Faye’s Pizza

This is the last pizza place I would go to eat pizza at. Pizza tastes like cardboard, service is not good, it is a small place. Parking area is small and odd to get into it. I would give it half a star.

Toppings are scarce and not enough sauce to the edges. Sometimes overcooked…

Worst customer service ever. I had such a negative person who did not care for one second about my problem and treated me like absolute garbage.

I wasn’t expecting much based on the atmosphere and the food presentation, but looks can be deceiving.
Faye’s Pizza is just really good food, no matter how you cut it.
We ordered the Appetizer platter and a large thin-​crust and left very happy — Total bill was under $ 21 and the 15″ pizza was good for 2 meals for 2 of us.
I would give a solid recommendation and would definitely go back next time I am in town.

Great pizza, awesome crispelle appetizer, and local beers! Good for kids, friendly servers, would always return.

Try their sub sandwiches! I had their Sausage Sub and it was to die for!

Pizza is delicious. Deep dish is my favorite thing ever and Faye’s did not disappoint on food quality! Their service was less than mediocre. We waited forever to be helped and the waitress was nothing spectacular. Extremely small space. Will try take out next time to avoid the crammed space!

Omg yummy yummy pizza! I also ordered a house salad with house dressing and it was perfect. We had it delivered to The Blue Harbor and it delivered hot. Price is very reasonable. I ordered a super size cheese Pizza, a large pepperoni pizza and a large house salad for $ 35. The only con is that it took over an hour.

Faye’s has great pizza. It’s not really restaurant ambiance as much as a pizza-​café type situation inside. Very, very clear that this is a place locals love!

Great pizza. We ordered the original hand tossed with sausage & mushrooms. Crust was perfect and the sauce was flavorful. Ate in and the servers were very nice. We’ll be back next time were in Sheboygan!

Great pizza restaurant. The buffalo chicken pizza is perfect for anyone who likes spicy food. Service was also on time and friendly.

We went to Faye’s for the first time and loved the appetizers! Our kids enjoyed the cheesy garlic bread, potato skins and the appetizer deluxe plate. The roasted potato and sausage soup was excellent! We also ordered a cheese pizza and a sausage, mushroom & onion pizza. They were good but next time we’ll try one of their specialty pizzas.

My husband and I went to Faye’ s for their Tuesday night special. This is a great deal — garlic bread basket, supersize pizza with choice of two toppings and a pitcher of soda for $ 16.95! Their pizza is terrific — thin, crisp crust, good sauce and really good sausage with lots of cheese. (The crust on their grocery store product is not the same and not that good). Wine and beer available to round out your meal. This is the place to go for thin crust pizza.

Grew up on this stuff, who needs NYC or Chicago pizza when you have places like Fayes and Nicky’s…enough said 4.5 stars

Great random find in Sheboygan. The pizza is fantastic. The crust is extra crispy and very good. Not too greasy.

Yum yum yum. First ordered this when we were staying at the Inn at Woodlake a little over a year ago. Crust was a little burnt, but overall ok.
Have ordered multiple times since we moved to the area and it is definitely my favorite. A little greasy, but not too bad, and not as bad as the only decent pizza place in the town I moved from. Crust is paper thin, great sauce (I always get extra) and really flavorful toppings. They are usually very fast, and prices are reasonable. Was so sad when I called on New Year’s Eve and they were closed already.

Having eaten pizza at Il Ritrovo (tho haven’t yet reviewed it — weird!) as well as Cucina in Kohler, I have to say this place beats those hands down!
First of all, the prices are very reasonable, unlike the aforementioned spots. This is not a place to ‘see and be seen’ but a place for families and, no offense, it seemed the working class; your average Joe if you will.
That’s a good thing considering this area of the country is predominately working class families. And the décor is really welcoming and somewhat homey with wooden tables and even one adorable 2-​seater table in a kinda catty-​corner window.
This was our first time coming, despite the fact a year ago it was recommended to us. Apparently the have specials often, and the night we went was all-​you-​can-​eat meatball and spagetti, with breadsticks and a soda, for $ 7.
We got a pizza (thin crust but not *too thin*!) with pepperoni, mushrooms, jalapenos (yes!), and onions. I didn’t like the way they slice it in squares, but the taste of the pizza itself was really great. While it was lacking marinara sauce, the cheese was phenomenal and all the ingredients tasted great and really fresh. I would definitely come back for this pizza, as I do think it’s the best I’ve had in the area.
We ordered the jalapeño poppers to start — and while the red jalapeño part (only 1 slice per popper, not a whole pepper) was spicy, the cream cheese really outweighed it. My husband loved them but for a Texas girl, I prefer the punch of a spicier popper! Still, they were good, and didn’t seem to be pre-​frozen.
The only fault was the caesar salad. Basically it was any green salad w/​croutons and dry cheese with generic dressing on the side. It had been forgotten and came after our pizza, but that was fine since I didn’t care for it any way. (I’m a caesar salad snob).
Wine runs $ 4/​glass here, which you can’t really beat, and which is decent table wine. They also have a selection of beers and pepsi sodas.
The waitstaff seems to be made up of young high school girls, but they work hard and that was awesome.
I will definitely be coming back, and you should give it a shot, yourself.
If you get the special or an entrée and only water or a soda, you can walk out spending under $ 10. That’s a steal for dinner out :)

i ordered Faye’s on the recommendation of a local while I was traveling.
I read the other reviews and was excited. And then it arrived.
It was okay. not bad, not great. It took a good 45 – 50 min on a Monday night.
The garlic bread was… garlic bread. Not worth the money.
All in all it was a decent pizza, though pretty forgettable.

I WILL SAY THIS IN CAPS! THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA PLACE I HAVE EVER IN MY LIFE BEEN TOO. I WILL SAY IT AGAIN. THE BEST!!! DON’T CHANGE ANYTHING.
Thin crust pizza is the best on the planet! Place is to die for! I wish they had more distribution of their frozen pizza’s at grocery stores in ozaukee county.
I had this pizza for my daughters bday party at the Blue Harbor and it was amazing. I have had it multiple times since.
This is what I expect a pizza to taste like. ITS PERFECT!

Great Thin Crust Pizza. Reasonable Pricing. Great Delivery. Thick Crust/​Deep Dish Pizza is OK and glad I tried it. Not my favorite though and not what I remember Faye’s for going back to the early 90’s. Excellent sit down dining is available at their location.