Rustico Cafe

Price, quality, staff, was all good. Best authentic italian restaurant in area. Would recommend to any looking for something other then the typical chain/​fast food. The owner who was very busy on sat took min to come over and ask how dinner was. We will go back. Great job

I have to say that when I first started going here, the place was 5 — STAR! But… The last couple lunch specials, they went to the dreaded FAKE CHEESE! WHY, WHY???
Food (other than the fake cheese) is decent as well as the prices but the fake cheese knocks off 2 stars!

A find! Great food & reasonable prices in a comfortable setting. Nice menu and great specials, too.

Rustico. Where do I begin?
One day I was on my way to Home Depot and I saw signs outside of a shopping complex about an Italian restaurant. It said «Sunset Menu 12.95.» 12.95 for a dinner? Count me in! So my friend and I decided we’d try it out. Best decision I ever made. I believe that night I got the penne vodka but im not really sure because I’ve eaten so many meals from there. I cannot resist. The staff is amazing, the food is irresistible, and the atmosphere is perfect. If you want authentic Italian food for a great price, I would recommend Rustico any day of the week. But mostly on Sunday’s-thursdays from 4:00 pm-9:00 pm because that’s when the sunset menu is available.

Best local Italian Restaurant in the area. Family owned and operated. Byob with a liquor store in the next strip mall (Roger Wilco). fantastic, well balanced pizza. Great anti pasta platter. Great bread. Awesome dinner entrees at a very affordable price.

Excellent food and great family atmosphere. This place is a real gem. We will be back. Great selection and excellent quality at a moderate price.

Love this place ! Best mozzarella sticks everrrr! Pizza so fresh and delicious. Love this place ! Average price. They don’t deliver but it’s worth the trip!

Me and my family love going there. Great food, service, and prices! One of the best byob in town!

This place is so authentic! Love their pasta dishes! Anything you order from here is fresh and amazing

This place has gone down hill. The menu says one price and when you pay it’s higher! Some of the wait staff are really nice and others are down right bitchy!

I received a package of coupons in the mail and Rustico had a coupon for two cheese pizzas for $ 16.99, so on a Saturday afternoon I called to place an order. I was told that the coupons weren’t for the weekends so I said ok and hung up thinking I must have missed something written in small print. When I looked at the coupon again, it said nothing about any restrictions about the weekends, so I called back and had the same man answer the phone and I told him the coupon says nothing about days of the week and he said that was the owners orders and that was it. It certainly wasn’t the answer I was expecting, so for the cost of a couple of dollars, I won’t be ordering from them again and I will be contacting the BBB and the Consumers Affairs Dept. about their false advertising.

Love this place. Huge menu, reasonable prices and a great atmosphere. Service is top notch too.

Great food for reasonable prices. Every time I eat here I have to have their penne vodka. Probably the best vodka sauce I have ever had. They make it fresh for each order, not like other places that pre make it at the beginning of the day. I always like to add spinach to my pasta and they also use fresh spinach which is a huge factor for me as I hate when restaurants use frozen or canned. Their calamari appetizer is another favorite. Comes in a huge portion and cooked precisely right. Sandwiches here are always huge. They have a $ 12.95 early bird special Sunday — Thurs that includes soup and salad and a huge choice of entrees. My husband usually orders some kind of seafood, and it is always fresh.
They do a huge take out business here, so there are constantly people coming and going. Servers are all nice and the owner is always present making sure everything is just right. Great place to take kids or for just a night out.

This place is amazing. We love going here. Their menu is so hard to choose from because there are so many delicious items. Everything is made fresh and you can see them cooking over the partition. I haven’t ordered anything I didn’t like. BYOB is great too. Great prices. Pizza is awesome. Stuffed mushrooms are amazing. Sauces are fresh. Chicken is fresh. I’ll take that over the Olive Garden any day. Keep up the good work!

Great food
The mussels are fantastic
My kids love the calamari
The only place for pizza

We’ve ordered from here twice now. Both times the orders were wrong when we got them home.
It’s a shame, because the food is pretty good. They apparently just don’t care what they put in the bag.

Rustico has so much potential. The food is great, the prices are reasonable, and the atmosphere is very family friendly. My family and I went to Rustico tonight and the experience that we had there made us definitely think twice about returning.
As my family and I walked in to be seated, the manager was yelling at all of the servers from the kitchen (which is exposed to guests). Although our servers couldn’t have been nicer, we could not even enjoy our night out as we were rushed through the entire meal. I have never felt so unwelcome at a restaurant before. Throughout my meal, I would look up to see 4 servers staring at my family and checking to see if we were finished. Meanwhile, the manager continued to yell at the servers in front of everyone when they were clearly working as fast as they could. As we were about to leave, I was finishing my drink when I thought the manager was going to ask me how my meal was. Instead, he was literally grabbing plates underneath of me so the next family could sit down. I have never experienced anything like this and I can’t say I will be returning anytime soon.

My husband and I used to eat at this place ALL the time. The last time we went there, we saw that all the prices were raised and cuts were being made, the sandwiches we used to order all the time no longer come with fries. Sorry, but the way to please your customers is not to raise prices and give them less. Also, some of the wait staff is excellent and some are just horrible.

We use to go here at least once or twice a week– until we got the male waiter they have-​sooooooo rude– so then we tried take out– totally messed up order-​its a shame cause it wasn’t a bad place–

I gave this place 3 tries and every time the order was screwed up through take out.(I kept trying since its the closest to me). The pizza is the worst around far from brick oven the cheese is like rubber. When I called the other night to calmly complain the order is screwed up again the guy told me well what can I say mistakes happen and hung up.