Caffe Tuscany

Walked by here yesterday and there was a sign on the door saying it is closed for good. Too bad. I had dinner here with family once, didn’t think it was so bad, though husband didn’t like.

I have visited this restaurant about three times and the food was excellent every time. The biggest thing that stands out is the freshness of the food and cheap prices.
The only thing I would like to see them change is their breadstick offering. Some sort of homemade bread with garlic would match the fresh food much better. The current offering is your standard breadsticks that you can buy in the frozen aisle of a grocery store.
If your looking for well priced fresh Italian food with a cozy atmosphere I would defiantly recommend this restaurant.

Food was excellent, cioppino was very good. Atmosphere was good also, it was a shame the place was empty. The waitress and matre de however were both not very bright so service was terrible. Asking to substitute pasta for potatoes with the cioppino was a real big deal (really???, italian get it), ordered a caprese salad (tomatoe and mozzerella) and got the regular house salad instead (letttuce, no tomatoes), but waitress insisted charging for a caprese since she didnt know the menu or what a tomatoe was. Only people in the place and she asked 5 times if I was done yet while we were in the middle of eating. Matre de couldnt figure out how to use a tv remote to take UFC off the bar TV. Such a shame because food was good, but no wonder it was empty.

First review since I joined 2 years ago and this one is worth my time: I don’t understand how Caffe Tuscany has such good reviews. The food and place makes me think of Olive Garden but in worse: the lettuce in the salad was not fresh and came out of a bag, the pasta were drenched with sauces that probably came out of a processed food supplier, the pasta was rubbery, the «forest mushrooms» were just tasteless baby-​bellas at best and everything was overpriced for the quality.
A plate of gnocchi in pesto sauce with a few pieces of chicken tasted like processed food and was for $ 17!
The décor looks like a fake Mediterranean place: fake extruded foam wood beams, faux brick work on walls and arches…
Only one good point (and awarded with one star) was the service that was friendly and attentive.
Sheboygan has some of the best Italian places in the Midwest; why waste your money at Caffe Tuscany?

I would definitely come back. The food, service, and atmosphere were great. The garlic bread was delicious and the portions weren’t overwhelming. A satisfying evening.

Have been to Caffe Tuscany a couple of times and have never been disappointed. The food is good. The price is good for the quality of food. I had the lasagna that was good. The atmosphere is great and the service was great! Definitely ask for Kelly, she is awesome! We had a huge group of 20 and they were very accommodating. No complaints here!

After putting it off for months, we finally tried Caffe’ Tuscany. Unfortunately we we’re disappointed to say the least. I had higher hopes for this place, considering the other somewhat positive reviews.
Sheboygan has some serious Italian competition when compared with IL ritrovo and Stepheno’s. Meaning, any new restaurant trying to compete has to meet some pretty high standards. Let’s just say Café Tuscany was not the same experience — food and service were sub-​par.
That said, I’m willing to try this place again and hope for a better experience in the future.

Was really good, enjoyed a good quality food for once in Sheboygan. We will try this again

Went there for the first time tonight with a friend. Absolutely LOVED the atmosphere! Good selection of pastas, pizzas, and wines. My friend and I split a Hawaiian 12″ pizza and that was enough food for both of us. The flavor would probably rate a 4 out of 5 for Hawaiian pizza I’ve tasted in my lifetime. :) We ordered the Riesling on their drink menu, and it was delicious. Price was pretty good too! I would MOST DEFINITELY come back again… Maybe on a date next time? ;)

the best place in sheboygan by far!!! everything was out of this world and me and my wife got one place in sheboygan to eat a good (did i say good) sorry great tiramisu!!!

We visited on a Saturday night. The staff was friendly and the food was good. We will defiantly go back. My husband has the crab stuffed Flounder and I had the pasta checca.

Had another exceptional meal with exceptional service. Had two different pizzas and bruschetta, phenomenal! Went to the bar first and talked to a very friendly bartender who made us feel very welcome. Very nice to see many other customers as well.