Pizzaro’s Pizzeria

Stick to the pizza. Just got a chicken parm dinner and it wasn’t bad… It was awful. I still love the place, but do yourself a favor and stick to the wood fired pizza lol

Very solid pizza joint in the valley. The bacon pizza in particular is very generous-​so much bacon you can barely see the pizza! Excellent service is a big bonus too. They accept credit cards and while parking can be tough, you can almost make your own parking space if you are just picking up. I love their cherry pepper pizza too.
One opportunity for improvement-​the artichoke pizza. It’s strange because the bacon is so right on, but the artichoke is beyond sparse. I’ve never seen one artichoke heart pulled apart and spread across an entire pizza. Ordering extra artichoke doesn’t help, it’s still almost the same sparse sprinkling of a few artichoke leaves. I’ve stopped trying to order artichoke pizza, but it’s a minor complaint in the grand scheme of things because this is still hands down one of the better pizza places in the valley (second to roseland of course).

I went for the first time two weeks ago for a takeout Calzone. I ordered it with more ricotta & less mozzarella. There was no one else in there as it was about 3 pm on a Sat. All the employees were extremely pleasant. It was nice that they have a TV to watch while you wait as I did not have a menu to call ahead. My «small» pepperoni calzone was ready in less then 10 minutes. It was the best calzone I’ve ever eaten with the best sauce I’ve had. It took me 3 days to eat it! I can’t imagine what

Absolutely wonderful! Me and my wife stopped in for lunch and wanted to try a local place. Service was great, pizza and calazone was delicious, atmosphere was warm and comfortable. A perfect 5 star experience.

Delicious pizza, wonderful staff, and super conveniently located on 67 in Seymour! My family and I frequent here and we will certainly be back many more times to come. It’s difficult to find decent pizza in the valley, but we’ve found it here!

Most delicious!
This place is the best Pizza in Seymour /​Oxford area by far. We have lived here 7 years now and are thrilled with the food.
We have ordered pizza to bring home (they do not deliver) and now gone in for a sit down lunch.
The Italian Combo grinder was fantastic and the pizza was, if course, delicious.
Highly recommended

I’ve lived in this town for seven years, and longed for a supremely delicious pizza close to home. Having previously lived close to New Haven, that had been my usual jaunt for good pizza (Pepe’s, of course). When this new place opened I of course was skeptical, after all, this is Seymour. The odds of a fantastical pizza to be found here are almost nil. Thought I’d give this place a chance.
I entered around noon on a weekday, the place was nearly vacant except for two people sitting waiting for a take-​out order. There was a young woman behind the counter, and a man shuffling pizzas inside the large brick oven (brick oven? In Seymour?! I’m already impressed!). The staff were friendly and efficient, quickly took my order, and literally seven minutes later, my pizza came out of that oven and was in a box ready to go.
My family is Italian. We don’t play around. Pizza is our jam. This was the test. My mom and I sat at her table with two dishes and each took a slice. As we began consuming our slices, I looked up at mom’s eyes, we were both smiling. My «I’m on a diet I’ll just have one slice» turned into four. There was no holding back, the gates of joy were opened.
When we finally finished our lunch, a five minute conversation ensued between us about how glorious this pizza had been, how this is our New Favorite Local Pizza Place.
A few nights later, I took my daughter and mom back and we dined-​in. My daughter ordered a «small» plain calzone, and mom and I opted to share yet another pizza. A friendly handsome man apologized for the lack of a waitress (really? We didn’t notice) and had taken our orders. The food came out quickly. The «small» calzone was rather large and my daughter enjoyed it (brought more than half home) Again, our pizza was heavenly.
If you have actual working taste buds on your tongue, and you value a glorious delicious pizza, trust this Italian gal: this is where you will find Your Happy Place.