Creanies Ice Cream

Adorable and «hoppin» place! Those who work there were super friendly and helpful! I had black cherry ice cream with chocolate jimmies. It’s a very causal and comfortable place to grab dessert and forget the calorie count.

The icecream is decent, but the service is substandard, the teens working there don’t pay attention to details. On 2 occasions, they have charged my credit card twice for my order and I’ve had several orders where they have either given me the wrong sized milkshake or wrong flavors.

YUMMY ICE CREAM!!! I got the pumpkin ice cream on a chocolate chip cone, delicious. The boyfriend got the mint chocolate chip ice cream on a pretzel cone. It was $ 9 for both. If you use a credit card, it’s a 20 cent charge.

Ok, I will say that the ice cream and such are fine. Nothing special. Typical ice cream parlor stuff. The problem lies in the cash only issue. I have no problem paying cash IF the prices didn’t change EVERY SINGLE time I go. We buy the same order pretty much every time. Sometimes I pick it up and sometimes my husband. The last 3 times we bought the same 3 items and the cost changed each time (by $ 1-​$ 2). Now, they also do not provide a receipt so you really don’t know what they are charging. If they took credit cards you would obviously be able to tell what you pay. Hmmm… maybe I see why they don’t accept credit cards. In any case, it is close to home, and I like water ice and the kids like ice cream, which is why we go. We decided to go today and slightly changed up the order, by ordering 2 less toppings on 2 of the ice cream sundaes, however, it cost me .75 MORE! How is this possible?! It’s almost like these girls make up their own pricing. I’ve priced it based on what they show on the board and it NEVER has matched. I thought about complaining to management, but I am just so annoyed I took to Unilocal

Love This place! Open year round with lots of parking now. All the choices make me feel like a kid! Love the custard but they have great ice cream no matter what you choose!

Yeah, it’s the ‘local ice cream place’ — but they don’t make their own ice cream. They also don’t seem to take the best care of it. Both cones we got had ice cream that plainly had been melted and refrozen, with big ice crystals and rubbery places. (A coffee and a blueberry cheesecake.)
If I wanted supermarket quality ice cream, I’d go to Shoprite and buy a gallon for the cost of one cone at Creanies. I suspect the good rating comes down only to nostalgia, not actual experiences. (And my childhood ice cream places made their own in house.)
They only get a second star because they’re open all year.

A very sweet surprise. We really enjoyed our sweet treat from Creanies. The employees were very nice. They were helpful when it came to assisting us with our ice cream needs. Unlike other reviews we didn’t find our ice cream to have a funny taste, or have the appearance of freezer burn. The $.20 charge for credit is minimum. Some places charge a dollar. We will definitely return with the kiddos.

My absolute FAVORITE ice cream place EVER.
I’m a Sicklerville native, so I’m almost obligated to be a Creanie’s patron, but that doesn’t mean that I’m obligated to think they’re amazing… With that being said, they are actually truly amazing. They have a wide selection of hand dipped and soft serve ice cream flavors, as well as water ice and Yum Yum, which is similar to water ice, but with a dairy additive, and let me add that Yum Yums are delish, my second choice when I’m not indulging in ice cream from Creanie’s. To top it all off, their topping selection is great, as well (heh, get it. Top it off. Toppings. Ah never mind). Oh! Let me not forget to mention that their hand dipped flavors also include a few sugar-​free and fat-​free yogurt options, which were a godsend while I was dieting a year or so ago.
They have a drive-​thru and a walk-​up window, with outdoor seating available. It tends to get crowded in the summer, but what ice cream place doesn’t? Especially a place as awesome as Creanie’s. Parking can be a smidge iffy, but once again, what do you expect in the middle of the summer? They also DO accept credit cards now, but there is a small fee (a dollar, I think.?) — I’m not one to complain about things like this, especially because I appreciate the convenience of being able to use a credit/​debit card, but they do PLENTY of business to be able to do away with the fee and still have accepting credit cards be worth it. A small qualm in the midst of such delicious ice-​cream-​related options, though.
The staff is typically made up of younger, late-​teen-​type adults, but that has never been a problem for me, as they are always on-​point and have never messed up any of my orders. They also never give me pushback on my usual strange request, which is a large cup of whipped cream (what?! I need a little extra for my sundae, and share the rest with my dogs!)
Oh! Yes! The dogs! Creanie’s also offers ‘Puppy Cups,’ which consist of a little vanilla soft-​serve in a cup, which is 100% dog friendly, and my dogs LOVE IT. I swear they know when I come home from Creanie’s and have Puppy Cups in my to-​go bag for them.
Overall, Creanie’s is great. I’ve been to plenty of other ice cream places across the country, yet I’m always drawn back to my favorite hometown place. My husband is a Baltimore native, and even HE looks forward to getting Creanie’s while up here in New Jersey. We’re actually about to head over there now. Hmm… But what should I get???

