mountain from Lulu’s, and the entire experience from beginning to end was super easy. The cake was really important to us, but we had a lot of disparate ideas that didn’t really mesh together. During our in-​person consultation, we felt like Emily was really listening to what we wanted, and did an amazing job of incorporating our ideas into a single, cohesive design.
The cake itself turned out even more beautiful than we had hoped, and we got so many compliments from our guests, and even our vendors. It also tasted SOOO good – we chose three flavors: Passion Fruit, Black Forest, and Red Velvet– and the textures and flavors were just perfect. It was by and far the best cake I’ve ever had. We had some extra, which I took to work a couple days after the wedding, and some of my coworkers are still bringing up how good it was!
The entire staff at Lulu Cake Boutique was super responsive and always answered phone and email inquiries quickly and completely. Delivery the day-​of was stress-​free and coordinated directly with the venue– I didn’t have to worry about a thing!

Does a shared namesake prevent me from writing an unbiased review? Possibly. But you’ll notice a glowing recommendation of lululemon is not among my stable.
A friend’s dad was kind enough to ship me a box of Lulu cookies. Though they arrived a little worse for wear on the appearance front, the coast-​to-​coast journey had not diminished their deliciousness. My favorites were the berry jam thumbprints and the chocolate rugelach. If Lulu’s cookies are at this level, I can only imagine what their specialty cakes must taste like.

My mother always said you catch more flies with honey. Or sugar. Or cake.
In the spirit of «bullet points» here’s our experience with Lulu:
1. We loved the cake so much that we booked a week after our tasting. We tried about three other distinguished NYC cake bakeries and none of them held a candle to Lulu.
2. We knew we wanted a Lulu cake, so we signed our contract, and paid a nominal $ 100 deposit. If we wanted to change anything we had a few weeks before the wedding to do so. If for some insane reason we decided to cancel our cake, we’d lose our $ 100 deposit. Fair enough.
3. A few weeks before the wedding, we had a significant decrease in our guest count, a change of heart on our design, and wanted to remove the pecans from our carrot cake. They quickly revised our contract, no problem.
4. We worked with Jay, Victor and Emily, all of whom were very pleasant in spite of our indecisiveness. I should mention that Jay failed to tell me that he was the owner; I just chalked that one up to modesty.
5. I’m glad we were reasonable people with realistic expectations. We were thrilled to have a Lulu wedding cake at our wedding that our guests continue to rave about.
I don’t blame a person for getting pissed off if these people for some reason or other decide they don’t want to make you your cake. I’d be livid. I mean the cake was *that good* and *that beautiful.* On the other hand, I applaud a business that discriminates against entitled, bitter people. It just made our cake taste that much better.

Giving true meaning to the words «Sweet 16» these cake masters have created the perfect centerpiece for our nieces party. It looked great and tasted even better. It was definitely the showstopper that night, aside from the birthday girl of course.
They paid meticulous attention to what my family wanted and created a cake that I thought only existed in my mind.
There confectionery masterpiece blew us away. I now know who I am going to call for birthdays, graduations, baby showers, wedding showers and other milestone events. Lulu Cake Boutique has officially been added into my iPhone contacts!

I have been coming to Lulu for awhile now and have to say that they are the best bakery i know. I travel to New York about six times a year for business. I usually surprise clients and fellow co-​worker with specialty cakes and other sweet treats on there anniversary, birthdays or just simple tokens of my appreciation.
Even though I live several thousand of miles awhile, Lulu’s makes it easy for me and always have my cakes and other treats ready for me when i arrive. Just before I head on over to New York, I discuss with Jay and we talk about what types of cakes I am looking for, and since I am not that creative of a person, I leave it up to him and his talented staff to come up with some creative, unique and amazingly delicious cakes. My clients and fellow co-​workers always can’t thank me enough.
Here is a most recent picture of the cake that they created for my nephew’s bat mitzvah. It was a chocolate devils food tiered square cake filled with nutella buttercream with praline crunch. Unbelievable!
I am so glad I was introduced to Lulu’s.
Thanks Jay and team for all your help. I could keep the relationships i have with my clients without the help from LuLu Cakes.
For those people looking for a great bakery, you MUST MUST try LuLu Cakes.

I realize my review is long, so let me give a summary in 6 bullets:
1. I loved lulu’s cakes (did a tasting)
2. I told lulu I wanted to buy their cake for my wedding (verbal agreement)
3. They wrote me up a contract for a different cake than what I ordered
4. I asked if they wanted me to fix the contract or if they wanted to fix the contract
5. They gave me huge attitude for no apparent reason, saying they may book up and if I don’t sign that contract they may not work with me
6. I decided not to use them because their customer service was terrible /​employee (Jay) was RUDE without any cause.
The detailed version of the story:
Let me start the review by saying that I worked with Lulu in Manhattan, but I believe they’re the same establishment. Let me also say that the cakes were delicious. They were among the top 2 cakes we tasted, and we tasted about 7 different cake shop’s cakes for our wedding.
That said, the service from Jay via email was atrocious. He was downright rude. When I gave him my verbal agreement we would purchase from them if we could work through the contract issues, he sent me the contract — I didn’t reflect the cake I requested at all — the contract was just plain wrong. When I politely mentioned that they had the wrong cake in the contract and asked whether he wanted me to fix it or if they wanted to fix it along with a few other details which were not consistent with our prior conversations, he wrote me back saying that they make book up for our date and if I don’t sign the contract he can’t guarantee me the date.
A) He threatened me
B) He basically asked me to sign a contract for a cake I didn’t want
At that point I knew I didn’t want to do business with these people. I replied back to him asking if he expected me to sign a contract for a cake I didn’t request, simply so I could post his reply to this review. He wrote me back 2 hours later saying someone booked for our date and they are no longer available, and didn’t reply to my question. Not only is he a jerk, he’s a coward that can’t admit his own passive aggressiveness.
Jay did not in his emails mentions he’s a partner of the company — so I add deceptive to his list of problems.
I will not do business with a company owned by someone who is so rude and disrespectful when I did nothing to provoke him. Jay, you need to learn to respect your customers. Or at least don’t treat them like dirt for no reason.
So I didn’t know who Jay was, but I decided I was so displeased with my experience, I’d go to the website to find out. It turns out Jay is a partner in the company. He seems to feel like even as an owner of a company he’s so popular he can be a jerk to customers. I highly suggest steering away from this business if you have any ethical standards whatsoever. Money should be spent with people who are not only talented, but also respectful, or at least not downright jerks for no reason.