Peabody’s Pizza Company

Peabody’s is a consistently decent pizza. It’s my go-​to delivery when I’m in the Sheboygan areas.
The delivery is always super fast, it’s rare that it takes more than twenty minutes for our food to arrive. We usually order a large pepperoni with olives, and it’s always well cooked and piping hot at our door. We also really like the Taco Pizza, which has taco meat, sour cream, and Doritos among other toppings, and the BLT pizza. Both are $ 18.99 for a large.
We also are sure to get some appetizers. Their garlic bread with cheese ($ 2.99) is always solid. Our must-​have is the Mozzarella Egg Roll Sticks ($ 5.99), which are mozzarella sticks but in a wonton wrapper instead of a normal breading. If you can’t decide, you can get a sampler for $ 10.99 that includes Mozzarella Sticks, Mozzarella Egg Roll Sticks, Cheddar Cheese Nuggets, Chicken Strips, and French Fries.
The only bummer is that most days they close at 10. When I’m craving a cheap assortment of fried and cheesy foods, I assure you it’s usually after that time slot!

I was a frequent customer until tonight. I ordered the boneless chicken wings. For $ 7.00 for about 7 tiny blobs of grizzle. Nasty. Any establishment that would rip you off like that doesn’t deserve any business. Spend your money elsewhere. Peanody’s sucks.

Got a large pizza & order of spaghetti shrimp Alfredo for price you pay very bad no sauce no cheese funky taste will never order there ever again!

Friday night we picked up an Ultimate Hawaiian (Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Onions, & Pineapple). The pizza was very good, crust was semi thin, sauce was kinda sweet, and they did not mess around with the toppings. First pizza in a long time where they actually put the ingredients out to the crust. The pizza was very affordable and we were very happy with what we got for our money. We will definitely be ordering again as we make our way through Sheboygans Pizza Places!!!