Vincent’s Pizzeria

Horrible! The sauce they use is too sweet. Thing of preference. I don’t think it’s called Vincent’s anymore. It much be Mary’s express. Very unhappy with the pizza

My wife and i had a groupon, so we tried out a bunch of items.
The best thing about this place are the appetizers like– garlic knots (pretty garlicky), cinnamon chocolate rolls were delicious, and the pinwheels were large and yummy.
Now the not so good — The grandma pizza was decent, but I’ve had much better. We also had a shrimp dish which gave shrimp bad name– overcooked shrimp and almost no sauce.
I probably will not be going back there ever.

Food was alright.
The staff is completely lost.

FYI: Vincent’s is no longer operating in Seaford; it’s been replaced by Peppino’s. That said, the menu remains the same, so either it’s just a re-​naming (although the website’s different) or they’ve just decided to keep with what worked.
All that said, the one in Farmingdale is still open. The «everything» crust (sesame, poppyseed, garlic, onion) is quite tasty; everything else is tasty enough, but generic Long Island pizza place.

Vincent’s is one of my favorite places to order from when I’m on LI. They make a mean linguine and clams and are normally speedy with delivery! It’s not my first choice for pizza but it’s up there!

i have to disagree with previous reviewers in rating vincent’s…to be perfectly honest, i haven’t been impressed
the pizza at vincent’s is the only reason they’re getting 3 stars out of me… it’s actually pretty decent, and i like the variety of crusts they offer (sesame, everything, etc. — almost like bagel options)
this however is where the positive remarks about the food at vincent’s end… anything i’ve had from here other than pizza has been of a poor quality… fried options (zucchini, calamari etc.) are put in a very salty & cheap breading that pales in comparison to what you can get at other local eateries, sauce is overly sweet, and i just haven’t enjoyed their offerings
to sum it up, in a pinch vincent’s is an ok option for pizza… beyond that, stay away

I recently moved to Massapequa, and have been trying various pizza places just to get a feel for the better places. Vincents is definitely one of the best places in the Seaford/​Massapequa border area.
First off, their prices are amazing. I easily get double the food I would at another average Long Island pizzeria. The food itself, is really, really good as well. One thing you may want to know is their slices have a sesame seed crust, which isn’t my favorite thing personally. However, the sizes of the slices compensate for the edge of the crust having them. Also worth noting, is that if you order a pie you can have an assortment of different toppings for the edge of the crust (or plain).
The pizza, man the pizza. If upon your visit, they have an ala vodka ANYTHING slice… get it. Vincent’s has the best ala vodka sauce pretty much anywhere. Also, leave room for desert. Their pastries are awesome!

This was the only pizzeria in the area that stayed open the night of the blizzard (Dec. 19^th) They were so nice and the pizza was DELICIOUS!!! Love the sesame crust!