Casa Maya

This place is okay. Nothing out of the ordinary. But it’s close and convenient and reasonably priced so we go. Service and décor are fine.

Amazing Margaritas !
Chicken soup !! Authentic. Home style FAB!
Family owned high quality food. Always friendly.

Great people. The workers and owner are very polite. I ordered at 9:45 (they close at 10) and they hooked me up. Perfect fajitas… Hit the spot. Very generous and welcoming

Casa Maya is very dependable. Seems like any time I come here the service is excellent and the place is clean. The food is pretty good with a decent menu selection. The chicken soup is awesome! I think this has to be the best soup I’ve ever had. Price is good. If I’m not sure where I want to eat, I can count on going to Casa Maya and leaving happy.

Such a great place! Amazing food and amazing service. Definitely tucked away but worth the time to find them. I have never had a bad meal at this restaurant. It’s super affordable and authentic food. Great margaritas!

Very comprehensive menu but the food is always hot and fresh. Service is quick and the chips and salsa that come as a complimentary starter are terrific. Lunch specials are the best deal and are a lot of food for a reasonable price. My go-​to favorite is the carne asada lunch special.

I went in a few weeks ago on a Monday night for dinner with a friend. Although I’ve lived here my whole life, this was my first visit. The food was very good. Chips and salsa to start off were delicious. I ordered the guacamole appetizer but the waitress brought me a side by mistake which ended up working out because I didn’t LOVE it. I had cheese enchiladas and refried beans and both were really good. My main issue was the service, there were only 3 tables in the restaurant and 2 servers yet somehow our drinks were always empty and we never had refills on chips and salsa. Our server kept saying she was sorry, but I honestly think she was in the back talking based on what I saw when we left. I would go back but hope for better service.

This was our first time here and it was amazing. Generous portions and great quality. We will definitely return.

Cash Maya has always been a favorite place for my family and I. We used to go basically every week. The food is reasonably priced and some days during the week have ½ priced margaritas. If you go on those days, you are most likely going to wait a little bit.
If you love Mexican food, you should go here.

Solid Mexican food. Very reasonably priced! Typical Mexican restaurant atmosphere. Service was excellent. Chips and Guacamole were good but have had better. Beef enchiladas were excellent, chicken were ok. For a typical small town Mexican place, not bad, but you aren’t likely to be raving about it either.

The Mole Ranchero was very tasty. The tortilla chips were a bit soft and chewy, but the salsa was above average.
The guacamole was OUT OF THIS WORLD great! I would go just for that!
The place was fairly clean and good for groups with small children. My wife got a chicken taco salad and said it was OK. My son gobbled up his kid’s plate which had a chicken enchilada with beans and rice.
No real complaints here, but nothing super amazing either. I would go back again as the prices were decent.

Menu has a lot of dishes and so far tried the Bistek Mexicana, Tacos and Chicken Enchiladas. I enjoyed all of them. Especially the Enchiladas.
Very clean and very friendly staff.

Our waitress was friendly, courteous, and timely. The restaurant was clean. The chips and salsa were good. I had the pozole, it was my first time having this soup but it is definitely something I will order again. And again. And again. It was delicious. My kids ordered American food at a Mexican restaurant it was expected it would be mediocre and it definitely was. I give it 4 stars because I’ve had 5 star. But if you live in Shorewood and want to eat local this would be a great choice.

Would love to go again. Nice atmosphere for everyone & a little homey feel. Hot steaming food, but could’ve had a little more rice, even if I ordered combo #11 for $ 9 something, heehee… Friendly service and waiting time for food to arrive for a busy Friday night wasn’t too bad.

Place has gone down hill. We loved this place when we moved to the area 11 years ago. Ate here many times and it was good. Not sure if owners changed, but menu changed. I asked to get an entrée off old menu, and they refused. Prices went way up and menu items disappeared. Beans and rice did not appear to be fresh cooked. Portion sizes decreased. It is sad, because I used to really love this place, and now we will never return.

Our favorite Mexican spot in the area. The service is always great and the food is delicious. Try the Pollo Fundido!

Just ok. Horchata very cinnamony. Beef for tacos tasted reheated. Fast service. Not much flavor.

Literally the best Mexican restaurant I have ever tried. We have eaten here dozens of times and it has never been bad. Their Mole is amazing and is right on point. I usually get that or their Enchiladas Supremas. The red sauce is perfect and never greasy. My wife has tried all of their vegetarian dishes and loved their Chili Relleno.
Do not miss out. Go here, support the local business. Half price margaritas on Tues and Wed also.

I was invited to lunch today by a good friend and he brought me to Casa Maya. I am very jaded when it comes to Hispanic food. I usually cannot stomach the ingredients and suffer for days.
However, this lunch was different! I not only enjoyed the food, but am laying in bed now with no «side affects!»
The ambiance was kinda funky, but it was lunch. Weird bar away from the restaurant set up.
The all important «first impression» at a Mexican restaurant is made by the chips and salsa. Casa Maya has perfect taste/​texture to its tortilla chips and the salsa was acceptable. B
The service was adequate, but the waitress spoke nearly no English. I’ve found that some of my greatest Mexican meals were served by non English speaking waitresses!
I ordered the pork with rice, beans and corn tortillas. The food was fresh and came out fast. I enjoyed the rice and beans, they were very unique and pleasant. The pork was cooked well and I did really enjoy them.
I will be returning again soon for dinner to really get a feel for Casa Maya. Being conservative with the three star rating, hope to raise it to a four following dinner.

A Shorewood favorite, not just cause I live here and it’s close but really a quality restaurant. We enjoy this as a family or just a date. It’s always consistently quality. Not the most flavor but good. Always good. That’s why 5 star because it’s never bad food or service. Like the huge 32oz. Beer!!!