Taste This Pizza

Very disappointed. I was told one price when ordering online, only to be charged $ 5 more when the food was delivered. That’s terrible business and with the food being only mediocre, the low price was the appeal in the first place.

A few months back, I noticed a sign in the recently vacated Little Nicky’s saying a new pizza joint was coming. Intrigued, I made a mental note to watch for its opening, as I love pizza and live very close by. Eventually, I saw it open and decided to try it out.
Turns out, a little piece of Manhattan has come to Seaford in the shape of dollar slices! I haven’t seen that yet here as far as I know, so I was pretty excited. Now, you have to have a certain type of expectation for a dollar slice. It will be minimal cheese, and likely very thin. The slice here is way better than any dollar slice I have had in the city. Yes, it is thin and the cheese is light, but it has actual flavor and is pretty darn good. You don’t gauge a White Castle burger to one from a steakhouse, so why on Earth would you compare a 2.50 cheese slice to a dollar one?
I visited again a few weeks later with family and decided to try out the dinners and various things to see if they are more than just a dollar slice shack. For starters, we had Garlic Knots, which I LOVE. And I loved these, they were great. I find many places don’t put enough garlic on them, which befuddles me a bit. I have been here just for garlic knots since to be honest!
For dinner, I tried the Rigatoni Bolognese, my favorite pasta dinner. The serving size was massive, as seems to be the standard on Long Island. It was good, although not nearly the best I’ve had. I feel like it could of had more sauce, and in general it was pretty average. The other people at the table had about the same opinion on their dinners, with the consensus being it wasn’t bad but it wasn’t amazing.
We had the Zeppole last, and while I see one reviewer did not like them, I really did. I guess I am sucker for oily Zeppole, but that is how I like them. I do agree they are way too conservative with the powdered sugar, Zeppole’s DEMAND huge amounts of sugar, especially with the oil.
I do need to mention, the décor of the restaurant is fantastic and kid friendly. Free candy, arcade games (makes me nostalgic, all pizza places had that when I was younger), and even a claw game that is a guaranteed win for only a dollar. They tend to have 50’s era sitcoms on the TV there I have noticed as well. Parking can be kind of a hassle though.
I had a hard time deciding on a star rating, because if it wasn’t a dollar slice place, I’d give a 3 for being a perfectly good and normal Long Island pizza place. However, with it being so rare to find a dollar slice out here, I have to judge them on being specifically a budget pizza place. And they are very good at that.

Just spotted this place on my way home on Merrick Road and figured why not? im low on funds and 1 $ slices sound about right. WOW, im shocked, this pizza is really great! i got 2 regular slices and 6 garlic knots and it was $ 4.00 all together for what turned out to be an awesome lunch. The staff was friendly and they even have zeppoles and free candy out for you to take! I will def be back to try more of their delicious items. Its $ 1.00 for a regular, grandma or sicilian slice, try finding that on long island and it wasn’t one of those nasty rubbery slices either. Def recommend it.

Taste this pizza… WoW! $ 1.00 slices… WOW! $ 8.00 pies… WOW! These prices are ²⁴⁄₇!
Taste this pizza is a new pizza place and the pizza is delicious! Unlike many other slices, this pizza does not leave you bloated or feeling like you ate too much!
Good specialty slices:
General Tsos chicken (try it! You’ll love it! Don’t be scared of it!)
Buffalo chicken
Regular slices are always good too!
Penne al la vodka was very good. It’s not a super heavy sauce, it was light and sweet.
Great booths to sit down and eat. Old school video games if you want to entertain yourself while waiting. The owner even puts out some chocolate samples to take while you wait!
And don’t forget, grab a magnet at the register for call ahead and delivery!
Definitely will be going back here!

Was in the area after work to get dinner for the family on a Friday night. Best decision of the week! I have nothing bad to say — I’ll be back to support this new pizzeria.
Good:
–Not sure what the food is made with but it leaves you full without feeling bloated and gross
-$ 1 slices, $ 8 pies; come with a 10 dollar bill and you can feed your family
–Buffalo chicken slices are great
–Penney Alla Vodka pasta is plenty for $ 8 (2 people can share an order)
–Sicilian slices are the right amount of sweet
–If you don’t see a specialty slice on the menu — they can make it on the spot!
–I had a General Tso’s chicken slice too!
–I played video games there while I waited for my order
Bad:
–It’s in Seaford and not closer to where I live.