A nice local ice cream parlor opened all year round. Go there with a good idea of what you are craving. The place gets packed and people are impatient behind you. I enjoy the milk shakes. The strawberry milkshake is pretty good. The one downside about this place is the parking. It’s a tight area and Sicklerville is loaded with a hole drivers. Beware walking through parking lot.

I’ve been coming here since I was a little kid and now I’m in my twenties. I love Creanies! You can’t go wrong with a classic milkshake or ice cream cone. When I was a kid, I would get soft serve vanilla with rainbow sprinkles… I’ll still get it today and it brings back memories of my childhood! Best ice cream around.

This place rubbed me the wrong way.
Yeah, it’s cool they’re in a good location and they’re open ²⁴⁄₇. However, it’s not cool for a customer to bring a coupon and for them to tell us that they never authorized said magazine to issue a coupon. I get it, but it’s just bad business to turn people away with coupons in a rude and arrogant way. All the cashier said was «We didn’t authorize that,» in the snottiest way. It made me not want to eat anything there, but we had already waited in line for ever.
I ended getting some kind of ice cream and it wasn’t impressive. Nothng special, at least to me. Oh and cash only.

I have been frequenting this store for many many years. They have a wide variety of flavors and types of ice cream and water ice. They now accept debit cards with no limit on purchases. I would definitely recommend this store to anyone.

This is the local ice cream place and it’s usually always packed. The custard I got was the super tiny micro version for some reason and it was not as cold as it should have been. We saw another worker make a cone and realize it was too soft and threw it away. Yet our ice cream was given to us and it had the wrong toppings and when we told our ice cream dude he didn’t really seem to care that much and didn’t offer to make another. I think next time I want ice cream I will travel further for better quality and better service.

Friendly service and good ice cream. We will be back!
Kiddie size is pretty good for grown ups too.

I’ll preface this with the fact that I always have been and forever shall be an ice cream junkie. It’s one of the first things people learn about me, and something close friends never forget. That being said, it should be no surprise that Creanies is one of my favorite ice cream spots ever… in the WHOLE WORLD!
This little ice cream shop looks like a shack that time forgot on the side of the road, with a few outdoor picnic tables (no indoor seating), neon sign, and a drive through window. The menu boasts a selection of just about everything an ice cream place could offer. Tons of hard ice cream flavors, soft ice creams, sugar free, cups, cones, topping, shakes, Italian ices, banana splits, and a variety of other sundae selections, Creanies really has it all. My past few visits have included selections of pistachio, rum raisin, and strawberry and I salute the «realness» of the flavors. None of the simulated, artificial tasting junk you get out of some brands.
The portions are decent, and I think the prices are great. I recently treated myself and four friends to Creanies, and the bill came to about $ 15. Let me know the next time you get anything at Carvel for $ 3!

Tons of flavors to choose from, and I haven’t had anything I didn’t like. Everything’s at a reasonable price as well! Definitely worth the trip out.

Came here after a disappointing dinner experience and it just made everything better. I’m not a sweets person, but Creanies is always the exception. I almost always get their black and white milkshake. I wasn’t disappointed. Their menu is EXTENSIVE and feature everything from homemade hand dipped ice cream to homemade water ice. The gf got a sundae with hot fudge/​caramel and my friend got pistachio ice cream on a homemade waffle cone. The place is open all year round and has a drive thru. I know they also do ice cream cakes. Do yourself a favor and check this place out. It blows Yo-​Go and any fast food shakes out of the water.
Tip: Cash only!

We love Creanies, We always come here during the summer and sometimes during the winter.
They have events during the year, so keep your eye open.
When we have guest’s and they come to Creanies then they want to move to Sicklerville… lol

This place is the best! They aren’t like other places in Jersey that try to come off as nostalgic, but end up being dry, antiquated excuses for the great food and service provided to their customers many years ago. Creanies maintains those feelings of nostalgia (drive-​thru, outside picnic benches, CASH ONLY) and also delivers on friendly customer service and amazing ice cream.
I never really tried their different water ice flavors so I can’t help anyone on that note, but the soft serve ice cream is literally the best I’ve had. Don’t know what it is about it, I’m sure they use many of the same ingredients as other places, but they just consistently provide the best ice cream creations in the area.
Be Smart, Get the soft serve, load it up with your favorite toppings, get a huge waffle cone to go along with it, indulge, and thank me later.

One thing Jersey has is custard. And I love me some custard. Shit, even if it’s not custard, I love me some ice cream.
After feeding our faces at Tony Luke’s, I wanted some damn custard and was guided here. Variety of flavors. Variety of options. I was pleased.
Boyfriend got a strawberry sundae with strawberry ice cream. I got the rum raisin — which was definitely more raisin than it was rum.
Overall, a nice spot for ice cream. I wouldn’t say it’s the best I’ve ever had but it was damn good. I was pleased that the ice cream/​custard (who knows) didn’t melt very fast as I was there to consume ice cream… not milk.
Outdoor, covered seated along with a drivethrough (but I don’t believe in eating in the car). Cash only. Do not recommend rum raisin.